Workers’ Representatives Part 1: No Union at Your Workplace? Who Represents Your Voice? [General Union]
You may have heard someone at work referred to as the “worker representative.” Maybe you’ve even seen their name on a document or been asked to vote for one. But what exactly are they representing you for?
Under Japanese labour law, there are certain procedures where someone needs to represent the worker side. If a union represents a majority of workers at the workplace, that majority union takes that role. But many workplaces don’t have a majority union. In that case, for certain procedures, the worker side is represented by a majority worker representative.
This person isn’t a union representative and doesn’t have the same powers as a union to negotiate wider changes to working conditions. Their job is much more specific: they represent the workers when particular procedures under labour law require it, and their authority is limited to those procedures.
A workplace doesn’t necessarily need someone permanently sitting in the role of majority worker representative. The representative is needed when a particular legal procedure requires someone to act for the worker side.
One of the most important examples is the Article 36 Agreement: Japanese law generally limits working hours to 8 hours a day and 40 hours a week. If an employer wants workers to work beyond those statutory limits or on statutory holidays, it generally needs a 36 Agreement with the worker side and must file it with the Labour Standards Inspection Office.
If there’s a majority union, the employer makes that agreement with the union. If there isn’t, the agreement is made with a properly selected majority worker representative.
The representative can also have a role when a company creates or changes its work rules. In that situation, the worker side is asked for its opinion. If there is no majority union, the majority worker representative gives that opinion on behalf of the workers.
So the basic idea is fairly simple:
Majority union → the union represents the worker side.
No majority union → a majority worker representative may represent the worker side for certain legal procedures.
It’s easy to look at the worker representative as just another name that needs to go on company paperwork, but it’s important to think about the 36 Agreement again.
The person representing the workers may be asked to agree to arrangements that allow the company to have employees work beyond the normal statutory working-hour limits. That’s more than just signing a form. Their agreement can affect how much overtime workers may be asked to do and how much of their personal time they get to keep.
And that raises some pretty important questions. Who chooses this person? Do the workers actually support them? Do they know what they’re being asked to agree to? Have they talked to the people they’re supposed to represent to get real feedback?
Worker representatives are also receiving increasing attention in discussions about Japan’s labour laws. The MHLW’s 2025 Study Group examined problems with the current majority-representative system, including how representatives are selected, what information they need, and how they gather workers’ views. There have also been discussions about the future role of workplace-level agreements and the circumstances in which employers may be allowed to depart from ordinary statutory rules. These discussions could have important consequences for workers, but the proposals have not automatically become law.
For now, though, there’s a much simpler place to start: Do you know who your majority worker representative is? And if you do, do you know how they were chosen?
And more importantly, if you don’t feel comfortable with this system, there is a way to change it. Workers can organize and grow their union within the workplace, and if the union comes to represent a majority of workers, the majority union takes on that worker-side role.
If you’d like to learn how to start building your union at work, check out our Individual Organizing Training.
Interested in increasing your union’s presence in the workplace? Join our Individual Organizing Training
Kanji of the Day: 車 [Kanji of the Day]
車
✍7
小1
car
シャ
くるま
自動車 (じどうしゃ) — car
自転車 (じてんしゃ) — bicycle
電車 (でんしゃ) — train
車両 (しゃりょう) — rolling stock
駐車場 (ちゅうしゃじょう) — parking lot
列車 (れっしゃ) — train
車内 (しゃない) — inside a car (train, bus, etc.)
乗用車 (じょうようしゃ) — car
車種 (しゃしゅ) — car model
新車 (しんしゃ) — new car
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Kanji of the Day: 項 [Kanji of the Day]
項
✍12
中学
paragraph, nape of neck, clause, item, term (expression)
コウ
うなじ
項目 (こうもく) — item
事項 (じこう) — matter
条項 (じょうこう) — clause
要項 (ようこう) — important points
注意事項 (ちゅういじこう) — things to note
重要事項 (じゅうようじこう) — important matter
優先事項 (ゆうせんじこう) — priority matter
前項 (ぜんこう) — preceding clause
留意事項 (りゅういじこう) — points to note
検索項目 (けんさくこうもく) — search item
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Wired Says ‘Please Let The Internet Die.’ Some Of Us Are Busy Building A Better One. [Techdirt]
It remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies absolutely do dominate much of the internet, and it’s close to impossible to avoid them entirely. But that doesn’t mean that that’s the entirety of the internet. And when you act as if it is, you do real damage to the good parts of the internet that still exist outside of the blast radius of those giants.
Five years ago, I wrote an article listing out a bunch of “other” internet websites, in the form of a “test suite” for anyone proposing internet regulations. Since most attempts to regulate the internet focus on the alleged (often not clearly proven) “harms” of one of the internet giants, I wanted people to think through the harm that these rules will do to the actual parts of the internet worth saving. These included forums and smaller shopping sites and web hosting and chat groups and more. It also included Wikipedia, which later picked up on the idea (I was told by someone there that this was partly inspired by my original article) and offered up “The Wikipedia Test.“
And yet, it seems difficult for people to remember this. It’s just so easy to bitch and moan that the internet now is just Meta and Google and Amazon and TikTok and (these days) OpenAI or whatever. And it leads to silly articles like Wired’s recent article Please Let the Internet Die.
But if you read through it, the entire article is about enshittifying internet giants, with the assumption that because they all suck, the rest of the internet should die as well.
Giants including Meta and Google have been forced to settle massive consumer lawsuits brought over privacy violations and mental health harms allegedly caused by the addictive mechanisms of their platforms. Schools are banning smartphones as multiple countries institute social media restrictions for under-16s. Parents are in a panic about their kids aspiring to careers as social media celebrities, losing themselves in a vast ecosystem of online casinos, or joining extremist movements.
Generative AI, briefly considered an amusing novelty, is now a turbocharged slop engine for the web, filling feeds and comment sections with useless, grotesque content. As humans scroll past headlines about AI taking their jobs, confusing fantasy for reality, and contributing to cognitive decline, any consumer appeal the technology might have is turning to anguish. The data centers that power it have become increasingly unpopular, and politically radioactive.
It is ridiculous to conclude that because some giant parts of the internet are enshittifying, there’s little worth saving in the rest of it. But that’s exactly where this article lands.
To be online, many now admit, is to be endlessly manipulated and exploited. In December, Oxford University Press declared rage bait to be the word of the year, noting that use of the term had tripled over the previous 12 months. The lexical spike represented a heightened awareness that monetized social accounts churn out bad-faith takes and extremist content, automating this abusive behavior with generative AI, simply to profit off hostile engagement. Billionaire oligarchs have opened the floodgates to such inauthentic activity, conspiracy-mongering, and hate speech by rolling back moderation.
In short, when you hang around online in 2026, you see little worth saving. Perhaps a decade ago, you felt that the glimmers of community and joy, of artistic and intellectual exchange, were enough to balance out the toxic junk. No longer.
But that’s bullshit. And, annoyingly, the folks at Wired should know that that’s bullshit. There are plenty of interesting parts of the internet that are still providing tremendous value. I’m obviously biased, but everything that’s been happening with ATprotocol in the last year has been incredible. Developers keep jumping in and building genuinely useful stuff — as just one example, an astronomer showed off software that streams time-critical data across the network to alert telescopes to supernovae — because anyone can just build things on open protocols. Just take a look at some of the many recaps of the Atmosphere Conference from earlier this year. People came out of it excited to build a new and better internet.
You can open up any of those links in the last two sentences and read about the excitement and the building, but I’ll just grab a bit from that last link:
The open web of the nineties didn’t win because the tools were better. It won because a critical mass of people decided that the alternative, a handful of AOL-style walled gardens choosing what everyone saw, was not the future they wanted. Then they built their way out of it. Slowly, unglamorously, in rooms that looked a lot like this one.
Whether atproto ends up being the thing, or a stepping stone to the thing, I don’t know. Nobody in the room claimed to know. But the work is real, the apps are shipping, and the people building them are taking it seriously without taking themselves seriously. That combination is rare, and historically, it’s the one that wins.
But if people just accept that “the internet needs to die,” we don’t get there. We get more stupid regulations that lock in those enshittifying giants and make it impossible to build a better internet.
The Wired piece is, in theory, a review of a new book called “The Internet Will Die,” which, at least as Wired presents it, frames the internet as fragile and doomed to cycles of decay, with big companies making things worse and deleting our digital histories along the way:
For one, West argues, people misperceive the “vastness” of the internet, which really amounts to “a vanishing fraction, a rounding error, of the human experience.” Moreover, it is remarkably fragile—West opens with the story of how a 2001 train derailment in a Baltimore tunnel took out a major bundle of fiber-optic cables, leading to internet slowdowns nationwide—and continually undergoes cycles of death and rebirth as a result of this natural instability.
If the internet is much smaller and less solid than imagined, West’s book suggests, then it’s crucial to recognize the forces that determine how those deaths unfold, or which pieces are preserved while others crumble. Because the market has falsely sold us the web as a comprehensive library of accumulated wisdom, each transient phase of this global network comes to define the present, for better and worse. Today we witness a dismal paralysis brought on by algorithmic incentives to churn out inflammatory garbage: Full-time influencers are in a losing arms race for attention with low-effort, high-volume channels that streamline production by delegating the creative process to bleeding-edge software.
But, again, that assumes an internet dominated by a handful of giants, the ones you hand all your data to, is the only internet possible.
But we already know that’s not true and it doesn’t need to be true in the future either. It sounds like West’s framing in his book is to encourage users to be more thoughtful about where they spend their time and energy online — and that’s great — but as Wired frames it, it’s all a wasteful endeavor since it’s always going to suck.
I certainly understand the fatalistic feeling that the internet sucks and will continue to suck. But that’s only true for people who lock themselves into the environments controlled by the internet giants you hate, rather than getting out and looking around at the cool things people are building which put the users in control of their own experience.
The piece ends with the author of the article, Miles Klee, admitting that the author of the book, John West, at least is open to the idea that a better internet can be created. But Klee, a self-described failed composter who’s “too lazy” for the gross work involved, doubts enough people will ever bother to do it.
“Look, the internet is rotting,” West says. “The question is, where are we going to put our energy?” A metaphor he often turns to in his book is compost. “Compost is just rot harnessed for a purpose,” he says. Can a decaying internet be fertilizer for something better? It’s a rosy notion, but speaking as a perennially failed composter—it’s just too gross, and I’m too lazy—I have my doubts about whether enough hardy, patient gardeners can be mobilized to make our digital landscape bloom once more.
And, again, I get the attitude, but I find this self-defeating nihilism to be pointless. The entire point of the internet, as Konstantinos Komaitis reminded us recently, is that it is unfinished. The internet is built on protocols that let anyone come in and build something better. Deciding we should just give up because some of the biggest players now suck is letting enshittification win.
The seeds of a better internet have already been planted. You can join Klee and Wired in doubting that enough gardeners will show up, but plenty of people are already out there digging. Come join us!
Tesla Starts ‘Selling’ Cybercabs You Can’t Buy With A $299/Month Automation Fee In Latest Ploy [Techdirt]
It’s pretty clear that Tesla doesn’t really want to make cars anymore. The company’s vehicle lineup is now full of dated relics, and it’s now discontinuing sales of the Cybertruck — arguably the biggest flop in automotive history. There was, of course, that recent demonstration of the nonexistent flying rocket-powered roadster, but that was generally stock-fluffing stagecraft aimed at dim children.
Instead, Musk envisions pivoting Tesla so it focuses more on AI and automation — despite the fact that the company’s AI systems aren’t profitable or particularly popular amidst a sea of better options, and many of Musk’s robotics and automation efforts mostly consist of hype, vaporware, or stuff that will never really see a mass commercial launch (like the nonexistent Optimum robot).
Speaking of hype, Tesla recently took to Elon Musk’s right wing propaganda website to announce that the company would soon be “selling” Cybercabs to consumers. According to the announcement, the Cybercab is being sold for $29,990 (before taxes and insurance). Plus a mandatory $299-a-month “Autonomy Subscription” charge:

Of course with everything Musk, the actual details matter. It’s invite only, meaning you won’t get one. Indeed it’s pretty clear that most people won’t actually be able to buy one. The car is only allowed to drive in a few cities (mainly, Austin, Texas), so you probably wouldn’t be able to actually drive the vehicle if you were actually able to buy one (which you won’t). And even if you happen to live in one of the zones where it currently can drive, you can’t leave those zones.
And the fine print indicates that on the off chance you actually get one (again, you won’t), you won’t be able to put the car to work as an automated taxi, despite Musk and Tesla’s earlier promises on this front:
“One of the biggest selling points of Musk’s 2024 “We, Robot” pitch was that regular people could buy a Cybercab and add it to Tesla’s Robotaxi network to earn passive income while they sleep or work. But the order terms explicitly prohibit owners from using the vehicle for commercial purposes — meaning no Uber, no DoorDash, and no putting it on Tesla’s own Robotaxi network to offset the $299/month fee. Tesla AI chief Ashok Elluswamy has floated Q2 2027 as a possible target for letting customer cars join the network, so early buyers are paying full freight with zero way to monetize the car.”
That $299 per month fee adds an additional $17,940 to the vehicle sticker price over five years. And the fine print indicates that Tesla reserves the right to charge you even more for automation, provided they give you a 30 day advanced warning. So the rich layers of bullshit are all very Musk.
There’s also the fact that these vehicles likely aren’t going to be very safe as the company conducts a glorified alpha test on public streets. Musk’s legendary decision to overrule his engineers on radar/lidar and go camera only for self-driving has already resulted in no shortage of human deaths. Meanwhile America’s safety regulators have been too corrupt, captured, or feckless to do anything about.
As it stands 278 Cybercabs are in operation in various cities. The NHTSA is purportedly investigating (for whatever good that’s worth) Tesla because the launch intentionally ignored public safety regulations governing vehicles without steering wheels. The agency also announced in 2025 that it had opened an inquiry into Musk robotaxis for failing to adhere to traffic laws and constant navigation mistakes.
While Tesla’s CFO insists the company wants to “literally take over every part of terrestrial transportation,” there’s very little indication that the company has the chops to fend off competitors and dominate the space. Most of what Musk now does is designed to prop up his fake supergenius engineer mythology, despite the ratio of bullshit to actual innovation becoming more and more lopsided.
So to prop up that mythology and goose comically inflated stock valuations, Musk is clearly keen on bundling and conflating Tesla’s increasingly stale vehicle lineup and “me too” automation and AI efforts with SpaceX’s actually innovative launch and Starlink technologies, and hoping the lion’s share of the press and public isn’t bright enough to notice the AI and automation stuff is low quality cack.
You can expect a Tesla and SpaceX merger in 2027 specifically for this reason.
It continues to say nothing good about America (or our media) how easily Elon Musk convinced the press and public he was a supergenius engineer who could cobble together complicated rocket machinery wearing coveralls in his backyard shed.
Hindsight continues to illustrate how Elon Musk’s real skill sets are opportunism, taking singular credit for the innovations of real engineers, the manipulation of a very broken media, and taking legal, regulatory, environmental, labor, and consumer protection “shortcuts” wherever possible.
Pluralistic: Lisa Hanawalt's "I Can't Stop Thinking About Horses and Sex" (20 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]
->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->
Top Sources:
None
-->

The title of animator Lisa Hanawalt's new graphic memoir I Can't Stop Thinking About Horses and Sex is a perfect encapsulation of the book's contents: a frank, self-aware, funny, horny, horsey exploration of Hanawalt's life, relationships, gender, and digestive issues:
https://drawnandquarterly.com/books/i-cant-stop-thinking-about-horses-and-sex/
Hanawalt is probably best known as the character designer for Bojack Horseman, but is also much loved in animation circles for her all-too-short-lived show Tuca & Bertie:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuca_%26_Bertie
She lived with the comedian/podcaster/showrunner Adam "Ruins Everything" Conover for 14 years, and the memoir revolves around the couple's breakup.
As the title promises, Hanawalt is also a lifelong horse-lover, who spent her childhood developing scars on her knees and calluses on the tops of her feet from endless all-fours sessions of pretending to be a horse. As an adult, she rides at the Los Angeles Equestrian Center, where she meets other horse people, who are beautifully depicted as the mix of posh sociopaths, obsessive animal-lovers, and lovable misfits (my daughter's middle school was around the corner from the LAEC and she grew up shoveling manure and tacking up at a teaching barn there; I can vouch for Hanawalt's faithful portrayal of the vibe).
Horses are Hanawalt's touchstone, the thing that brings her thoughts and emotions back into equilibrium, no matter what life throws at her. Eventually – inevitably – she acquires a horse, and just as inevitably, that horse proves to be her savior and her heartbreak. Horses are massive, majestic, impossibly powerful animals that are nevertheless forever on the verge of death, one weird disease or inexplicable fall from being maimed for life or keeling over.
The story of Hanawalt's pony Juni is intertwined with the story of her and Conover's breakup and her post-breakup relationships. Both threads of the tale are developed through beautiful, extremely funny, deeply personal vignettes that are brought to life by Hanawalt's art, which depicts bodies (animal, human, and animalistic human avatars) as hilarious, weird, and sexy all at once.
These two motifs criss-cross as we journey through Hanawalt's dating life, her childhood sexual trauma, her IBS, and her fears and hopes about her fertility (two of the major subplots involve Hanawalt's experiences with egg-freezing and bowel problems, and the way that the medical system treats women).
Hanawalt has a gift for compact, revealing character studies that leave the reader feeling both warm affection and exasperation with everyone in her life (including Hanawalt herself). It's a world without heroes and villains, where flaws and virtues are almost always flip-sides of the same coin. Everyone is crazy sometimes, including Hanawalt, and Hanawalt is self-aware enough to know when she's getting in her own way, and even why that happens, and also (just like all of us) can't always stop herself from tripping herself up.
Hanawalt's written and drawn a wise, funny, horny book that wrings comedy and insight out of trauma and melancholy. It's a gorgeous read that lingers.
Hanawalt isn't the only person who made smart, funny media out of her and Conover's breakup. Conover's comedy special about the breakup and its aftermath is called "Big Divorce Energy" and it was released the same week that Can't Stop Thinking hit the shelves:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVB-SUX7zgk
I saw Conover perform this set live and it was terrific – and it got even better by the time he recorded it for the special. It makes for a perfect bookend for Hanawalt's memoir, a fact that both Conover and Hanawalt affirm in a lovely, warm conversation they recorded for Conover's Factually podcast. It's an interview that raises the bar for the kind of affection and even love a mature couple can salvage from a breakup:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUXEDUiICM4
The book itself is from Montreal's Drawn and Quarterly, who have a well-deserved reputation for publishing quality graphic novels, especially memoirs. D&Q always puts together a beautiful physical artifact, and Can't Stop Thinking is no exception: a handsome hardcover with luxurious, thick semi-matte pages and a bookmark ribbon sewn into the binding. It's the perfect gift for any friend going through a breakup (or thinking about buying a horse).

Anthropic’s Meh Debut https://prospect.org/2026/11/20/anthropic-debut-ipo-stock-market-sec/
#25yrsago They Fight Crime https://web.archive.org/web/20011204174257/http://www.rain-street.org/fightcrime.htm
#20yrsago GeekCorps builds cantenna WiFi TV network in Mali https://web.archive.org/web/20061213100911/http://www.geekcorps.org/2006/11/the-geekcorps-cantv/
#15yrsago Britain’s Occupy movement picks up steam https://web.archive.org/web/20131001063502/https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/nov/19/occupy-london-protesters-ideas-bank
#10yrsago Word of the day: Kakistocracy http://jury.me/blog/2016/11/19/kakistocracy
#5yrsago Inflation or price-gouging? https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/20/quiet-part-out-loud/#profiteering
#1yrago The long game https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/20/if-you-wanted-to-get-there/#i-wouldnt-start-from-here

Sheffield: Reverse Centaur at Juno Books, Nov 25
https://www.outsavvy.com/event/40274/cory-doctorow-in-conversation
Virtual: Enshittification, AI, and the Future of Technology (UBC Master of Educational Technology), Nov 28
https://met.ubc.ca/2026/09/met-speaker-series-cory-doctorow-enshittification-ai-and-the-future-of-technology/
Oxford: Bennett Oxford Symposium on Open Code in Science, Dec 9
https://www.bennett.ox.ac.uk/events/2026-bennett-institute-symposium/
Santa Barbara: UCSB Reads, Apr 29
https://www.library.ucsb.edu/events-exhibitions/ucsb-reads-2027-presents-author-cory-doctorow
Montreal: World Science Fiction Convention, Sep 2-6
https://montreal2027.ca/en
How AI is Breaking the Internet (and Everything Else) (Blood in the Machine)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXRaPjFRyT0
Clint Eastwood (No Gods No Mayors)
https://www.patreon.com/NoGodsNoMayors/posts/clint-eastwood-173008088
Life After AI (Brain Bar)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPPa43-n0vI
Terms of Service with Clare Duffy (CNN)
https://www.cnn.com/audio/podcasts/terms-of-service-with-clare-duffy/episodes/458ce968-af5d-11f0-b539-13ed2afe25f8
"Canny Valley": A limited edition collection of the collages I create for Pluralistic, self-published, September 2025 https://pluralistic.net/2025/09/04/illustrious/#chairman-bruce
"Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, October 7 2025
https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374619329/enshittification/
"Picks and Shovels": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about the heroic era of the PC, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2025 (https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865908/picksandshovels).
"The Bezzle": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about prison-tech and other grifts, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2024 (thebezzle.org).
"The Lost Cause:" a solarpunk novel of hope in the climate emergency, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), November 2023 (http://lost-cause.org).
"The Internet Con": A nonfiction book about interoperability and Big Tech (Verso) September 2023 (http://seizethemeansofcomputation.org). Signed copies at Book Soup (https://www.booksoup.com/book/9781804291245).
"Red Team Blues": "A grabby, compulsive thriller that will leave you knowing more about how the world works than you did before." Tor Books http://redteamblues.com.
"Chokepoint Capitalism: How to Beat Big Tech, Tame Big Content, and Get Artists Paid, with Rebecca Giblin", on how to unrig the markets for creative labor, Beacon Press/Scribe 2022 https://chokepointcapitalism.com
"Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027
"Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027
"The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027
Today's top sources:
Currently writing:
"The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.
A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING

This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.
Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
https://pluralistic.net/plura-list
Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):
https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net
Medium (no ads, paywalled):
Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):
https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic
"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla
READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
ISSN: 3066-764X
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 13 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 14 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 15 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
| Picture of the day |
|---|
Véu da Noiva Waterfall, Seixal, Madeira, Portugal
|
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 17 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
| Picture of the day |
|---|
Photographic art “Witches’ Dance Trilogy” (based on a view of the buoys at the buoy yard in Norderney, Lower Saxony, Germany)
|
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 18 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
| Picture of the day |
|---|
Dusk at St. Peter's Basilica, Vittorio-Emmanuele II bridge, and Tiber river in Rome, Italy. The Catholic Church celebrates the Dedication of the Basilicas of Saints Peter and Paul today.
|
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 19 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 20 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
| Picture of the day |
|---|
Trail from Andiast to Breil-Brigels. Bad weather in the Breil-Brigels region, but it has now dried up.
|
‘Absurd’: Private Torrent Trackers Still Don’t Know Who Sued Them as Plaintiff Skips Hearing [TorrentFreak]
Last month, the person litigating as Matthew Schneider was ordered to prove his identity to an Illinois federal court.
The self-proclaimed filmmaker had already dropped his copyright lawsuit against several private torrent trackers, but two of the Doe defendants are seeking sanctions against him.
The plaintiff was supposed to email his passport, driver’s license and Copyright Office paperwork to the courtroom deputy by October 9. However, he didn’t and instead offered to show one apostilled UK ID to the judge alone.
On Tuesday, Judge Andrea R. Wood planned to ask him what had changed his mind, but she never got the chance to do so as the plaintiff didn’t show.
The status hearing was scheduled for 11 AM Chicago time, by video. The courtroom deputy called for the plaintiff twice, but he didn’t appear, on video or by phone. The court also emailed him, without response. After about twenty minutes the hearing started anyway.
“We waited long enough to account for any reasonable delay,” Judge Wood said.
At a video hearing last month Schneider did appear, but by phone only, citing technical difficulties on his end. This time, Judge Wood asked him to test his video connection with the court in advance, but that also didn’t happen.
Judge Wood did not jump to conclusions and gave him one week to explain in writing why he failed to appear. If he doesn’t respond, he forfeits the ability to seek discovery, and his own proposed discovery requests won’t go out either.
At the hearing, defense attorney Erin Russell, who represents Doe #1, argued that the pending discovery requests should move forward as soon as possible. This, because some information, including IP-address logs, is only retained for a limited time.
“It’s absurd that we are conducting discovery to figure out who the plaintiff in this lawsuit really is,” Russell said.
The third-party subpoenas the defense proposed last month are the way to find that out, she argued. These include one to the PACER Service Center, for the IP addresses the plaintiff used to access the court’s website. Russell also pointed to the plaintiff’s mail-drop address in Sanborn, New York, which may hold records of where his mail is forwarded.
While Schneider must prove his identity, the tracker operators remain anonymous. Judge Wood directed them to file their identities with the court under seal, a routine step for parties litigating under a pseudonym, and she said she will consider whether anonymous defendants can seek sanctions at all.
The judge offered no guarantees, but she noted that the plaintiff’s absence makes it harder to justify giving him the defendants’ real names, particularly while he isn’t appearing to defend the sanctions motion.
The defense will also draft a protective order covering whatever discovery reveals about the plaintiff’s identity and address, something both sides agreed to in October.
The hearing was also meant to settle the discovery requests both sides filed in October. The plaintiff’s questions came in four days late and turned the tables on the defense. Among other things, he asked the tracker attorneys to admit that they contacted the judge’s chambers to delay rulings, and that they never viewed his “Do Us Part” film before filing the sanctions motion.
The defense objected to all these requests. In its objections, Doe #1 also mentioned that the film the plaintiff submitted as evidence in September “appears to have been created using generative AI technology and does not qualify as an ‘audiovisual’ submission.”

Doe #10 added that the plaintiff has yet to provide evidence for the ten works he sued over. “Plaintiff has not produced a registration certificate, application, or deposit copy for any of them,” the filing reads.
Judge Wood will address these discovery requests in a written order.
For now, the mystery of who sued the trackers continues. The next hearing is set for December 17, in person this time, and the judge noted that the cost of showing up in Chicago may be part of what the defense tries to recover.
—
Doe #1’s proposed discovery requests and third-party subpoenas are available here (pdf). The plaintiff’s proposed discovery requests are available here (pdf), with the objections from Doe #1 (pdf) and Doe #10 (pdf). The plaintiff’s objections to the defense’s requests can be found here (pdf). TorrentFreak listened in to the hearing by telephone and the coverage of the hearing is based on our notes.
From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.
You Can’t Rebrand This [The Status Kuo]
It’s as gross as it was predictable. Appearing by video Wednesday at The New York Times’ DealBook Summit from China, where he is traveling with Donald Trump’s delegation, Elon Musk declared, “I’m not MAGA.”
That’s funny. I distinctly remember Musk bounding onstage to stand beside Trump in Butler, Pennsylvania, just weeks before the 2024 election, wearing a black MAGA cap. Then he jumped up and down and nearly blinded us with his belly, leaving the world with the other image we’ll forever remember him by.
Back then, Musk openly declared, “As you can see, I’m not just MAGA — I am Dark MAGA.”
Now it’s, haha, just kidding, guys. Learn to take a joke, yeah? I’m not MAGA at all now!
This rebrand won’t stick because we won’t allow it. He is forever the Elon Musk who ran DOGE for the Trump regime. The same Elon Musk who flooded social media with white supremacy and took Russia’s side by throttling Starlink service for Ukraine. The same Elon Musk who blew nearly half a billion dollars on extreme MAGA candidates in the midterms.
Lately, things have turned sadly comical. His Election Day tweet, “Vote red today!” seems to have vanished from his X account, along with a pinned call to elect Republican senators that came down after Democrat James Talarico claimed victory in the Texas Senate race, as Forbes reported. (Asked whether its owner had been deleting posts, Musk’s own chatbot Grok threw him under the bus and answered “True.”)
Fifteen days after the election, Musk is deep in his feels—“pretty foolish” about “having spent so much money and not seeing much for it.”
We agree. But if his candidates had won, “Dark MAGA” Musk would have been leaping around Trump like an idiot again. Today, with his allies routed across the land, even in his adopted home state of Texas, Musk has to come down from his high and live in reality.
He’s not going to like it.
Buyer’s remorse, half a billion later
Musk spent at least $445 million supporting Republican candidates and conservative PACs this cycle, according to the campaign finance watchdog OpenSecrets.
His record is less than exemplary. Just three of the 43 House Republicans he backed won their races, while 33 lost, Reuters found, with the remaining yet uncalled. He bankrolled losing campaigns in Texas, Maine, Ohio, Michigan and Alaska. (By contrast, if I may boast a bit, the Human Rights Campaign, whose board of directors I chair, won every hotly contested race we backed with our far more modest but hard-earned $15 million, and we posted a 94.4 percent win rate for our endorsed LGBTQ+ federal candidates.)
Musk’s electoral plans exploded on the launch pad like a SpaceX rocket. He said his goal had been a 51-seat Republican Senate majority through 2029, an effort that “failed, by the way, obviously.” More broadly, he had wanted Republicans to hold the House, the Senate or the presidency in 2029 and to prevent a Democratic supermajority. He also said he opposes a Republican supermajority, even though he moved to Texas to live under one.
A lot of money can go into an election, Musk told Andrew Ross Sorkin, and “have an effect that is relatively minor.” (Narrator: Dude just proved that.)
Given the chance to do it all over, Musk conceded he would have spent less. In the same breath, he hedged, saying without that money, “maybe it would have been much worse.”
Much worse than losing not only every Senate battleground race, but also deep-red seats in Mississippi, Kansas and South Carolina?
I’m also dubious of his claim that he would have spent less knowing what he knows now. He didn’t learn his lesson after Wisconsin’s state Supreme Court election last year, so why assume he’ll learn one from the midterms?
On not being MAGA, Musk said he wasn’t sure what the term means, but if it means “sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party,” he doesn’t have that.
What he has instead is a long record of supporting Trump on the trail, sporting MAGA gear, calling himself “Dark MAGA,” funneling hundreds of millions to MAGA candidates and taking a chainsaw to the federal government in service of Project 2025. His cuts to USAID alone left hundreds of thousands of children projected to die of starvation and disease. He left a trail of death and ruin and now wants to pretend it never happened.
Nope. Blue America remembers.
Dark MAGA goes dark
The DealBook stage has hosted earlier iterations of Musk. In 2023, he used it to tell advertisers who had left X, “Go fuck yourself.” It was a clear sign he had turned from annoying to arrogant, a man willing to burn everything down to own the libs.
And for a man unsure what MAGA means, he’s sure talked it up. A Trump loss, he warned the Butler crowd in October 2024, would make that year’s vote “the last election.” By Madison Square Garden three weeks later, the brand had been upgraded to “dark, gothic MAGA.”
Musk has promised to pull back before, only to return with more money than ever.
In May 2025, he told the Qatar Economic Forum he would do “a lot less” political spending: “I think I’ve done enough.” After his falling-out with Trump, he touted the ill-fated America Party in July, his brief, fizzling answer to a “one-party system.” By New Year’s Day 2026, he was tweeting for Republicans again: “America is toast if the radical left wins.”
Then came the $445 million this year. It was to be his second expensive lesson in what money cannot buy.
Cheese, checks and a 10-point loss
Wisconsin voters had tried to tell him how this would go 19 months earlier.
The April 2025 contest for a state Supreme Court seat matched liberal Susan Crawford against conservative Brad Schimel, a Trump-backed judge who campaigned in a MAGA hat. More than $21 million from Musk and allied groups went toward beating Crawford. Musk may have had a personal interest in the outcome: Tesla was challenging the state’s refusal to license its dealerships under a law barring automakers from owning them, a case that could have reached the very court whose swing seat he was hoping to secure.
The money he threw around soon became a grotesque display that backfired badly. Two voters at his Green Bay rally on March 30 left holding oversized $1 million checks. One of them, according to his social media profile, turned out to chair the Wisconsin College Republicans. What a coincidence!
The checks struck Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul as a “blatant attempt” at election bribery, and he went to court. But the state’s justices declined to hear the case.
In the end, Musk’s money became a liability. The race became a referendum on outside and outsized influence. Crawford won by about 10 points.
Paxton’s patron
But Musk never learns. He waded into the midterm fray with his hundreds of millions, which in the Lone Star State meant backing state Attorney General Ken Paxton. This MAGA darling came with some Texas-sized baggage, including a 2023 impeachment by a Republican-run Texas House, a felony securities fraud indictment that shadowed him for nearly nine years, a federal corruption investigation and adultery allegations from his wife, state Sen. Angela Paxton.
Worried about Paxton’s standing in the race, Musk’s political team reached out to the GOP’s Senate Leadership Fund. A $75 million check from Musk arrived on Sept. 9, and $83 million more came two weeks later. All of it passed through a new outfit called Texas PAC. By election night, Musk accounted for more than $200 million of the $280 million Republicans spent on advertising in the race.
Replaying a 2024 greatest hit, an ad from the Musk-funded Texas PAC declared Talarico was for “they/them, not you.” Musk also pitched in on X, amplifying a false story that Talarico had suffered a mental breakdown and checked into an Ohio mental health center. Musk tweeted that the Talarico campaign was “hiding something big.” The clinic replied that Talarico had never been a patient.
Talarico, a 37-year-old former middle school teacher, destroyed Paxton despite Musk’s hundreds of millions and became the first Texas Democrat sent to the Senate since 1988. On The View, he relayed the voters’ message to Musk: “Texas is not for sale.”
Howdy, governor
The warmest words from Musk during the interview went, surprise, surprise, to Texas Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa, the Democrat who unseated Gov. Greg Abbott. Musk predicted (wishcasted?) that she would be “quite moderate” and declared Texas would be fine under her.
So, 10½ months after warning that America was “toast” if the radical left won, he has decided the left’s new governor of Texas is reasonable. But she likely won’t forget that in the campaign’s final stretch, he was still shelling out money to keep her out of the job. Musk alone supplied nearly one-fifth of Abbott’s last fundraising haul.
Texas was supposed to be Musk’s safe space. He moved there in December 2020 after months of fighting California officials over pandemic rules. Tesla’s headquarters followed, announced at a 2021 shareholder meeting inside the Austin factory. SpaceX and X came in July 2024, after California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a law on student gender identity that Musk called the “final straw.” Abbott’s welcome tweet promised the move “cements Texas as the leader in space exploration.”
Abbott showered Musk with sweetheart deals. More than $1.6 billion in tax incentives for Musk’s companies ran through the governor’s office, which Hinojosa is about to occupy.
Hinojosa is proving less inclined toward such generosity. Her victory speech targeted Musk without naming him, asking whether Texas belongs to people “who write the biggest check to politicians in Austin.” Days after the election, a possible sale of Boca Chica State Park to SpaceX was shelved at her request until she is sworn in. Data centers’ free run of Texas, she told CNN, “stops when I’m governor.”
The irony is hard to miss. The man who fled one blue state now needs to plead with the newest member of the Blue Crew. Tesla is seeking state incentives for a proposed $10 billion solar cell plant near Houston. Solar is nice, but Texas no longer needs to mortgage its future to Tesla to have nice things.
Texas Democrats may have more than incentives on their minds. Reports of SpaceX and xAI breaking agreements and laws, from building in a wildlife refuge to dumping trash in state parks, deserve a serious investigation. State Rep. Gene Wu, a Houston Democrat and former felony prosecutor, made that case on NewsNation last week.
Nobody ever trusted Musk
If there’s one thing MAGA understands, it is self-interest. During a December 2024 fight over H-1B visas, Laura Loomer declared that Musk “is not MAGA and never has been.” Two months later, Steve Bannon’s forecast on CNN for the tech billionaires around Trump was that “they’re with us, but only temporarily.”
When Musk began openly feuding with Trump, Democrats shut the door on any chance of his crossing over. Rep. Greg Casar (D-TX) told Axios that embracing him would amount to “shooing more working class voters away.”
But Musk isn’t the only oligarch finding himself in the political wilderness.
Alex Karp runs Palantir, a company that saw its federal contract haul nearly double to $970.5 million in Trump’s first year back. Karp himself branded his company “completely anti-woke.” Yet eight days after the election, Politico found a changed and chastened man! He said he was open to backing a Democrat in 2028, insisting that “all of our products are essentially progressive.” (Among those products is the surveillance platform behind ICE deportations.)
Meta’s Mark Zuckerberg began moving leftward before any votes were counted. Two weeks ahead of the election came word that Joel Kaplan, the adviser who built Meta’s relationship with Trump’s White House, was on his way out. Then, as if on cue, a bipartisan team of Washington veterans, assembled to deepen Meta’s ties with Democrats, took shape days before the vote.
A $1 million personal pledge to Trump’s inauguration fund bought Sam Altman his place at the table. On election night, he tweeted that people “should not cede control of the future to superintelligence.” The Guardian compared it to something Bernie Sanders would say.
Musk and his ilk want us to accept the transactional nature of their relationship to power, but they should study history to better understand where Trump’s “Golden Age” is headed. After the Gilded Age came the Progressive Era, when the Supreme Court ordered Standard Oil broken up, J.P. Morgan’s railroad trust was dissolved and the railroads were brought under federal regulation. With a trifecta within reach in 2028, Democrats should be prepared to deliver a similar blow to the tech oligarchs.
As for Musk? May he rot alone in his own private heil.
Bill Cassidy, Who Got RFK Jr. Confirmed As Sec. Of HHS, Calls For Him To Be Fired [Techdirt]
So there’s no misunderstanding, let’s start this post with the following: fuck Bill Cassidy.
This simpering, boot-licking, about-to-be-former-senator was the key vote in the confirmation hearings for RFK Jr.’s appointment as Secretary of HHS. Seen as a serious person with a background in the medical profession, his vote was essentially permission for enough other GOP votes to get Kennedy across the finish line. And if you don’t understand by now just how calamitous Kennedy’s tenure has been at HHS, then you’re so far lost that you’re unrecoverable. It’s been a disaster.
Despite trying to lick Trump’s boots ever since he voted to convict during Trump’s second impeachment trial, Dear Leader never forgives and never forgets. As a result, Cassidy was rewarded for his trouble by getting primaried out of his reelection campaign thanks to Trump’s endorsement of his opponent. In the wake of his failure to get reelected, Cassidy suddenly found portions of his spine once more. He suddenly realized that RFK Jr. is bad and sucks at his job. He flipped his previous vote to a “no” in a failed Senate bill to end Trump’s military adventures in the Middle East.
And now, with only a few weeks left in the office from which he’s been booted, Cassidy is, for the very first time, calling for Kennedy to be fired.
After former White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles was let go, Kennedy boasted that the Senate “no longer has any leverage over me” as Stephen Miller is now in the role.
CBS’s “Face the Nation” host Margaret Brennan asked Cassidy on Sunday to respond to these remarks.
“Well, first, he’s obviously trying to provide cover for failure as Secretary of Health and Human Services. He was supposed to be doing something positive on ultra-processed foods. That’s what MAHA moms wanted. There’s been minimal progress, and now we’ve lost our measles elimination status, and we have infants dying from measles,” said Cassidy.
“There is no logic. This is about covering a series of failures,” he added.
I could say the very same about this call to fire Kennedy, Senator. You put him there! You are what allowed these failures to occur. You were the very first potential firewall against children getting sick and dying from measles, from cyclosporiasis ravaging the GI tracts of Americans, from the bullshit about Tylenol causing autism, the chemtrails, and so on. You failed in your role during the confirmation hearings. You failed to live up to the Hippocratic oath you took as a doctor. You failed to properly hold Kennedy accountable once he was in his role as Secretary.
While expressing dismay over Kennedy’s actions as recently as August, saying it was “pretty evident” that the secretary had lied about his plans to change the vaccine schedule, Cassidy avoided expressing any regret over his decision.
A series of failures, attempted to be papered over by a call for Kennedy to be fired that came far, far too late to be of any use. It is time for you to go home and do whatever it is you’re going to do now that you’ll be out of elected office.
And, with any luck, the new Congress will fix the problem you created.
Why Fewer People Are Challenging Bad Patents [Techdirt]
The number of petitions being filed at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) has collapsed. That’s not reason for celebration. The PTAB is an important line of defense against low-quality software patents being used in lawsuits against people and companies.
The drop didn’t happen because suddenly patents have become higher quality. It’s simply because USPTO leadership is increasingly refusing to consider good challenges to patents, for reasons unrelated to the merits. The process has become so unreliable that many would-be patent challengers aren’t even trying.
Inter partes review (IPR) is a process that allows people to challenge patents at the Patent Office, rather than having to fight an expensive lawsuit in federal court. It’s one of the most important ways to get bad patents out of the system.
In the third quarter of 2026, July through September, only 97 IPR petitions were filed at the PTAB, compared to 327 petitions during the same period in 2025. Similarly, only 37 IPR petitions were filed in September 2026, compared to 129 petitions in December 2024—the last full month before the current USPTO leadership began reshaping how the Board handles patent challenges.
This dramatic decline shouldn’t just concern patent lawyers. EFF has fought bad patents because so many software and internet patents make claims to the basic tools of free expression online, like sending email, using online ads, or publishing web pages. When bad patents go unchallenged, they affect everyone who cares about the freedom to write new code and make new technology.
That’s why EFF has defended IPR since it came on the scene more than a decade ago. It provides a faster and less expensive way to challenge patents that should never have been granted. Congress created IPRs because the Patent Office makes mistakes. District court litigation is an extraordinarily expensive way to correct them. Without a meaningful administrative review process, bad patents remain powerful weapons in the hands of patent trolls and others seeking to extract settlements from companies that often did nothing wrong.
Now, USPTO leadership is dismantling that safeguard.
Since Congress created the IPR patent challenge process in 2012, the PTAB has always had some discretion in deciding which petitions deserve review. But institution rates today are much lower than their typical historical range.
Between fiscal years 2022 and 2024, the PTAB instituted between 66% and 68% of IPR petitions. In fiscal year 2026, which concluded in September 2026, the institution rate fell to 41%. And institution is only the first step of an IPR—it means the PTAB has agreed to hear the challenge, not that the challenger won, and the patent will be invalidated.
That decline helps explain why fewer petitions are being filed in the first place. Preparing an IPR petition takes substantial time and money. While cheaper than federal court, it’s still a complicated administrative process. Before filing, a challenger typically needs to search for prior art, hire experts, and develop detailed technical and legal arguments about why the patent never should have been granted.
Companies were willing to pay for IPRs because, historically, they could expect a predictable process. Petitions that met the statutory standard generally had a reasonable prospect of being heard and decided on the merits. But the USPTO has made it harder to get petitions heard and is throwing them out for reasons that have nothing to do with the merits of the challenges. Faced with these odds, many potential challengers aren’t filing at all.
When the PTAB decides to hear an IPR case, that means the petition has been “instituted”—but that has never meant that the petitioner will definitely win. It means the PTAB has determined the challenge warrants a full merits review, and the parties could expect the proceeding to continue toward a final written decision. But under the current USPTO leadership, that expectation has disappeared. The PTAB’s institution decisions are being repeatedly vacated by the Director.
USPTO Director John Squires has vacated at least 29 decisions granting institution of IPR proceedings, and subsequently denied the petitions, terminating those proceedings before a final written decision. These include cases that PTAB judges had already agreed to hear, as well as proceedings that Squires himself had previously allowed to proceed. This level of retroactive intervention is unprecedented.
In some cases, the parties had already invested substantial time and money litigating before the PTAB, only to have the proceeding terminated based on new reasoning by the Director’s office that arose after institution.
For example, in Revvo Technologies v. Cerebrum Sensor Technologies, the Director vacated an institution decision and remanded the case to the Board. The Board then instituted review again, but the Director reversed that decision. Using a new approach, the Director said that the petition had inconsistencies between claim construction positions taken before the PTAB and in district court. Since then, that decision has been cited as a basis for terminating several other instituted proceedings.
The result is another layer of uncertainty for people who want to challenge bad patents. Getting through the front door of an institution decision is much harder than it used to be—and now, even getting through that door doesn’t mean the PTAB will decide your challenge. Predictability is one of the things that made IPRs work.
Congress created IPRs in part because challenging a questionable patent in federal court is enormously expensive and risky. Patent examiners work under serious time constraints, and some patents that shouldn’t have been granted will inevitably issue. Not every patent dispute requires years of expensive district court litigation. Congress recognized that, and created an administrative process, staffed with experts more capable of correcting those mistakes.
That system has benefited the public. Since 2012, it has helped invalidate thousands of patent claims that never should have been issued. The IPR process has protected startups, software developers, nonprofits, and small businesses that otherwise would have faced crushing litigation costs simply for building products or offering services that use everyday internet technology.
EFF supports a balanced IPR system because it should be easier to fight against bogus patents that should never have been issued. The cost of fighting a patent can be a weapon in itself, and weak patents don’t just burden large technology companies. Patent trolls routinely target small businesses and independent developers, and have gone after podcasters, retailers, and even coffee shops and nonprofits. These organizations have neither the resources nor the desire to spend years litigating over potentially invalid patents in federal court. IPR offers a chance to challenge those patents before litigation costs get out of control.
If we weaken the IPR system, bad patents become much harder and more expensive to challenge.
Some defenders of the current approach argue that lower institution rates reflect more balance in the patent system. But institution rates at the PTAB have plummeted from 68% to 41% in just two years—a nearly 40% decline. IPR petition filings have reached historic lows. And even proceedings that have already been instituted can now be terminated months later, without a decision on the merits.
These developments send a troubling message to members of the public who might want to use the PTAB: don’t bother. The PTAB doesn’t need to institute every petition. But it does need to provide a process that is transparent, predictable, and fair. Right now, confidence in the system is disappearing.
If companies, individuals, and nonprofits conclude that IPRs aren’t worth pursuing, the consequences won’t stop at the PTAB. More weak patents that never should have been granted will survive, and patent trolls will use them. That means more defendants facing expensive district court litigation or paying settlements driven by the cost of litigation.
That’s not what Congress intended when it created IPRs. It should not become the PTAB’s “new normal.”
Reposted from the EFF’s Deeplinks blog.
Court Tells Cops That The 4th Amendment Doesn’t Cover AI-Generated ‘Probable Cause’ [Techdirt]
I don’t know where this decision will take us, but its implications reach much further than the single case it covers. AI is pretty much everywhere, and if a court says an algorithm can’t make probable cause determinations, it affects/infects everything from facial recognition tech to predictive policing software to Axon adding AI shovelware to its omnipresent body cameras under the (correct) assumption cops don’t like writing reports.
In this case, Alain Osorio was arrested for allegedly passing a bad check at local bank. The only pictures of the suspect came from the bank’s CCTV footage. This was handed over to Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence (KY) Police Department.
The detective decided to run a screenshot of the suspect’s face (derived from the CCTV footage) through the PD’s facial recognition program. The decision [PDF] doesn’t specify which facial recognition program was used, but given that the match was made using photos found on Facebook, it suggests Clearview AI might have been involved, given its scraping of hundreds of billions of images from the open web since its inception.
Not that it did anything useful in terms of actual detective work. Nor did it do anything remotely constitutional, not when the operative word in “probable cause” is “probable.”
Relying solely on the AI identification, Detective Kilmer concluded that the match was accurate. [Id. at 4–5]. The Facebook profile belonged to an individual known as “Yony Smith Npoles Charon,” and for an unknown reason, Detective Kilmer concluded that “Yony” was actually Alain Vizcay Osorio—the man in the booking photo.
The court says “for an unknown reason.” I can make an educated guess, however. Passing a bad check is the sort of crime most cops won’t really dig into. Detective Kilmer was handed the case and did the bare minimum: he ran an AI-assisted search. He didn’t actually do anything that resembled actual detective work. But he still felt his 30 seconds of non-existent effort were enough to support a criminal complaint and the issuance of an arrest warrant.
Osorio — who lived in Nebraska — was arrested and extradited to Kentucky to face criminal charges. He was released on bond the day after his arrest (January 24, 2025). He was then indicted by a grand jury in March 2025 and arraigned roughly two months later. Again, Osorio pleaded not guilty. At that point, the state’s attorney’s office dismissed the charges after Osorio provided proof he had been working in Nebraska at the time the bad check was being passed by (the presumably still at-large) suspect captured by the bank’s security camera.
The only thing the AI used by the detective seemed to be capable of doing was reinforcing the investigator’s “all Black people look the same” prejudices. (To be clear, I don’t specifically know if this detective has these prejudices, but the chain of events in this case certainly support an assumption of this person’s assumptions, if you catch my drift.)
The individuals in the security footage and the Facebook profile image do not resemble the booking photo of Osorio. [Id. at 6–7]. Based on the booking photo, the only thing Osorio has in common with the suspect is that he is a black male with facial hair. [Dkt. 3-1 at 2–3]. Based on the photographs, it appears that Osorio has a different head shape, different haircut, different facial features, and different complexion.
Detective Kilmer told the court (via his affidavit) that he had used “investigative tools” to “match” Osario to the suspect. In reality, the court says, Kilmer only used a single tool and rolled with its obviously faulty conclusions despite Florence PD policy specifically stating facial recognition AI alone is not enough to “establish probable cause.”
Kilmer runs directly into this policy and the Fourth Amendment itself, which poses multiple problems for his desire to walk away fiscally intact from this lawsuit. The policy is undeniable, which means Kilmer deliberately ignored his “training” and any “expertise” it was supposed to impart.
But beyond that, there’s the Fourth Amendment itself, which can’t as easily be ignored as cop shop software clickwrap. That much is made perfectly clear in the court’s introductory paragraph:
The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution does not allow a detective to delegate to AI the task of assessing probable cause. In other words, the Fourth Amendment does not permit an individual to be arrested based on nothing more than an uncorroborated conclusion by AI that the individual in question has committed a crime. And no reasonable detective in the Defendant’s position could conclude otherwise.
The first part of that suggests implications far beyond this case, given how often “detectives” are letting their fingers do the walking (so to speak) and pretending whatever the computer coughs up is arrest-worthy. That’s not just the facial recognition tech used in this case. This is also the AI that steers patrols and public interactions via so-called “predictive policing.” That’s also the AI that writes reports for police officers, allowing the computer to create the permanent, official record of stops, arrests, and uses of force.
But what’s also important is the last sentence of that paragraph. That’s the thing that’s going to make this stick. The detective isn’t shielded by qualified immunity, which means this is sure to be appealed. But if this officer does this (rather than “allow” the people who he’s supposed to be serving to buy him out of a lawsuit via a settlement), he’s going to make this an appellate case. And there’s definitely no reason to assume the higher court is just going to blow off the obvious concerns raised by this lawsuit and allow QI to cover up this compendium of wrongs.
For now, the decision stands as it is: AI isn’t probable cause. Never has been. Never should be. And if this court has anything to say about it, it never will be. Detectives who prefer to let computers do their thinking for them might want to dial back their reliance on algorithms. Justice should never be subject to available processing power. And if you lack the desire (or intelligence!) to do detective work properly, well…

ICE Adds A New Layer Of Cruelty By Deliberately Hiding The Current Locations Of Detained Migrants [Techdirt]
No one in this administration is worth saving. You could just put them all on a boat and sink it in a ocean and only the publisher still waiting to recoup the advance on a “Hillbilly Elegy” sequel will shed any tears.
The administration got its ass kicked in the mid-terms. And while Trump had very little coherence to offer while it was happening, he’s back in the driver’s seat again. For now. The ghoul traveling in Trump’s orbit has been elevated to Chief of Staff. Stephen Miller — who actively embodies the Nazi-ism he wants to see in the world — has even more power, now that he’s officially a high-ranking staff member.
The rest of the administration is similarly under pressure to produce results, especially now that at the stroke of Midnight 2027, it will no longer control the House or the Senate. While this latest update on administration awfulness predates the mid-terms (but just barely), rest assured it will be amplified, abused, and otherwise exploited to ensure maximum evil until it becomes something the government seeks to rein in, rather than simply something the Trump administration can deploy without fear of reprisal.
There are lots of things we already know about Trump’s mass deportation program. First and foremost, it has nothing to do with removing dangerous migrants from the US. Its entire purpose is to rid this country of “others” — brown or black people who aren’t nearly as white as they should be. Where they end up matters not at all. It only matters that they’re gone.
The administration has allies in places it definitely shouldn’t have allies. The Fifth Circuit has been an absolute outlier since Trump’s return to office, rejecting thousands of federal court rulings to the contrary across the nation to declare migrants have no due process rights. This runs contrary to the Constitution and 10,000+ court rulings but it doesn’t really matter. Texas and Louisiana have massive ICE detention facilities. And detainees are swiftly routed to this jurisdiction to ensure they’re deprived of their rights until the government decides which random hellhole it wants to send them to.
The judicial system continues to catch the government in the act of depriving right. And the government continues to insist it doesn’t matter what the system of checks and balances has to say about its actions. There’s a lot of friction and it’s not going to go away, not matter how many unlawful executive orders are issued.
But there’s still this Fifth Circuit pressure valve, which currently allows the government to speedily shift detainees to detention centers where their rights aren’t respected. And this is on top of the normal bullshit pulled by ICE et al, where the constant movement of detainees is a deliberate effort to deprive them of their due process rights by keeping jurisdiction in constant flux.
Now there’s a new wrinkle: one that’s meant to be more of the same. And it’s also something no other administration has attempted prior to this point in history. This is brute force rights removal, performed by an administration that would rather see you bankrupted than rein in any of its ugliest urges:
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has stopped publicly revealing where it is holding thousands of detainees who are subject to final deportation orders, an unannounced move that has made it far more difficult for lawyers and relatives to find them, according to current and former officials familiar with the practice.
ICE removed those detainees from its online detainee locator system on Sept. 15, according to three current and former ICE officials who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the change. Several lawyers contacted by The Associated Press confirmed their clients vanished from the system this week, and the American Immigration Lawyers Association warned its members about the situation Friday.
Plenty of administrations have lied and cheated. But this is the only administration that has openly declared it would rather cheat than play fairly and has still somehow managed to retain most of its power even though thousands of courts have not only called out its cheating, but restored rights to thousands of people the administration has indiscriminately subjected to its very specific forms of discrimination.
Where it goes from here is unknown. Courts can issue orders that will try to return the status to quo. But it’s unlikely any of this will matter until MAGA becomes a minority group itself. Without the full-throated cowardice of the Republic Party to back whatever play Trump (or Stephen Miller) chooses to make, what’s seen here — as awful as it is — might be the beginning of the end.
Unfortunately for those swept up ICE raids, these disappearances will still be effective enough to see them deprived of their rights, if not actually deported to countries more than willing to let foreigners die on their soil so long it results in a paycheck or, perhaps, a bit more respect from a country that has chosen to turn its back on its human rights record.
Daily Deal: The Complete CompTIA And IT Exam Training Bundle [Techdirt]
The Complete CompTIA and IT Exam Training Bundle offers access to multi-platform IT training courses, practice exam simulators, and hands-on labs such as CramWise, LinuxPath, DojoLab, CodeDirect, and ExamsDigest. These help prepare you for exams like CompTIA A+, Network+, Security+, Cloud+, Server+, and PenTest+, alongside cloud and networking credentials. It’s on sale for $27.97 with an early Black Friday discount.

Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.
Dancing with the trophy shortage [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]
It’s easy to get distracted by (and hooked on) the quest for a trophy. It’s easy to measure and a bright light to focus on.
But this skips the key question: What’s it for?
The Savannah Bananas never won their league. But they made more money (and their fans had more fun) than any other team.
Your favorite episode of the Mel Robbins show might not be the one that got the most views. And of course, the best video on YouTube is unlikely to be the one that went the most viral. That’s simply the easiest to measure.
High school sports seems to be about solving the trophy shortage, but is that what it should be for? Are all the other teams and all their athletes failures? Or is it simply a shortcut that lets the coach off the hook when they hesitate to do the hard work of developing their students?
If it’s easy to measure, it might not be the thing you ought to be measuring. In fact, it probably isn’t.
Oh Sure, NOW Nick Clegg Tells Tech Bros They Were Wrong To Back Trump [Techdirt]
I’m getting a bit tired of the so-called “prodigal tech bros” who worked in tech companies, and only really speak out about the terrible decisions made by the leaders of those companies after they leave (at which point they get way more press coverage than anyone who has been criticizing those decisions all along). But this new piece from Nick Clegg in The Atlantic, saying that “Getting Too Close to Trump Was a Mistake“, feels like a new variation on the genre. Like the prodigal tech bros, his message isn’t necessarily wrong, just coming way too late from a messenger who should have actually taken a stand earlier.
If you don’t recall, Nick Clegg is the former UK politician (and deputy Prime Minister) who then went to Facebook/Meta, where he spent a few years as their “President for Global Affairs” (effectively, second in command to Zuck) where he tended to be rolled out to take political heat for unpopular decisions. He was the one who made it clear that Zuck was willing to give up Section 230 to allow governments to “regulate” Facebook… in a manner that would harm Meta’s competitors way more than Meta.
He left in January of 2025 as Trump’s second term was set to begin, allowing Joel Kaplan — who was way more connected to US GOP politics — to take his place. So, in some sense, it’s little surprise that Clegg is now willing to throw Trump under the bus. But also, a bit late for that, Nick. Some of us were calling this shit out right away, when it was still extremely politically inconvenient to do so, rather than waiting until after the American public spoke out loud and clear during the midterms.
As for Clegg’s reasoning as to why Silicon Valley’s leaders lined up behind Trump, he’s right that they basically got none of what they hoped to get:
First, tech leaders said that uniting the power of Washington and Silicon Valley would help America in its fight with China for AI supremacy. Yet over the past 18 months, China has been closing the gap with the United States by most objective measures, including model performance and chip development. In some important respects, China has outpaced America altogether, deploying open-weight models faster, developing a more sustainable energy strategy, and training world-class researchers and engineers at a larger scale.
Second, Silicon Valley leaders said that partnering with the government would help assuage public concerns about AI and overcome the “woke” opposition to Big Tech. Yet societal attitudes toward AI in the U.S. are much more negative now than they ever were under President Biden, and worse than almost anywhere else on the planet. Fostering the very backlash they claimed they were trying to confront is a peculiar triumph of hubris and incompetence.
Third, tech executives hoped that earning Trump’s good graces would allow them to avoid unwelcome regulatory incursions outside the U.S., especially in Europe. The Trump administration has undoubtedly helped with this in some ways. For example, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has become an important ally for tech leaders trying to fight a number of European Union enforcement decisions. But by any other meaningful measure the approach has been a disaster: Anti–Big Tech, and (alas) anti-American, sentiment has never been higher in large parts of the world, and most major economies—including Canada’s, India’s, Germany’s, and Brazil’s—are now scrambling to have less, not more, of what Silicon Valley produces.
Since Silicon Valley pivoted to Trump, then, its scorecard has looked something like this: chief rival (China) strengthened; domestic support weakened; global markets infuriated.
Again, though, there were plenty of people who warned about this as soon as they started up lining up behind Trump (even before the 2024 election). None of this was difficult to predict. So it seems a bit unseemly to bring all this up now.
Clegg’s analysis of why they missed it so much is at least a little bit more interesting. I’m not sure I agree with them all. His first one is that they had “FOMO” about Elon Musk’s close relationship with Trump, and were worried that this would undercut their own company’s efforts while competing with Musk’s companies. I don’t buy that FOMO alone explains it — the miscalculation seems so obvious that almost anyone could have seen it coming from the start.
The more interesting one to me is this one:
Payback. Tech leaders had a lot to be angry about in the run-up to Trump’s reelection. Some felt unfairly treated by traditional media, academia, and cultural elites. Conservatives had long felt unwelcome in the Valley’s traditionally liberal milieu. The Biden administration had clumsily vilified tech leaders rather than work with them on policy and regulation. These factors created a large group of powerful, wealthy, and offended individuals. Stepping into the Trump tent seemed like a good way to even the score.
I actually do think this was a major motivating factor among many (and have pointed that out a few times as well). But Clegg should point out how pathetic and silly this is. Tech leaders are some of the most powerful executives in the world. The fact that they got so offended that the Biden admin didn’t kiss their ass is no reason to throw in with fascism. This has nothing to do with high school popularity and cliques — it’s about having some fucking standards about humanity and basic rights.
On the next point, though, I do think Clegg is spot on:
Misunderstanding politics. As someone who spent nearly two decades in elected office and has spent much of my time since working in and around tech, I am always struck by how eagerly smart and wealthy people expound on subjects about which they know very little—especially politics. Their commercial success seems to foster in them a view that politics is easy, if only dim-witted officeholders would listen to them. It is this hubris that makes the Valley such an exhilarating and exasperating place.
I don’t think this is necessarily limited to tech bros. Indeed, I don’t think it’s necessarily limited to the wealthy. Lots of people have very strong (often ill-informed) opinions on lots of things. The real problem is that with the ultra wealthy, people feel a ridiculous obligation to take their brain farts on other subjects seriously. That’s where the mistakes come in. This is compounded by the assumption that because tech bros create magical-seeming innovations, they must also have special insight into policy and the future. I’m as critical as anyone of politicians not understanding tech, but the same is true in the other direction, where people in tech tend to have a very confused and unrealistic understanding of politics.
But a big part of the problem is that people take the stupid policy ideas from the tech bros seriously because of their wealth and the fact that they once lucked into selling some random business for hundreds of millions of dollars. And it seems like many of the tech bros assumed — incorrectly — that the public adulation they had received for years for their innovations would follow them into the realm of politics.
The reality is the reverse has happened. As they’ve embraced fascism and Trumpism, rather than having the public come along with them, the public (especially younger people) no longer trust them at all. Embracing Trumpism completely burned bridges with young Americans:

But again, this turn of events shouldn’t have been a surprise. Innovators were celebrated when they focused on making people’s lives better, and actually empowering them. But over the last decade, the leaders of the field, the same ones who lined up behind Donald Trump, seemed to totally ignore how the public’s views regarding their own platforms had shifted. And that’s because they had shifted from an era of actually empowering people to one of extracting as much as they could from them, and then demanding more.
The innovations no longer seemed cool and interesting and empowering. They seemed needy and aggressive and extractive.
Clegg’s piece is frustrating in that there are elements of it that are absolutely accurate. But it comes way too late and in too weak a form. As I said right after the election, much of Silicon Valley is actually working on unique and useful innovations and doesn’t support the fascist MAGA project. But too many of the CEOs and the VCs decided to buy in, and now they’re going to face blowback. My fear is that the blowback directed at the shitty leaders of shitty companies will actually do more damage to the underlying internet that people still rely on, rather than just narrowly targeting the actual bad actors.
While Clegg admits that Democrats in Congress are likely to investigate the tech industry for their coziness with Trump, he misses the larger point: the blast radius of those investigations will go beyond just those companies that embraced what they thought was a fascist cheat code to dominance. It’s going to make it much harder for the actual innovation, the smaller companies, and the new services that actually empower people, to exist as well. The end result is going to be a lockdown on the wider industry, because a few shithead leaders of the biggest companies couldn’t think just a few steps into the future.
There’s real collateral damage from the tech bros’ embrace of fascism, and avoiding it starts with not sugarcoating what a mess this was all along — and discussing directly how much damage their embrace of Trumpist fascism will do to the good parts of the internet.
Kanji of the Day: 乱 [Kanji of the Day]
乱
✍7
小6
riot, war, disorder, disturb
ラン ロン
みだ.れる みだ.る みだ.す みだ おさ.める わた.る
混乱 (こんらん) — disorder
乱れ (みだれ) — disorder
乱暴 (らんぼう) — violence
波乱 (はらん) — disturbance
散乱 (さんらん) — dispersion
乱射 (らんしゃ) — indiscriminate shooting
大乱 (たいらん) — rebellion
乱入 (らんにゅう) — intrusion
大混乱 (だいこんらん) — chaos
反乱 (はんらん) — insurrection
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Kanji of the Day: 捻 [Kanji of the Day]
捻
✍11
中学
twirl, twist, play with
ネン ジョウ
ね.じる ねじ.る ひね.くる ひね.る
捻出 (ねんしゅつ) — managing (to raise funds, find time, etc.)
捻挫 (ねんざ) — sprain
捻り (ひねり) — twist
捻転 (ねんてん) — twisting
首を捻る (くびをひねる) — to cock one's head in puzzlement
一捻り (ひとひねり) — fine-tuning
捻じ伏せる (ねじふせる) — to hold down
捻くれる (ひねくれる) — to become twisted
首捻り (くびひねり) — head-twisting throw
頭捻り (ずぶねり) — head pivot throw
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Arranging Buttons and Layout for a Clear Map [OsmAnd Blog]
Think of a painting you really liked. You probably don't remember the frame, and that's the best thing you can say about a frame. It was there to hold the picture, and that's all.
On the OsmAnd screen, the map is the picture. Buttons, widgets and the compass in the corner are the frame. With the phone in your hand on a city street, you hardly see them. Then one day the phone goes onto the handlebar of a motorcycle, sideways, you pull on your gloves, and now the frame is all you see. The zoom buttons sit right on the road you're about to take, the search button hides the next village, and pressing the right thing with a glove on is mostly luck.
The map didn't change. The frame just got too big for it. So let's make it smaller, quieter and easier to hit with gloves, and make sure it stays out of the way when the phone turns.

Photo by Gijs Coolen on Unsplash
The easiest way to give the map more room is to show fewer buttons. In Default buttons, every standard button has its own switch, so you can just turn off the ones you don't use on the bike. Search, for example. You won't be looking anything up while riding, and at a stop you'll take the phone in your hand anyway. The compass can stay, but set it to appear only when the map is rotated.
If there's something you do on almost every ride, you can give it a separate button. Custom buttons are made from Quick Actions. With a helmet headset, for example, it could be a button that turns voice prompts off and back on, so you don't have to go into the settings for that.
Custom buttons can be moved with a long press, so you can put them where they're easier to reach. They snap to an invisible grid in the corners of the screen, and when widgets or panels change, OsmAnd shifts them so they don't overlap.
The map can also make more room for the road ahead. With Display position set to Bottom (on iOS, it's called Location position on screen), your location sits a little below the center, so you see more of what's coming than of what you've already passed.
![]() | ![]() |
Take the voice prompts button from the previous section. On the map it looks small and tidy, and that's fine right up until you try to press it with a glove on. Every button has its own appearance settings, and on Android you can also change all default buttons in one go (on iOS, it's one button at a time).
Start with the icon, because it can do more than just sit there. A dynamic icon changes with the state of the action, so the button itself tells you what's going on. You can also give a button the icon of one of the actions you've added. And if you'd rather it always looked the same, pick a specific icon and it won't change.
Then make it bigger. Drag Size up, and the button becomes something your thumb finds without searching. Corner radius changes the shape, from sharp square corners to smooth rounded ones. A little rounding is usually enough.
A bigger button covers more of the road, though, and that's what the background is for. On Android, Background opacity goes from 0 to 100%: keep the button solid, make it partly transparent, or turn it down until only the icon with a light shadow is left. On iOS, the Background setting has two types. Solid works the same way, with an opacity slider from 0 to 100%. Liquid Glass turns the button into a piece of glass on top of the map: Clear lets more of the map show through, and Tinted makes it a bit more solid when there's a lot going on behind it.
Every change shows up right away in the preview, so you can play with it until the button feels right, and only then save it.
And if you'd rather not touch the screen with gloves at all, OsmAnd works with external input devices, such as Bluetooth keyboards and WunderLINQ controllers. Their buttons can zoom the map and run Quick Actions, so the voice prompts switch can live on the handlebar instead of the screen.
![]() | ![]() |
Painters had these two words long before phones did. A portrait is tall, a landscape is wide, and nobody expects one picture to work in both. On a motorcycle, you get both in one day. The phone rides sideways on the handlebar, and at a stop you take it in your hand and hold it upright.
By default, OsmAnd uses the same widgets in both orientations, so whatever you set up for the handlebar follows you into portrait too. To keep them apart, turn on Separate layouts on Android or set Screen elements to Independent on iOS. Configure screen then has Portrait and Landscape tabs, and changes in one don't touch the other. You don't have to start from scratch, either: a panel's widget list can be copied from the other orientation and adjusted from there.
Landscape has its own catch. The screen is wide but not very tall, and the top and bottom panels end up right next to the map buttons. Panels layout decides how they share the space. Wide stretches the top and bottom panels across the whole screen, and Compact fits them between the side panels and the map buttons. You can choose it separately for portrait and landscape (on Android, the option appears once Separate layouts is on).
The widgets themselves can be adjusted too, panel by panel: their height, whether icons are shown, text colors for day and night, and the background, which can also be transparent. A custom background color is a paid feature. Each widget also has its own size, Small, Medium or Large. Speed and the next turn are worth making Large, because on the road you read them at a glance. If one panel or another profile already looks the way you like, you can copy its appearance instead of setting everything again. On iOS with Independent screen elements, all of this is set separately for each orientation.

All of this belongs to one profile. The screen you put together for the motorcycle stays in the Motorcycle profile, and the ones you use on foot or in the car stay exactly as they were. Nothing you changed for the handlebar follows you into the city.
Even within one profile, the screen doesn't have to look the same all day. The left and right panels can hold up to five pages of widgets, so one page can show what matters on the move and another what you check at a stop.
If another profile should get the same buttons, you don't have to set them up again. In Default buttons, Copy from another profile brings over which buttons are visible and how they look. Custom buttons are shared between profiles, and in each one you just decide whether a button shows up. Switching profiles can be a Quick Action as well, so going from the bike to walking around town takes one tap.
Back to the painting from the beginning. A good frame is the one you don't remember, and after a day on the road, you probably won't remember the buttons either. Just the road.
We appreciate your interest in us and thank you for taking the time to read this article. Join us on social media to keep up to date with the latest news and share your experiences. Your opinion is important to us.
Pluralistic: How to forfeit one of copyright's best labor policies (19 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]
->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->
Top Sources:
None
-->

There's a seeming paradox to copyright. For 50 years (starting with the 1976 Copyright Act) legislatures have monotonically expanded copyright, so that today, copyright lasts longer, covers more works, restricts more activities, and provides for harsher penalties for infringement, all in the name of protecting artists.
After 50 years of this, artists are, on average, poorer than we were in 1976, but the media companies we sell our work to are much, much richer. They're larger and more profitable, and yet our wealth (both in absolute terms and as a share of media company profits) has declined.
This may feel like a paradox, but it's actually easy to understand unless you've had the self-inflicted neurological injury we call "getting an econ degree." That's an injury that leaves the sufferer incapable of reasoning about or even perceiving power.
If you've avoided that fate, then you can see that when an artist sells to one of five publishers, four studios, three labels, two app companies or one ebook/audiobook company, that artist has very little leverage. In that market, giving an artist more to bargain with is just giving them more to bargain away.
I have often compared giving more copyright to creative workers trapped in this oligopoly to giving a bullied schoolchild extra lunch money. No matter how much money you give that kid, they're not going to get fed. The bullies just take whatever money you give to the kid. Indeed, if you indirectly transfer enough money to the bullies, they'll pay for a global ad campaign: THINK OF THE HUNGRY SCHOOLCHILDREN! THEY NEED MORE LUNCH MONEY!
This is exactly what has happened with 50 years of successive copyright expansions. Every time Congress gave a new copyright to creative workers, the cartels we bargain with just amended their non-negotiable contracts to force us to hand over that new right for no extra payment. Then they used those new rights to get richer and more powerful, and to exert more control over the distribution channels we need to reach our audiences, which made us poorer. Then Congress heard their THINK OF THE STARVING ARTISTS pitch, and gave us more copyright…which we promptly handed over to our bosses. Lather, rinse, repeat.
If you want to feed a hungry schoolkid, you have to change the structure of the system. For example, you might open a credit account with the school lunchroom, so that the kid never has any cash for the bullies to take. Likewise, if you want to help artists get more money, you need to make a systemic change.
There are lots of ways to do this. In 2022, Rebecca Giblin and I co-wrote a book called Chokepoint Capitalism, and we devoted half of the book to detailed, shovel-ready proposals for ways to alter the copyright system to benefit artists, not our bosses:
https://www.beacon.org/Chokepoint-Capitalism-P2020.aspx
That section includes a chapter on something called "termination of transfer," which was introduced with the 1976 Copyright Act. Under termination of transfer, any copyright contract (a "transfer") can be unilaterally canceled ("termination") by any creator after 35 years. So even if you sign away your copyrights for the entire term (your life plus 70 years), you can tear up that agreement after 35 years by notifying the company you sold your rights to and then filing some paperwork with the US Copyright Office:
https://pluralistic.net/2021/09/26/take-it-back/
We got really excited about termination. For one thing, Rebecca is one of the world's leading experts on the subject. In 2021, she co-authored the landmark study "U.S. Copyright Termination Notices 1977-2020: Introducing New Datasets," published in the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies:
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3880708
Termination is a uniquely efficient way to make artists richer at the expense of our bosses. The fact that you can only exercise it after 35 years produces some very interesting effects. First, consider that almost no copyrighted works are commercially viable after 35 years (most copyrighted works cease to generate income after 14 years or less, this being the original term of copyright in the USA). The rare works that continue to generate revenue 35 years after their release are the "perennial favorites" that drive a vast share of media industry profits.
Now consider that, between the realities of the human lifespan and the amount of time it takes most artists to master their craft, any given work you produced 35 years ago is almost certainly from the start of your career. That's the moment in which artists are typically most vulnerable. Artists at the start of their careers are unknown quantities and are often crammed into signing terrible deals, even worse than the "standard" media deal.
Put these two facts together and you'll see that termination is disproportionately applicable to a body of work that is wildly profitable for media companies, but the creators of those works are entitled to even less of the money it generates, thanks to the crummy contracts they were railroaded into because they were just starting out when they made them.
Termination lets creators cancel those crummy contracts, take back their rights, and bargain for a better deal with the old media company (or a new one). This time, they bargain from a position of unassailable strength, due to the fact that they're selling a property that's proven itself to be a perennial profit-generator.
Best of all, you can't bargain out of termination. Even if you sign a contract that says, "I promise I will not exercise my termination of transfer right," you can still exercise your termination right. This is a structural change, like the parent who opens a charge account with the school cafeteria so that their kid no longer has any lunch money to hand over to the bullies. The way Congress wrote termination into the 1976 Act, it doesn't matter how hard the media company you initially sign with twists your arm, you literally can't promise them you won't use your termination right 35 years after signing.
That's where that landmark study Rebecca co-authored comes in. Rebecca and her co-authors found that termination was working exactly the way Congress intended: it was making artists richer. It's particularly helpful to marginalized creative workers, for example, Black "heritage" musicians who were railroaded into terrible contracts that meant they never got a dime for decades of airplay, covers and samples of their hits. If this sounds familiar, you might be thinking of my 2024 technothriller The Bezzle, where I use this as a key plot point:
https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865878/thebezzle/
Genre writers have really benefited from termination. The authors of massively popular YA series like The Baby-Sitters Club and Sweet Valley High claimed back their rights under termination. So did Peter Straub and Stephen King, who took back the rights to their early books and resold them on much more favorable terms. Just the threat of termination forced Disney to make giant payouts to Marvel's key creators, like Stan Lee, Steve Ditko and Jack Kirby:
https://deadline.com/2023/12/marvel-court-termination-disney-spider-man-dr-strange-1234843941/
In Chokepoint Capitalism, Rebecca and I point out that most of the 1976 Copyright Act (like longer copyright terms) has failed to help artists, but termination is the rare exception, a proven effective way to put money in artists' pockets. Which is weird, because in the 50 years since the 1976 Act, Congress has repeatedly doubled down on pretty much every measure in the Act, except the one thing that is empirically proven to be good for artists. Of course, all that failed stuff in the 1976 Act is good for giant media companies, and termination is bad for those companies, so it's not hard to see why there's been so little legislative appetite to beef up termination.
But it's also easy to see how we'd do that beefing up. In the original draft of the Copyright Act, termination was automatic, and kicked in after 20 years (meaning that 20 years after signing any contract, every creator would automatically get back all the rights they sold in the contract). The final version of the Act watered down termination so it kicks in after 35 years, and even then only after the artist does a ton of paperwork.
Giving artists the termination rights they were promised in the initial draft of the 1976 Act is a no-brainer. But that's not what we've gotten from Congress. To the extent that Congress acted on termination, it was to take it away from musicians. In 1999, an obscure Congressional staffer named Mitch Glazier snuck a clause into an unrelated bill that made it impossible for most recording artists to exercise their termination rights. This was such a scandal that Congress had to convene a special session to cancel this amendment and restore musicians' rights, and Glazier was drummed out of his Congressional job:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Glazier#Work_for_hire
Don't worry, Glazier landed on his feet: he was immediately hired by the RIAA (the record industry's lobbying arm) as their new CEO and there he perches even today, making more than $1.4m/year to do a job he continues to describe as "defending artists":
https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/131669037
With Glazier as the standard-bearer for "artists' rights," it's no wonder that creators haven't gotten a better deal on termination out of Congress.
Indeed, things are looking very bad for termination of transfer right now, thanks to a string of court decisions that pit a common tax strategy employed by freelance creatives against termination of transfer.
Like many freelancers, creative workers often incorporate limited liability companies that contract with the companies that employ them. These companies then pass the revenue on to creators as "partner distributions." There are lots of reasons to like this arrangement: it simplifies probate and estate planning, helps creators fund their pensions, and offers tax deductions for expenses like a home office or research trips.
This arrangement is especially common in Hollywood, where the companies that writers, directors, and other creative trades work through are called "loan-out companies" (because the company employs the creative, and "loans them out" to movie studios).
Movie studios and other media companies have recently seized on the existence of these loan-out companies to argue (with a great deal of success) that the existence of these loan-out companies nullifies termination of transfer.
You see, termination of transfer is only available for creative works that are independently produced and licensed through a copyright contract. Termination does not apply to "works made for hire," such as the emails and reports you might write in the course of your duties as an employee. The logic here is that termination of transfer is supposed to help artists get more out of their copyrights, but forcing (say) an insurance company to disgorge all the memos you wrote for them 35 years ago would introduce chaos and uncertainty without helping workers in any way (there's not exactly a market for 35-year-old insurance company memos).
The media companies' argument goes that creative workers are employees of their loan-out companies, so if you sell a script or a novel through your LLC, that is a "work made for hire" that the LLC owned, and that means that it can't exercise your termination of transfer rights to get that work back after 35 years.
Aaron Moss, who edits the Copyright Lately website, has been beating the drum about this for years, calling it "a ticking time bomb for copyright-intensive industries." He's been repeatedly vindicated, most recently through a bizarre dispute between Michael Mann, the director and writer of 1995's blockbuster Heat, and New Regency, the studio that released it:
https://copyrightlately.com/michael-mann-heat-copyright-termination/
Moss's article on the dispute is a very entertaining read, unpacking a decidedly weird gambit that Mann has deployed to regain the rights to Heat. But the most important part of the article is the way it describes the state of play for termination's ongoing collision with loan-out companies. The studios and labels have racked up a string of wins using this gambit, with creators settling their cases or losing outright. Take musician John Waite's bid to get his rights back from UMG: the judge ruled in UMG's favor, saying, "people cannot use a corporate structure for some purposes – eg taking advantage of tax benefits – and then disavow it for others":
https://copyrightlately.com/copyright-termination-loan-out-corporations/
This is a bad situation. Termination is a fantastic, artist-friendly legal doctrine, one that lets creators claim back some of our most cherished media. Termination gave George Clinton the rights back to his entire catalog (his sleazy ex-manager forged Clinton's signature on a rights assignment). It let Gary K Wolf take Roger Rabbit back from Disney:
https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/18/im-not-bad/#im-just-drawn-that-way
It let the Spinal Tap crew get a much better deal out of their studio, and paved the way for 2025's (criminally underrated) Spinal Tap II:
The Wachowskis just announced that they're going to exercise their termination rights to get The Matrix back from Warner Brothers, which is now owned by Trump's cronies, thanks to California Attorney General Rob Bonta's decision to let the Warner-Paramount merger go through:
https://puck.news/hollywood/2026/11/the-wachowskis-are-reclaiming-the-matrix
This clash between termination and loan-outs has been on my radar since 2021, when the artist-defending media lawyer Jeff Trexler told me about it over drinks at Comic-Con. I've since spoken to accountants and lawyers who think there might be a way to finesse this if creators set up contracts with their loan-outs that give the loan-outs the right to collect their royalties and advances, without assigning copyright to the loan-out companies. I don't have any definitive answers on this: if you're worried about it, you should talk to your own lawyers and accountants.
It's a dangerous erosion of one of the few bright spots in copyright, a rule that is an unambiguously good way to benefit artists, not media companies.
In the meantime, if you've got some 35-year-old copyrights you'd like to terminate, I've got a tip for you. The Authors Alliance is a nonprofit that defends the rights of authors (I volunteer for its advisory board); we've got a free online tool that will help you terminate your own transfers and get your rights back:
https://www.authorsalliance.org/resources/termination-of-transfer/

Intelligence Hawks Plot to Sneak Through Warrantless Spying https://prospect.org/2026/11/18/intelligence-hawks-plot-to-sneak-through-warrantless-spying/
Quebec student strike, demos a big success despite cops attack https://yvesengler.com/2026/11/18/quebec-student-strike-demos-a-big-success-despite-cops-attack/
THE PHOENIX, by FLAMING HYDRA: Return of the Human Internet https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/thebrickhouse/return-of-the-human-internet-the-phoenix-by-flaming-hydra
Niva https://niva.design/
#25yrsago The History of Interlibrary Loan https://web.archive.org/web/20011124021520/https://web.mit.edu/dchud/www/p2p-talk-slides/20011107-p2p-histill.htm
#10yrsago When Mike Pence came to Hamilton, the cast added a special afterword, just for him https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/19/us/mike-pence-hamilton.html
#10yrsago The Snoopers Charter is now law in the UK: “extreme surveillance” rules the land https://web.archive.org/web/20161119071955/https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/nov/19/extreme-surveillance-becomes-uk-law-with-barely-a-whimper
#10yrsago 19 questions to frame a reconciling conversation with your opposite-voting loved ones https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/podcasts/how-could-you-19-questions-to-ask-loved-ones-who-voted-the-other-way.html
#5yrsago Teamsters transformed https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/19/hoffa-jr-defeated/#teamsters-for-a-democratic-union

Sheffield: Reverse Centaur at Juno Books, Nov 25
https://www.outsavvy.com/event/40274/cory-doctorow-in-conversation
Virtual: Enshittification, AI, and the Future of Technology (UBC Master of Educational Technology), Nov 28
https://met.ubc.ca/2026/09/met-speaker-series-cory-doctorow-enshittification-ai-and-the-future-of-technology/
Oxford: Bennett Oxford Symposium on Open Code in Science, Dec 9
https://www.bennett.ox.ac.uk/events/2026-bennett-institute-symposium/
Santa Barbara: UCSB Reads, Apr 29
https://www.library.ucsb.edu/events-exhibitions/ucsb-reads-2027-presents-author-cory-doctorow
Montreal: World Science Fiction Convention, Sep 2-6
https://montreal2027.ca/en
Clint Eastwood (No Gods No Mayors)
https://www.patreon.com/NoGodsNoMayors/posts/clint-eastwood-173008088
Life After AI (Brain Bar)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPPa43-n0vI
Terms of Service with Clare Duffy (CNN)
https://www.cnn.com/audio/podcasts/terms-of-service-with-clare-duffy/episodes/458ce968-af5d-11f0-b539-13ed2afe25f8
AI, Work, and Power (Software Engineering Daily)
AI, Work, and Power https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/podcasts/cory-doctorow-on-ai-work-and-power/
"Canny Valley": A limited edition collection of the collages I create for Pluralistic, self-published, September 2025 https://pluralistic.net/2025/09/04/illustrious/#chairman-bruce
"Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, October 7 2025
https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374619329/enshittification/
"Picks and Shovels": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about the heroic era of the PC, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2025 (https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865908/picksandshovels).
"The Bezzle": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about prison-tech and other grifts, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2024 (thebezzle.org).
"The Lost Cause:" a solarpunk novel of hope in the climate emergency, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), November 2023 (http://lost-cause.org).
"The Internet Con": A nonfiction book about interoperability and Big Tech (Verso) September 2023 (http://seizethemeansofcomputation.org). Signed copies at Book Soup (https://www.booksoup.com/book/9781804291245).
"Red Team Blues": "A grabby, compulsive thriller that will leave you knowing more about how the world works than you did before." Tor Books http://redteamblues.com.
"Chokepoint Capitalism: How to Beat Big Tech, Tame Big Content, and Get Artists Paid, with Rebecca Giblin", on how to unrig the markets for creative labor, Beacon Press/Scribe 2022 https://chokepointcapitalism.com
"Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027
"Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027
"The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027
Today's top sources:
Currently writing:
"The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.
A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING

This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.
Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
https://pluralistic.net/plura-list
Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):
https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net
Medium (no ads, paywalled):
Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):
https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic
"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla
READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
ISSN: 3066-764X
| RSS | Site | Updated |
|---|---|---|
| XML | About Tagaini Jisho on Tagaini Jisho | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Arch Linux: Releases | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Carlson Calamities | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Debian News | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Debian Security | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | debito.org | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | dperkins | 2026-11-20 05:00 PM |
| XML | F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | General Union | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | GIMP | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Japan Bash | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Japan English Teacher Feed | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Let's Encrypt | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Marc Jones | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Marjorie's Blog | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | OpenStreetMap Japan | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | OsmAnd Blog | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Popehat | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Ramen Adventures | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Release notes from server | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect | 2026-11-20 05:00 PM |
| XML | SNA Japan | 2026-11-20 05:00 PM |
| XML | Tatoeba Project Blog | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Techdirt | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | The Business of Printing Books | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | The Luddite | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | The Popehat Report | 2026-11-20 05:00 PM |
| XML | The Status Kuo | 2026-11-20 05:00 PM |
| XML | The Stranger | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | Tor Project blog | 2026-11-21 05:00 AM |
| XML | TorrentFreak | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | what if? | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |
| XML | Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed | 2026-11-20 07:00 PM |
| XML | xkcd.com | 2026-11-21 12:00 AM |