Judge Won’t Let ‘DMCA-Ignored’ Host Use Cox Ruling to Escape $42m Judgment [TorrentFreak]
Last November, DISH Network won a $41.85 million default judgment against Ukrainian hosting company Virtual Systems and its owner.
In its 2024 complaint, the pay-TV provider accused the company, also known as VSYS Host, of ignoring more than 500 takedown notices while pirate IPTV services streamed DISH’s programming from its servers.
The defendants didn’t appear or respond to the complaint before the judgment was entered. However, when DISH’s lawyer asked them to confirm that they would comply with the permanent injunction, their Ukrainian attorney Taras Dementiev replied within a week.
Dementiev wrote that his clients were preparing to challenge the judgment, including with a motion for relief from judgment.
“We therefore cannot and will not confirm immediate compliance with a judgment whose validity is being formally and actively contested,” he added.
At the end of December, the owner of Virtual Systems filed an appeal at the Ninth Circuit. That effort was short-lived, as the appeals court dismissed it as untimely in January.
The defendants then hired Seattle law firm Williams Kastner and turned to the district court instead. In April, they filed a motion for relief from judgment, the only option left after a final judgment.
One of the key arguments in this motion was based on a fresh ruling. On March 25, the Supreme Court wiped out the $1 billion piracy judgment the major record labels had won against Internet provider Cox.
In that case, the Supreme Court narrowed contributory liability. A provider can be held liable if it induces infringement or offers a service that’s tailored to infringement. The host argued that this undermined the court’s earlier finding that it was liable.
DISH, meanwhile, kept monitoring. In an April letter to the defendants’ new lawyer, it listed at least 176 instances in roughly three months where, it says, the host’s servers were used to stream DISH programming in violation of the injunction. Many of these were the same pirate services that were named in the complaint, DISH added.
The host also argued that DISH misled the court about its Seattle servers, which it said were the only U.S. servers Virtual Systems ever used. According to an engineer who reviewed the routing data, none of the infringing material listed in the complaint was stored there.
DISH disagreed. A manager at NagraStar, which monitors piracy for DISH, declared that at least ten of the IP addresses listed in the complaint geolocated to the United States. After the lawsuit was filed, the same addresses started geolocating to Ukraine instead.
That change happened around the same time the Whois information for the IP range was last modified, on September 4, 2025. According to DISH, that was about a week after it asked the court for a default judgment.
The NagraStar manager added that at least one of the listed IP addresses was tied to the network number that the host’s own engineer associated with its Seattle servers. DISH therefore argued that the defendants changed the information about the servers, including their location, after they were sued.
According to the host, it no longer has any servers in Seattle at all. In an April letter, its lawyer told DISH that the injunction resulted in it being booted from the Sabey data center.
“Your client’s presentment of the order and injunction effected the eviction of our client Virtual Systems and terminated any contract to house servers at the data center,” he wrote.
Interestingly, however, the VSYS homepage still lists Seattle as one of its data center locations at the time of writing.
After taking in the arguments form both sides, Judge Barbara Jacobs Rothstein denied the motion for relief from judgment this week. The judge noted that the defendants had waited more than five months after the judgment, and offered “no explanation” for the delay.
The Cox argument didn’t help its case either. The court explained that a later change in the law doesn’t normally reopen a final judgment. In this case, it doesn’t change the outcome either way, as the Cox ruling didn’t address vicarious liability at all.
“Because Cox did not review or alter vicarious liability, the default judgment remains independently supported on that ground regardless of how Cox narrowed contributory infringement,” Judge Rothstein writes.

The Seattle argument failed as well. The court notes that the hosting company could have challenged DISH’s allegations by appearing in time.
The court therefore denied the motion. The defendants’ request to pause DISH’s post-judgment discovery was denied as moot.

In its response, DISH noted that the host’s motion painted Cox as an extreme case, pointing to an internal Cox email that read “F the DMCA!!!” and the fact that Cox only terminated 32 subscribers. The pay-TV provider wasn’t impressed.
“Defendants’ conduct is worse: Defendants publicly advertised their ‘DMCA Ignored’ policy to attract pirate streaming services and did not take action on a single DMCA infringement notice,” DISH wrote.
The host does admit to some of the marketing. “Defendants admit that certain marketing materials historically used the phrase ‘DMCA-Ignored’ in connection with servers physically located in Ukraine,” its answer to the complaint reads. At the same time, it denies having a ‘DMCA-Ignored’ policy, and argues that U.S. takedown procedures don’t automatically apply to servers abroad.
Virtual Systems also has other problems. According to the company, both of its Kyiv data centers were hit by Russian missile strikes on September 23, taking them out of operation. Most virtual servers were running again from a new facility in Ukraine within days, and earlier this month it opened a new location in Warsaw, Poland.
When we checked this week, its offshore hosting page still pitched Ukraine to IPTV services.
“In Ukraine, local data-related regulations are much more tolerant to copyright breaches and other legal abuses; IPTV streaming & generic pharmacy websites would feel more secure over here,” it reads.

—
A copy of Judge Rothstein’s order denying the motion for relief from judgment is available here (pdf). DISH’s response to the motion, with the supporting declarations, can be found here (pdf), and the defendants’ answer and counterclaims here (pdf).
From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.
Earning enrollment [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]
The single most important factor in learning is whether the student is actively engaged in the process.
Eyes bright, hands up, curious and eager for the insight on the other side.
Ask any teacher–students like this are a delight.
The same is true for the work of professionals–from doctors to cashiers. Wanting to be there, open to interaction, eager for change–these are so obvious that we usually overlook them.
In fact, the real work of anyone building an institution of learning or an organization that seeks to serve is simple: create the conditions for people to choose to actively participate.
The lazy method is to wait for the self-motivated and take credit for the results when they show up. The hard work is to build the systems and culture that makes it more likely that you’re attracting, motivating and transforming the people who want to go where you can take them.
Everything else is a bonus.
Emergent properties [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]
No system stays the way it began, and all systems evolve characteristics that surprise us.
The rise of the automobile system led to roads and gas stations, of course, but also parking lots, drive-through fast food restaurants and drunk driving.
The TV industrial complex was based on the effectiveness of advertising, and the ads that were among the most profitable were for beverages and snack foods, which made those industries ever more efficient and led to convenience foods and also widespread obesity.
And factory farming feeds billions of people. Competitive pressures led to a rise in fertilizer use and a destruction of topsoil, which also dramatically shifts the climate.
Any complex system will soon surprise us with its unanticipated effects.
Just for Skeets and Giggles (11.21.26) [The Status Kuo]
The Democratic tally keeps rising, with Mary Peltola now declared the winner of Alaska’s U.S. Senate race.
While Trump jetted to Asia for a summit with his fellow autocrats, former President Barack Obama toured the country welcoming new Democratic lawmakers.
Speaking of presidents—both former and sadly current—this bit by Trevor Noah made the rounds again. How is he so good at this?
As an aside, this Ahhhnold impression was too good to leave out.
If you're paying attention to what officials say rather than how they say it, you might want to hear this supercut.
Eager to bask in some positive light again, Trump headed to the APEC summit where he displayed his famous dignity and grace.
The big meeting, of course, wasn’t all the other member nations. It was the trilateral sit-down among Xi Jinping, Trump and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen—the first-ever meeting among the three. Here’s The Daily Show’s coverage:
The consensus? Well, not a good look.
No puppet!
Speaking of puppets…
After the meeting, Trump called our European allies in the Coalition of the Willing and asked why they were still funding Ukraine. No, really.
And he kept insisting that the war in Ukraine would never have happened on his watch.
Russia saw its road access to occupied Crimea destroyed by powerful Ukrainian missiles.
With the strikes on data centers and oil refineries, it’s quite a hat trick for Ukraine.
Speaking of issues to fix, there seemed to be quite a few in the news. Jon Stewart had some thoughts on the chaos.
Or basically, this:
But what was causing it all?
Was Skynet finally preparing to end all humanity?
Don’t worry, these guys are on the job!
Anyone else think of this scene?
The culprit appears to be patches that big companies rushed out to implement after AI uncovered so many bugs in the essential software we all depend on.
Surely the president has some words of hope and encouragement, no?
And he’ll take full responsibility because the buck stops with him, right?
There was even scary talk of a “dirty bomb” the Iranians were allegedly planning to detonate. Because war, right?
Speaking of bad fallout, the blast zone from the Nvidia chip and alleged espionage scandal keeps widening.
Even as former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang came under mounting pressure for allegedly facilitating banned chip transfers to China, a petition circulated urging the company to take him back.
The NYT Pitchbot was pitch-perfect this time.
McSweeney’s never misses either.
SNL’s cold open had a PSA for nerdy tech CEOs.
Pretty good, except we need some male honeypot training for Sam Altman and Peter Thiel.
Speaking of lame tech CEOs, Elon Musk actually claimed he isn’t MAGA after the midterm wipeout.
We see you, Elon.
McSweeney’s again.
Republicans fear that that Democrats, who will soon hold commanding majorities, will act like the GOP did in power.
They also fear that the war on woke has backfired and become a punchline. Exhibit 1: Grand Theft Auto VI graphics like this:
Meanwhile, most of the world is like,
I’m looking for a few new paid supporters to step up and help staunch the bleeding! Every day, I sadly lose more supporters to attrition than sign up, and over time that curve looks scary! Help me keep The Status Kuo available to everyone, especially those on fixed income or disability, by buying me a coffee once a month!
The award for best canine interjection in a song goes to…
Anyone need a beautiful smile today?
I have to add my own dog in here. Windsor has the cutest underbite grin!
She’s also a prime suspect at heinous crime scenes like this one.
The Rxckstxr brought the perfect voice to this moment.
The happy sounds this calico makes may stay with you.
But nothing will prepare you for this clip. I burst out laughing when I saw it, and then the woman reading the comments sent me over the edge!
The defendant hid out for days but was apprehended at the scene of this crime.
Winter had arrived, but these ducks didn't get the memo.
This was a hoot to read.
We’ve seen a lot of maps over the past two weeks, but I bet you’ve never considered this one.
“Mitt” Romney’s home state, I see you.
There’s a new Bond, and some people were asking very dumb questions.
Someone took the time to figure this out.
When your idol is from South Korea, be prepared for language barriers.
On the subject of speaking English,
If you haven’t seen the old man with the old-man bangers, he’s a gem.
This actually made me gasp in old.
A friend recently saw me in a train lounge and was sure it was just someone who looked like me. This next story reminded me of our laugh over that.
The British have a unique appreciation for self-aware, off-colour humour.
Here’s more timely, smart quips from across the pond.
I laughed way too hard at this.
Proof that language is no barrier to humor.
Here’s a dad joke from the U.K.!
And one from the Indian subcontinent, via the U.S.
Have a great weekend and a wonderful Thanksgiving week! (And if you’d like to give your thanks for my efforts here, consider upgrading your subscription today!)
Jay
This Week In Techdirt History: November 15th – 21st [Techdirt]
This Week in 2016
This Week in 2011
This Week in 2006
Kanji of the Day: 常 [Kanji of the Day]
常
✍11
小5
usual, ordinary, normal, common, regular, continually, always, long-lasting
ジョウ
つね とこ-
非常に (ひじょうに) — very
通常 (つうじょう) — usual
常に (つねに) — always
異常 (いじょう) — strangeness
日常 (にちじょう) — everyday
常識 (じょうしき) — common sense
非常識 (ひじょうしき) — lack of common sense
通常国会 (つうじょうこっかい) — ordinary session of the Diet
常連 (じょうれん) — regular customer
日常生活 (にちじょうせいかつ) — everyday life
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Kanji of the Day: 裸 [Kanji of the Day]
裸
✍13
中学
naked, nude, uncovered, partially clothed
ラ
はだか
赤裸々 (せきらら) — naked
裸足 (はだし) — barefoot
全裸 (ぜんら) — stark naked
裸眼 (らがん) — bare eyes (i.e., without glasses, contact lenses, etc.)
裸体 (らたい) — naked body
上半身裸 (じょうはんしんはだか) — naked above the waist
裸参り (はだかまいり) — visiting a shrine naked in winter
裸一貫 (はだかいっかん) — having nothing except one's body
半裸 (はんら) — half-nakedness
裸婦 (らふ) — nude woman
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
日本のOverture Mapsの建物データの現在地 [OpenStreetMap Japan]
Overture Mapsの建物データ(2026-10-21.0)を集計し、日本の約5,400万棟のうちOSM由来が約55%で最優先され、OSMに建物がないエリアをMicrosoftなどの機械学習データで補っていることを解説しています。都道府県別のOSM由来率は佐賀県が約90%で最も高く、北海道が約89%で続き、属性が入るのはOSM由来に限られることも示しています。建物マッピングに関心のある方におすすめです。
Updated Debian 13: 13.8 released [Debian News]
The Debian project is pleased to announce the eighth update of its
stable distribution Debian 13 (codename trixie
).
This point release mainly adds corrections for security issues,
along with a few adjustments for serious problems. Security advisories
have already been published separately and are referenced where available.
White House Withdraws Latest Nominee To Head The FDA; HHS Chaos Engine Goes Brrrrrr [Techdirt]
I have said repeatedly that whatever else we can call RFK Jr.’s department of Health and Human Services, it is undoubtedly also a chaos engine. Between nominees who can’t get confirmed, vacant director level positions, other positions being filled by acting directors, and all the rest, HHS is currently producing confusion and incompetence more than anything else. We’ve also seen this at the FDA more specifically, with one chief regulator calling it quits after only three weeks, even though he himself was replacing another regulator who only made it a few months. Further up the chain, you’ll recall that Marty Makary only made it about a year as FDA commissioner before he quit.
In Makary’s place, Kyle Diamantas was named Acting Commissioner in May of this year. He’s still in that role today. The Federal Vacancies Reform Act limits an Acting Commissioner’s ability to serve in that role to 210 days. Diamantas is currently just shy of 200 days in his role to date. And, wouldn’t you know it, the White House has just withdrawn its nominee for FDA Commissioner for reasons nobody seems to totally understand.
The White House withdrew the nomination of Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) amid opposition from Senate Republicans, it confirmed to The Hill.
Overton was set to face a key vote Wednesday in the Senate health committee, where Republicans hold only a one-vote majority — meaning losing one member would be enough to sink the nomination if all Democrats oppose it.
The White House said it was pulling the nomination because she didn’t have the votes needed to be confirmed. Strangely, the White House seems to be the only one that thinks that’s true. All that needed to happen was to placate a bunch of anti-abortion GOP senators, which seems like the lowest of hurdles over which the White House needed to leap. Here’s a guy who is routinely fooled by fake promises during confirmation hearings saying so out loud.
Cassidy said he was having “productive conversations” with committee members and believed Overton would have cleared his committee. The final hangup, he said, was anti-abortion senators seeking assurances from the administration about its commitment to “life issues.”
“My conversations with her convinced me she would follow the science and push back against decisions that put Americans’ health at risk,” Cassidy wrote. “The Administration withdrew Dr. Overton rather than make such commitments. Unfortunately, with the limited time left, confirming a permanent FDA Commissioner will fall to Senate Democrats.”
That… doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. The Trump administration has never been shy about bowing to the anti-abortion wing of its own party. For her part, Overton is vehemently anti-abortion. She celebrated when Roe v. Wade was overturned. She refused in confirmation hearings when questioned to admit that mifepristone is medically safe.
This is starting to look instead like the MAHA movement is responsible for this and that it has nothing to do with abortion.
Former Kennedy senior adviser Calley Means, a prominent figure in the MAHA movement, said this month that Overton wrote a policy relaxing standards for fruit-flavored vapes.
He also alleged Overton helped the Justice Department “construct a legal argument” for why the Supreme Court should take up a case that involved shielding major chemical company Bayer from lawsuits connected to its pesticide products.
RFK Jr. recently stated that he now has the freedom to go full MAHA with Stephen Miller being named Chief of Staff. This smells for all the world like him, or other MAHA administration creeps, flexing this perceived new muscle and getting the Overton nomination pulled. That is rank speculation, of course, but it makes a great deal more sense than any concerns about abortion from Republican senators.
But, as Cassidy rightly stated, confirming the next FDA Commissioner will fall instead to a Congress controlled by Democrats. There will likely be another Acting Commissioner appointed, since Diamantas’ time will have run out. There won’t be time for new confirmation hearings.
The FDA, like it’s parent agency HHS, is once again outputting chaos.
Tech Companies Are Trying To Shift The Entire Concept Of Privacy (Again) [Techdirt]
Privacy, which companies were once happy to claim was all about personal choice, is now primed to affect everyone around you even more than it already did.
Meta and Google’s smart glasses can record anything the owner is looking at or use artificial intelligence to describe it. Apple’s Audio Intelligence feature turns every Apple Watch into a transcription machine that records or summarizes your day. Amazon’s Bee devices take that a step further and can record and transcribe everything. Dozens of other companies are introducing pendants, rings, and other products designed to record, transcribe, or summarize everything we say and do all day long.
Privacy has always been a team sport. The actions you take with communication apps, collaborative software, or your cloud backup solutions, have long impacted everyone else you’re interacting with. But moving those choices deeper into the physical world where strangers, colleagues, family, and friends are all now a part of your privacy choices is drastically changing the game.
Tech companies want us to accept a reality where one person’s privacy choices (or lack thereof) means you suddenly need to be an expert in consumer tech who understands the capabilities of many devices on the market, how they work, how and if they signal when they’re recording, and what platforms they do or do not connect to. They believe these ambient surveillance devices that work in the background and are designed to look as normal as possible are the future, while they also expect the owners of these devices to use them responsibly and to notify those around them of their capabilities to act within whatever laws their states may have.
This is not reasonable, nor how consent works in any practical sense.
Let’s break this down by looking at some of the biggest players currently in the game: Apple and Amazon, who have two different takes on transcribing audio throughout the day, as well as Meta and Google, who both have slapped AI and cameras onto eyeglasses.
Ask Apple about privacy concerns and they’ll point to a white paper that explains all the technical barriers between them as a company and the data generated by the watch. Ask Meta and they’ll talk about all the ways you can customize the privacy controls or how certain details, like faces, may be blurred out when you interact with Meta AI through the glasses (but not during standard recording). Google does this too. Amazon will also talk about how you’re always in control, and no audio is stored (though it’ll also let you enable Amazon store integration, so your conversations can directly result in ads for products). And so on across all the companies making these products.
Some of these solutions do a better job than others at cutting out potential law enforcement or company access to this data. There will be a time to dive into these details more deeply, but the technical privacy promises these companies focus on only cover the consumer and user of the device. They ignore every bystander you interact with and their inability to actually opt out. There is no technical protection for you as a non-user of these devices, the person who finds yourself captured by them.
Still, we hope to look deeper into the technical differences between this category of devices soon.
With something like Apple’s Audio Intelligence and Amazon’s Bee devices, it may be best to treat them similar to an always-recording microphone, even if companies try to claim there’s “technically” no audio recording. These tools still often use a microphone to capture raw audio from conversations and convert it into summaries or transcripts before discarding the audio. Google’s blog post notes that it has whole responsible use part of their Terms of Service where users have to agree not to record others without permission or in sensitive places.
But it’s not just the question of the legality from the point of view of the user. Law enforcement will eventually try to compel access to the data that these products create (either real-time audio or the summaries and transcripts they create). And while some products, like Apple’s Audio Intelligence, are engineered to make that difficult, not every product will be. We know from history that when data exists, governments will do everything they can to access it. There’s no reason to think something would change today.
There is a problem humming along in the background that is impossible to address with technical or legal solutions. If secretly documenting conversations becomes the norm, it makes every private conversation less spontaneous and open. It breaks a longstanding social norm that you will not record and document every conversation with friends, family, colleagues, or strangers.
The companies that make these sorts of products like to claim they’re no different from tools we already have. You can easily record everything right now with a phone or a camera. Heck, you can do so with a camcorder or cassette recorder if you want. And you can transcribe conversations with pen and paper, too. But those are actionable steps we take that both require effort from the user, and are clear to others around us. This new wave of passive surveillance tech is designed to encourage continuous monitoring and hide its use.
Even taken at face value, none of these products can understand the complex social context we all navigate every day. We intrinsically know there are different social agreements we all make when we’re standing on a street corner, at a protest, in a bathroom, at a doctor’s office, at the gym, or in a restaurant. Taking notes in a meeting at work is completely normal. Getting a summary of a conversation with your best friend about their divorce is not. Always-on monitoring of our conversations is an unacceptable burden on our conversational privacy.
Google seems to all but admit this problem in a conversation with CNN when it described the company’s experiments with a notification system that would alert people’s phones when someone was recording nearby:
“And just alerting bystanders doesn’t do much to help, [Juston Payne, senior director of product management at Google] said. “It can actually be weirdly disempowering to you in that you’re like, ‘What am I meant to do now?’” he said.”
It’s easy to buy into the tech company line that these products are inevitable, but we’ve seen so many vaporware products over the years that we should take those claims of success with a grain of salt. We’ve seen entire product categories come and go within just a few years, and if the public doesn’t want this stuff, the tech companies will have to throw in the towel.
Of course, that doesn’t mean we all just have to sit around and hope that’s what happens. For its part, Apple launched its Audio Intelligence features in beta specifically to get feedback, and we think it’s worth taking the time to fill out their feedback forms (or in the Feedback Assistant app if you’re in the beta) and let them know what you think.
Products from the likes of Meta, Google, Amazon, and others might be harder to push back on, but politely and clearly engaging with those who use them in ways that make you uncomfortable is a good place to start. And if you see abusive videos on social networks where these sorts of products are used, report them. If you find these products useful for yourself, make it clear to those around you when you’re using them, and only do so with consent and in social moments where it makes sense to do so.
Republished from the EFF’s Deeplinks blog.
Ctrl-Alt-Speech: Make America Break Again [Techdirt]
Ctrl-Alt-Speech is a weekly podcast about the latest news in online speech, from Mike Masnick and Everything in Moderation‘s Ben Whitelaw.
Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Spotify, Pocket Casts, YouTube, or your podcast app of choice — or go straight to the RSS feed. To get extended episodes with additional coverage, support us on Patreon.
In this week’s episode, Mike and Ben cover:
And in the extended episode for Patreon supporters, they cover:
Our fun links this week include Nerdticker and Internet History Roulette.
Follow us on Instagram, YouTube, and Bluesky for video clips from the episode!
If you’re already a Patreon supporter, you can get the extended episode on Patreon.
Messing with the thermostat [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]
No matter how high you turn the thermostat, your house will take just as long to get to 72 degrees.
Second metaphor: You can’t make a pizza faster in a 2,000 degree oven. In fact, you’ll incinerate it, not cook it.
Third metaphor: Two people can have one conversation and meet each other. For a group of 11, it’s 55 conversations.
Fourth metaphor: It’s easier to salt bland food at the table than to fix over-salted food in the kitchen.
PS Next week in the US is Thanksgiving. But wherever you are, I hope you’ll enjoy the Thanksgiving Reader, an annual tradition designed to be shared.
Judge Says DHS’s Seizure Of An Immigration Lawyer’s Phone Likely Violated The First Amendment [Techdirt]
It’s logical to assume what happened here was a deliberate violation of immigration lawyer Andrew Lattarulo’s rights. The problem is that even deliberate violations need to be litigated. The ruling here paves the way for Lattarulo to continue his lawsuit against immigration officers who violated his rights. Unfortunately, winning here just generates another on-ramp to roads littered with insurmountable jurisprudence roadblocks.
But let’s not dwell on the potential futility of this lawsuit and instead dig into a decision where a federal judge has bucked the Supreme Court’s desire to excuse and all federal officers from accountability. This ruling finds in favor of someone whose rights were violated, rather than automatically assuming precedent demanded immediate dismissal. (h/t Kyle Cheney)
Early on in the decision [PDF], you can clearly see why immigration officers decided to engage in punitive action against Lattarulo. It’s not just that Lattarulo regularly defended people ICE wanted to make disappear, but he also actively informed other migrants of their rights via viral-esque videos:
Andrew Lattarulo is an immigration lawyer and part owner of the law firm Georges Cote LLP, which represents “thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings.” Lattarulo also runs a popular Instagram account featuring videos of himself discussing “know-your-rights information about U.S. immigration matters,” [id. ¶ 59], which regularly “amasses hundreds of thousands of views…”
At some point, this lawyer and the law firm drew the attention of Trump’s anti-migrant forces. This led to normally unimaginable legal action by the Trump administration. The DHS’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) unit claimed the Cote law firm employed undocumented migrants. It demanded the firm turn over documentation on its employees — a demand the Cote law firm apparently complied with.
While HSI went through the motions of trying to find literally any reason at all to shut down a law firm that provided zealous representation to detained migrants, Lattarulo and his employer decided to spend the weekend in Aruba. Cote returned from this trip and went through customs without incident.
Things went way worse for Lattarulo when he returned from the same weekend trip:
When his flight arrived at Logan Airport, three U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) agents and one HSI officer stopped Lattarulo as he got off the plane. The agents seized his cell phone without a warrant and then downloaded a complete copy of the data stored on the phone. Eight days later, they returned the cell phone via overnight delivery.
What’s on the record suggests the government did this not because it was essential to its border-securing work but simply because it could, given that it happened in one of the nation’s many constitutional dead zones, which not cover any international airport but anything up to 100 miles inland from any physical border crossing.
Supposedly, the government has not yet performed a search of the seized phone. But it definitely intends to… or at least believes it can work its way backwards from an unconstitutional search via any of the handy Get-Out-of-Lawsuit-Free cards the courts have provided it over the years.
The seized cell phone data is currently in a format that is not readable or reviewable, but the government intends to convert the data to an accessible format and search it if the Court permits.
The data includes confidential information, including privileged attorney-client communications related to Lattarulo’s clients.
So, there’s more than Lattarulo’s First Amendment rights at stake here. But if the government wants to engage in deliberate violations of attorney-client privilege, it first needs to convince a court that the seizure of Lattarulo’s phone has nothing to do with his immigration law work or his popular Instagram account that discusses these same legal issues.
Thus far, it’s not working out for the government. As the court notes in its discussion of the case, there is “no dispute” that Lattarulo’s public statements via his Instagram account (which include criticism of government policies and practices) are protected by the First Amendment. What needs to be demonstrated is that the seizure of the lawyer’s phone would likely not have happened if he hadn’t engaged in this criticism of the government.
This sure looks like illegal retaliation against this lawyer, says the Court. Before even getting to the matter of the phone seizure itself, the court points out that HSI aggressively accelerated its “investigation” of the law firm — trimming the response time for the firm to turn over documents from the stated ten days to less than three days, apparently for the sole reason of giving it a justification for the seizure of the lawyer’s phone upon his return to the United States.
Furthermore, if the government was truly interested in securing information from the law firm, rather than just looking for an excuse to seize an immigration lawyer’s phone, it would had detained the head of the law firm (Georges Cote) and demanded access to his devices upon his arrival in the US a full day before Lattarulo’s plane landed. That HSI showed no interest in Cote — despite him being the ostensible target of its illegal employment investigation — makes it abundantly clear this was all about the government finding some way to punish Lattarulo for his speech and, possibly, illicitly gain access to his communications with ICE detainees.
The government asked the court to not only reject this lawsuit but to apply a “bright line” ruling stating that anything the government pretends to be “reasonable suspicion” is sufficient to excuse any resulting rights violations. The court says lol no, that won’t be happening.
Defendants seek a bright-line rule that because they had reasonable suspicion to conduct the search, Lattarulo cannot show that retaliation was a but-for cause. [Opp’n at 14–15]. The Court disagrees.
[…]
[T]he limited record before the Court suggests that searches of cell phones are not regularly conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here and that Lattarulo’s own law firm partner was not subjected to the same seizure and search of property. The presence of reasonable suspicion therefore does not categorially bar a finding of causation under Nieves.
The court also addresses some of the Fourth Amendment concerns generated by HSI and ICE’s actions. While it’s not willing to rule on this issue (yet), mainly because these violations flow from the initial First Amendment violation, it doesn’t let them pass without comment.
The question this case raises is: reasonable suspicion of what? In other words, what types of suspected criminal activities can the government use a warrantless advanced border search to investigate? The First Circuit in Alasaad stated that the exception applies to searches for “contraband” or for “evidence of contraband or a border-related crime.”
[…]
The difficulty of this case lies in the fact that the suspected violation at issue—employment of unauthorized aliens in the United States in violation 8 U.S.C § 1324a—involves a law that is “enforced or administered by CBP or ICE” but arguably is not a “border-related crime.” Based on the information before the Court, there appears to be no connection between Lattarulo’s border crossing (or, more broadly, the government’s interest in policing the border) and the suspected crime that formed the basis for the government’s border search. Rather, it appears that the government seized on a fortuitous border crossing following a weekend vacation as an opportunity to search for evidence of a domestic crime it was already investigating.
At the end of the day, the court finds in favor of the Constitution. Since the phone has already been returned to Lattarulo, the court doesn’t need to do much else other than forbid HSI from looking through the content it downloaded from the lawyer’s phone until further notice. Given what’s stated here, “further notice” will likely take the form of a ruling ordering the government to destroy the data it copied from the lawyer’s phone. If we’re lucky, the government will appeal this and end up creating even more precedent that works against it.
Until then, the government is on notice that this sort of stuff won’t fly, even when it’s happening in “Constitution-free zones” where a majority of US citizens reside, or — at the very least — pass through on a daily basis.
Daily Deal: MagellanTV Documentary Streaming Service [Techdirt]
MagellanTV offers documentary collections that are deeper and broader than just about any other streaming service available. It’s the place to dive deep into shows about war, ancient history, science and technology, crime, and culture. Watch over 4,000 high-quality movies and series from the world’s best filmmakers. Get one year for $30, two for $60, three for $72, or unlimited for $129.97.
Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.
Autocracy and Absurdity [The Status Kuo]
A very unserious president sat down with two very serious autocrats in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday. It was the first-ever sit-down among the three leaders, the grotesque finale of Trump’s three-day swing through Asia.
Most Americans understandably skipped the coverage. Watching a lame-duck president waddle across the foreign stage is nobody’s idea of a good time, and the highlights (low points?) confirmed our misgivings. There was a disco number. There was a long, restful eyes-closed moment. There was even a very warm display of friendship toward a murderous dictator.
As Kamala Harris once warned, the danger of having elected such an unserious man is that he holds such serious power.
Disco nap
Chinese President Xi Jinping knows what Trump likes. At Wednesday night’s welcome banquet, with Trump seated next to Xi, young Chinese performers sang and danced to the Village People’s “Y.M.C.A.” Trump got the same song from the People’s Liberation Army band at his state banquet in Beijing in May. White House aide Margo Martin tweeted the Shenzhen video with a heart emoji, but watching it, you have to wonder whether the Chinese are trolling him.
At Thursday morning’s session, Xi touted the merits of free and open trade. For about 10 seconds, viewers of China’s state television feed saw Trump with his head slumped forward and his eyes closed. (The Daily Show had amazing coverage, which you can watch here.)
The White House cried fake news. Communications director Steven Cheung tweeted that Trump “was looking at papers in front of him.”
Whether his eyes were moving from reading or from REM sleep remains unknown. But HuffPost reviewed the longer video and found that his eyes closed several more times during the speech.
So many papers to read!
From Russia with hugs
Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin hadn’t sat down one-on-one since their infamous Alaska summit in August 2025. On Thursday, when he saw the Russian despot, the first thing out of Trump’s mouth was a smiling “Who is he?” before he added, “He’s my friend.”
Don’t we all greet our real friends by announcing they are our friends?
Europe’s leaders were in Berlin that same day for a meeting of Ukraine’s allies. The Shenzhen meeting drew comparisons to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where the Allies carved up postwar Europe. “A ‘Yalta’ format will not bring peace,” German Chancellor Friedrich Merz told reporters, adding that they would not allow Europe to be divided up. Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said she couldn’t understand why an American president would want to sit down with Putin at all and predicted Putin would come out of it emboldened. “He looks happy,” she said.
Trump’s declaration of friendship landed no better. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk (the better Donald T.) was blunt: “Mr Putin is not our friend and will never be.”
Four points, zero Ukraine
Jonathan Eyal, an associate director at the Royal United Services Institute, a think tank in London, said the only substantial thing to come out of Shenzhen “was the rejection of international law and institutions.”
After about 90 minutes, the main thing the three leaders produced was a four-point “Declaration toward Peace,” covering U.N. reform, fossil fuel production, the International Criminal Court and nuclear weapons.
The ICC point is the most cynical. The court issued an arrest warrant for Putin in March 2023 over the deportation of Ukrainian children, and President Joe Biden called it justified. On Thursday, in front of the cameras, Trump called the court “out of control.” All three leaders signed language calling immunity for state officials “of paramount importance” and saying the court must not abuse its jurisdiction.
Gissou Nia, a former war crimes trial lawyer in The Hague who now directs the Strategic Litigation Project at the Atlantic Council, said the language “threatens the ICC’s very raison d’être,” and that the U.S. has never strayed this far from its own record of backing accountability. Her colleague Melanie Hart, a former State Department China adviser, said Beijing and Moscow probably pushed for it.
Hart said the rest of the declaration mostly served China and Russia too. She described the U.N. reform language as a Chinese initiative, the fossil fuel point as something both countries wanted and the nuclear talks as a way for Beijing to buy time while it builds its arsenal. But Daniel Fried, a former assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs, gave the nuclear point some credit as a modest step toward bringing China into arms talks. On the fuel point, he said Russia benefits most and that the language suggests the U.S. is working to loosen sanctions on Russian oil.
For a peace declaration, it leaves out some key issues, most glaringly Ukraine, which goes unmentioned. Putin said afterward that his demands for ending the war haven’t changed and still include Ukraine ceding territory in the east.
Phoning it in
The Berlin group calls itself the Coalition of the Willing, a grouping of countries committed to supporting Ukraine. Trump’s envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff were there in person.
A few hours after the summit, Trump called in from Air Force One. Nobody in Berlin was expecting it. The call came through Kushner’s cellphone.
Four European officials told Politico that Trump wanted to know why they were still spending billions on Ukraine’s military; one said he called the money “wasted.” The Washington Post, citing four people familiar with the call, reported that he told the group Putin was eager for peace and that they should make a deal with the Kremlin and spend the money on themselves.
A U.S. official told Politico it was “not accurate” to say Trump told the Europeans to cut off aid to Kyiv.
Merz said Europe’s money is meant to get Ukraine to peace talks from a position of strength. “We want to end this war,” he said.
Putin, meanwhile, spent the same day ruling out a limited ceasefire and threatening to retaliate against Ukrainian strikes, according to the Post.
Trump once boasted he would force the rest of NATO to spend more on defense. No one imagined, before Trump’s second term, that this would mean defending against American encroachment on allied territory.
While many have long believed Trump is in Russia’s pocket, it’s another thing to watch him throw Ukraine to the Russian bear while calling the man who launched the invasion his “friend” before all the world.
That is the crux of our collective dilemma. We are living through absurd times when the actions of the most unpopular president in generations can still destabilize and destroy. Even a president with little public support can shatter important alliances and inflict death and destruction wherever and whenever he fancies.
It will be up to the incoming Democratic Congress to curtail the worst of Trump’s impulses and curb his power so that he cannot unilaterally abandon our allies, commit international crimes on the open seas or launch more wars of choice that wreak havoc on the world economy with no easy way out.
Workers’ Representatives Part 1: No Union at Your Workplace? Who Represents Your Voice? [General Union]
You may have heard someone at work referred to as the “worker representative.” Maybe you’ve even seen their name on a document or been asked to vote for one. But what exactly are they representing you for?
Under Japanese labour law, there are certain procedures where someone needs to represent the worker side. If a union represents a majority of workers at the workplace, that majority union takes that role. But many workplaces don’t have a majority union. In that case, for certain procedures, the worker side is represented by a majority worker representative.
This person isn’t a union representative and doesn’t have the same powers as a union to negotiate wider changes to working conditions. Their job is much more specific: they represent the workers when particular procedures under labour law require it, and their authority is limited to those procedures.
A workplace doesn’t necessarily need someone permanently sitting in the role of majority worker representative. The representative is needed when a particular legal procedure requires someone to act for the worker side.
One of the most important examples is the Article 36 Agreement: Japanese law generally limits working hours to 8 hours a day and 40 hours a week. If an employer wants workers to work beyond those statutory limits or on statutory holidays, it generally needs a 36 Agreement with the worker side and must file it with the Labour Standards Inspection Office.
If there’s a majority union, the employer makes that agreement with the union. If there isn’t, the agreement is made with a properly selected majority worker representative.
The representative can also have a role when a company creates or changes its work rules. In that situation, the worker side is asked for its opinion. If there is no majority union, the majority worker representative gives that opinion on behalf of the workers.
So the basic idea is fairly simple:
Majority union → the union represents the worker side.
No majority union → a majority worker representative may represent the worker side for certain legal procedures.
It’s easy to look at the worker representative as just another name that needs to go on company paperwork, but it’s important to think about the 36 Agreement again.
The person representing the workers may be asked to agree to arrangements that allow the company to have employees work beyond the normal statutory working-hour limits. That’s more than just signing a form. Their agreement can affect how much overtime workers may be asked to do and how much of their personal time they get to keep.
And that raises some pretty important questions. Who chooses this person? Do the workers actually support them? Do they know what they’re being asked to agree to? Have they talked to the people they’re supposed to represent to get real feedback?
Worker representatives are also receiving increasing attention in discussions about Japan’s labour laws. The MHLW’s 2025 Study Group examined problems with the current majority-representative system, including how representatives are selected, what information they need, and how they gather workers’ views. There have also been discussions about the future role of workplace-level agreements and the circumstances in which employers may be allowed to depart from ordinary statutory rules. These discussions could have important consequences for workers, but the proposals have not automatically become law.
For now, though, there’s a much simpler place to start: Do you know who your majority worker representative is? And if you do, do you know how they were chosen?
And more importantly, if you don’t feel comfortable with this system, there is a way to change it. Workers can organize and grow their union within the workplace, and if the union comes to represent a majority of workers, the majority union takes on that worker-side role.
If you’d like to learn how to start building your union at work, check out our Individual Organizing Training.
Interested in increasing your union’s presence in the workplace? Join our Individual Organizing Training
Kanji of the Day: 車 [Kanji of the Day]
車
✍7
小1
car
シャ
くるま
自動車 (じどうしゃ) — car
自転車 (じてんしゃ) — bicycle
電車 (でんしゃ) — train
車両 (しゃりょう) — rolling stock
駐車場 (ちゅうしゃじょう) — parking lot
列車 (れっしゃ) — train
車内 (しゃない) — inside a car (train, bus, etc.)
乗用車 (じょうようしゃ) — car
車種 (しゃしゅ) — car model
新車 (しんしゃ) — new car
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Kanji of the Day: 項 [Kanji of the Day]
項
✍12
中学
paragraph, nape of neck, clause, item, term (expression)
コウ
うなじ
項目 (こうもく) — item
事項 (じこう) — matter
条項 (じょうこう) — clause
要項 (ようこう) — important points
注意事項 (ちゅういじこう) — things to note
重要事項 (じゅうようじこう) — important matter
優先事項 (ゆうせんじこう) — priority matter
前項 (ぜんこう) — preceding clause
留意事項 (りゅういじこう) — points to note
検索項目 (けんさくこうもく) — search item
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
Wired Says ‘Please Let The Internet Die.’ Some Of Us Are Busy Building A Better One. [Techdirt]
It remains incredible — and disturbing — to me how many people now think of the entire internet as being made up of a few giant enshittifying companies. I understand why that is. The big companies absolutely do dominate much of the internet, and it’s close to impossible to avoid them entirely. But that doesn’t mean that that’s the entirety of the internet. And when you act as if it is, you do real damage to the good parts of the internet that still exist outside of the blast radius of those giants.
Five years ago, I wrote an article listing out a bunch of “other” internet websites, in the form of a “test suite” for anyone proposing internet regulations. Since most attempts to regulate the internet focus on the alleged (often not clearly proven) “harms” of one of the internet giants, I wanted people to think through the harm that these rules will do to the actual parts of the internet worth saving. These included forums and smaller shopping sites and web hosting and chat groups and more. It also included Wikipedia, which later picked up on the idea (I was told by someone there that this was partly inspired by my original article) and offered up “The Wikipedia Test.“
And yet, it seems difficult for people to remember this. It’s just so easy to bitch and moan that the internet now is just Meta and Google and Amazon and TikTok and (these days) OpenAI or whatever. And it leads to silly articles like Wired’s recent article Please Let the Internet Die.
But if you read through it, the entire article is about enshittifying internet giants, with the assumption that because they all suck, the rest of the internet should die as well.
Giants including Meta and Google have been forced to settle massive consumer lawsuits brought over privacy violations and mental health harms allegedly caused by the addictive mechanisms of their platforms. Schools are banning smartphones as multiple countries institute social media restrictions for under-16s. Parents are in a panic about their kids aspiring to careers as social media celebrities, losing themselves in a vast ecosystem of online casinos, or joining extremist movements.
Generative AI, briefly considered an amusing novelty, is now a turbocharged slop engine for the web, filling feeds and comment sections with useless, grotesque content. As humans scroll past headlines about AI taking their jobs, confusing fantasy for reality, and contributing to cognitive decline, any consumer appeal the technology might have is turning to anguish. The data centers that power it have become increasingly unpopular, and politically radioactive.
It is ridiculous to conclude that because some giant parts of the internet are enshittifying, there’s little worth saving in the rest of it. But that’s exactly where this article lands.
To be online, many now admit, is to be endlessly manipulated and exploited. In December, Oxford University Press declared rage bait to be the word of the year, noting that use of the term had tripled over the previous 12 months. The lexical spike represented a heightened awareness that monetized social accounts churn out bad-faith takes and extremist content, automating this abusive behavior with generative AI, simply to profit off hostile engagement. Billionaire oligarchs have opened the floodgates to such inauthentic activity, conspiracy-mongering, and hate speech by rolling back moderation.
In short, when you hang around online in 2026, you see little worth saving. Perhaps a decade ago, you felt that the glimmers of community and joy, of artistic and intellectual exchange, were enough to balance out the toxic junk. No longer.
But that’s bullshit. And, annoyingly, the folks at Wired should know that that’s bullshit. There are plenty of interesting parts of the internet that are still providing tremendous value. I’m obviously biased, but everything that’s been happening with ATprotocol in the last year has been incredible. Developers keep jumping in and building genuinely useful stuff — as just one example, an astronomer showed off software that streams time-critical data across the network to alert telescopes to supernovae — because anyone can just build things on open protocols. Just take a look at some of the many recaps of the Atmosphere Conference from earlier this year. People came out of it excited to build a new and better internet.
You can open up any of those links in the last two sentences and read about the excitement and the building, but I’ll just grab a bit from that last link:
The open web of the nineties didn’t win because the tools were better. It won because a critical mass of people decided that the alternative, a handful of AOL-style walled gardens choosing what everyone saw, was not the future they wanted. Then they built their way out of it. Slowly, unglamorously, in rooms that looked a lot like this one.
Whether atproto ends up being the thing, or a stepping stone to the thing, I don’t know. Nobody in the room claimed to know. But the work is real, the apps are shipping, and the people building them are taking it seriously without taking themselves seriously. That combination is rare, and historically, it’s the one that wins.
But if people just accept that “the internet needs to die,” we don’t get there. We get more stupid regulations that lock in those enshittifying giants and make it impossible to build a better internet.
The Wired piece is, in theory, a review of a new book called “The Internet Will Die,” which, at least as Wired presents it, frames the internet as fragile and doomed to cycles of decay, with big companies making things worse and deleting our digital histories along the way:
For one, West argues, people misperceive the “vastness” of the internet, which really amounts to “a vanishing fraction, a rounding error, of the human experience.” Moreover, it is remarkably fragile—West opens with the story of how a 2001 train derailment in a Baltimore tunnel took out a major bundle of fiber-optic cables, leading to internet slowdowns nationwide—and continually undergoes cycles of death and rebirth as a result of this natural instability.
If the internet is much smaller and less solid than imagined, West’s book suggests, then it’s crucial to recognize the forces that determine how those deaths unfold, or which pieces are preserved while others crumble. Because the market has falsely sold us the web as a comprehensive library of accumulated wisdom, each transient phase of this global network comes to define the present, for better and worse. Today we witness a dismal paralysis brought on by algorithmic incentives to churn out inflammatory garbage: Full-time influencers are in a losing arms race for attention with low-effort, high-volume channels that streamline production by delegating the creative process to bleeding-edge software.
But, again, that assumes an internet dominated by a handful of giants, the ones you hand all your data to, is the only internet possible.
But we already know that’s not true and it doesn’t need to be true in the future either. It sounds like West’s framing in his book is to encourage users to be more thoughtful about where they spend their time and energy online — and that’s great — but as Wired frames it, it’s all a wasteful endeavor since it’s always going to suck.
I certainly understand the fatalistic feeling that the internet sucks and will continue to suck. But that’s only true for people who lock themselves into the environments controlled by the internet giants you hate, rather than getting out and looking around at the cool things people are building which put the users in control of their own experience.
The piece ends with the author of the article, Miles Klee, admitting that the author of the book, John West, at least is open to the idea that a better internet can be created. But Klee, a self-described failed composter who’s “too lazy” for the gross work involved, doubts enough people will ever bother to do it.
“Look, the internet is rotting,” West says. “The question is, where are we going to put our energy?” A metaphor he often turns to in his book is compost. “Compost is just rot harnessed for a purpose,” he says. Can a decaying internet be fertilizer for something better? It’s a rosy notion, but speaking as a perennially failed composter—it’s just too gross, and I’m too lazy—I have my doubts about whether enough hardy, patient gardeners can be mobilized to make our digital landscape bloom once more.
And, again, I get the attitude, but I find this self-defeating nihilism to be pointless. The entire point of the internet, as Konstantinos Komaitis reminded us recently, is that it is unfinished. The internet is built on protocols that let anyone come in and build something better. Deciding we should just give up because some of the biggest players now suck is letting enshittification win.
The seeds of a better internet have already been planted. You can join Klee and Wired in doubting that enough gardeners will show up, but plenty of people are already out there digging. Come join us!
Tesla Starts ‘Selling’ Cybercabs You Can’t Buy With A $299/Month Automation Fee In Latest Ploy [Techdirt]
It’s pretty clear that Tesla doesn’t really want to make cars anymore. The company’s vehicle lineup is now full of dated relics, and it’s now discontinuing sales of the Cybertruck — arguably the biggest flop in automotive history. There was, of course, that recent demonstration of the nonexistent flying rocket-powered roadster, but that was generally stock-fluffing stagecraft aimed at dim children.
Instead, Musk envisions pivoting Tesla so it focuses more on AI and automation — despite the fact that the company’s AI systems aren’t profitable or particularly popular amidst a sea of better options, and many of Musk’s robotics and automation efforts mostly consist of hype, vaporware, or stuff that will never really see a mass commercial launch (like the nonexistent Optimum robot).
Speaking of hype, Tesla recently took to Elon Musk’s right wing propaganda website to announce that the company would soon be “selling” Cybercabs to consumers. According to the announcement, the Cybercab is being sold for $29,990 (before taxes and insurance). Plus a mandatory $299-a-month “Autonomy Subscription” charge:

Of course with everything Musk, the actual details matter. It’s invite only, meaning you won’t get one. Indeed it’s pretty clear that most people won’t actually be able to buy one. The car is only allowed to drive in a few cities (mainly, Austin, Texas), so you probably wouldn’t be able to actually drive the vehicle if you were actually able to buy one (which you won’t). And even if you happen to live in one of the zones where it currently can drive, you can’t leave those zones.
And the fine print indicates that on the off chance you actually get one (again, you won’t), you won’t be able to put the car to work as an automated taxi, despite Musk and Tesla’s earlier promises on this front:
“One of the biggest selling points of Musk’s 2024 “We, Robot” pitch was that regular people could buy a Cybercab and add it to Tesla’s Robotaxi network to earn passive income while they sleep or work. But the order terms explicitly prohibit owners from using the vehicle for commercial purposes — meaning no Uber, no DoorDash, and no putting it on Tesla’s own Robotaxi network to offset the $299/month fee. Tesla AI chief Ashok Elluswamy has floated Q2 2027 as a possible target for letting customer cars join the network, so early buyers are paying full freight with zero way to monetize the car.”
That $299 per month fee adds an additional $17,940 to the vehicle sticker price over five years. And the fine print indicates that Tesla reserves the right to charge you even more for automation, provided they give you a 30 day advanced warning. So the rich layers of bullshit are all very Musk.
There’s also the fact that these vehicles likely aren’t going to be very safe as the company conducts a glorified alpha test on public streets. Musk’s legendary decision to overrule his engineers on radar/lidar and go camera only for self-driving has already resulted in no shortage of human deaths. Meanwhile America’s safety regulators have been too corrupt, captured, or feckless to do anything about.
As it stands 278 Cybercabs are in operation in various cities. The NHTSA is purportedly investigating (for whatever good that’s worth) Tesla because the launch intentionally ignored public safety regulations governing vehicles without steering wheels. The agency also announced in 2025 that it had opened an inquiry into Musk robotaxis for failing to adhere to traffic laws and constant navigation mistakes.
While Tesla’s CFO insists the company wants to “literally take over every part of terrestrial transportation,” there’s very little indication that the company has the chops to fend off competitors and dominate the space. Most of what Musk now does is designed to prop up his fake supergenius engineer mythology, despite the ratio of bullshit to actual innovation becoming more and more lopsided.
So to prop up that mythology and goose comically inflated stock valuations, Musk is clearly keen on bundling and conflating Tesla’s increasingly stale vehicle lineup and “me too” automation and AI efforts with SpaceX’s actually innovative launch and Starlink technologies, and hoping the lion’s share of the press and public isn’t bright enough to notice the AI and automation stuff is low quality cack.
You can expect a Tesla and SpaceX merger in 2027 specifically for this reason.
It continues to say nothing good about America (or our media) how easily Elon Musk convinced the press and public he was a supergenius engineer who could cobble together complicated rocket machinery wearing coveralls in his backyard shed.
Hindsight continues to illustrate how Elon Musk’s real skill sets are opportunism, taking singular credit for the innovations of real engineers, the manipulation of a very broken media, and taking legal, regulatory, environmental, labor, and consumer protection “shortcuts” wherever possible.
Pluralistic: Lisa Hanawalt's "I Can't Stop Thinking About Horses and Sex" (20 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]
->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->
Top Sources:
None
-->

The title of animator Lisa Hanawalt's new graphic memoir I Can't Stop Thinking About Horses and Sex is a perfect encapsulation of the book's contents: a frank, self-aware, funny, horny, horsey exploration of Hanawalt's life, relationships, gender, and digestive issues:
https://drawnandquarterly.com/books/i-cant-stop-thinking-about-horses-and-sex/
Hanawalt is probably best known as the character designer for Bojack Horseman, but is also much loved in animation circles for her all-too-short-lived show Tuca & Bertie:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuca_%26_Bertie
She lived with the comedian/podcaster/showrunner Adam "Ruins Everything" Conover for 14 years, and the memoir revolves around the couple's breakup.
As the title promises, Hanawalt is also a lifelong horse-lover, who spent her childhood developing scars on her knees and calluses on the tops of her feet from endless all-fours sessions of pretending to be a horse. As an adult, she rides at the Los Angeles Equestrian Center, where she meets other horse people, who are beautifully depicted as the mix of posh sociopaths, obsessive animal-lovers, and lovable misfits (my daughter's middle school was around the corner from the LAEC and she grew up shoveling manure and tacking up at a teaching barn there; I can vouch for Hanawalt's faithful portrayal of the vibe).
Horses are Hanawalt's touchstone, the thing that brings her thoughts and emotions back into equilibrium, no matter what life throws at her. Eventually – inevitably – she acquires a horse, and just as inevitably, that horse proves to be her savior and her heartbreak. Horses are massive, majestic, impossibly powerful animals that are nevertheless forever on the verge of death, one weird disease or inexplicable fall from being maimed for life or keeling over.
The story of Hanawalt's pony Juni is intertwined with the story of her and Conover's breakup and her post-breakup relationships. Both threads of the tale are developed through beautiful, extremely funny, deeply personal vignettes that are brought to life by Hanawalt's art, which depicts bodies (animal, human, and animalistic human avatars) as hilarious, weird, and sexy all at once.
These two motifs criss-cross as we journey through Hanawalt's dating life, her childhood sexual trauma, her IBS, and her fears and hopes about her fertility (two of the major subplots involve Hanawalt's experiences with egg-freezing and bowel problems, and the way that the medical system treats women).
Hanawalt has a gift for compact, revealing character studies that leave the reader feeling both warm affection and exasperation with everyone in her life (including Hanawalt herself). It's a world without heroes and villains, where flaws and virtues are almost always flip-sides of the same coin. Everyone is crazy sometimes, including Hanawalt, and Hanawalt is self-aware enough to know when she's getting in her own way, and even why that happens, and also (just like all of us) can't always stop herself from tripping herself up.
Hanawalt's written and drawn a wise, funny, horny book that wrings comedy and insight out of trauma and melancholy. It's a gorgeous read that lingers.
Hanawalt isn't the only person who made smart, funny media out of her and Conover's breakup. Conover's comedy special about the breakup and its aftermath is called "Big Divorce Energy" and it was released the same week that Can't Stop Thinking hit the shelves:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CVB-SUX7zgk
I saw Conover perform this set live and it was terrific – and it got even better by the time he recorded it for the special. It makes for a perfect bookend for Hanawalt's memoir, a fact that both Conover and Hanawalt affirm in a lovely, warm conversation they recorded for Conover's Factually podcast. It's an interview that raises the bar for the kind of affection and even love a mature couple can salvage from a breakup:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUXEDUiICM4
The book itself is from Montreal's Drawn and Quarterly, who have a well-deserved reputation for publishing quality graphic novels, especially memoirs. D&Q always puts together a beautiful physical artifact, and Can't Stop Thinking is no exception: a handsome hardcover with luxurious, thick semi-matte pages and a bookmark ribbon sewn into the binding. It's the perfect gift for any friend going through a breakup (or thinking about buying a horse).

Anthropic’s Meh Debut https://prospect.org/2026/11/20/anthropic-debut-ipo-stock-market-sec/
#25yrsago They Fight Crime https://web.archive.org/web/20011204174257/http://www.rain-street.org/fightcrime.htm
#20yrsago GeekCorps builds cantenna WiFi TV network in Mali https://web.archive.org/web/20061213100911/http://www.geekcorps.org/2006/11/the-geekcorps-cantv/
#15yrsago Britain’s Occupy movement picks up steam https://web.archive.org/web/20131001063502/https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/nov/19/occupy-london-protesters-ideas-bank
#10yrsago Word of the day: Kakistocracy http://jury.me/blog/2016/11/19/kakistocracy
#5yrsago Inflation or price-gouging? https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/20/quiet-part-out-loud/#profiteering
#1yrago The long game https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/20/if-you-wanted-to-get-there/#i-wouldnt-start-from-here

Sheffield: Reverse Centaur at Juno Books, Nov 25
https://www.outsavvy.com/event/40274/cory-doctorow-in-conversation
Virtual: Enshittification, AI, and the Future of Technology (UBC Master of Educational Technology), Nov 28
https://met.ubc.ca/2026/09/met-speaker-series-cory-doctorow-enshittification-ai-and-the-future-of-technology/
Oxford: Bennett Oxford Symposium on Open Code in Science, Dec 9
https://www.bennett.ox.ac.uk/events/2026-bennett-institute-symposium/
Santa Barbara: UCSB Reads, Apr 29
https://www.library.ucsb.edu/events-exhibitions/ucsb-reads-2027-presents-author-cory-doctorow
Montreal: World Science Fiction Convention, Sep 2-6
https://montreal2027.ca/en
How AI is Breaking the Internet (and Everything Else) (Blood in the Machine)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXRaPjFRyT0
Clint Eastwood (No Gods No Mayors)
https://www.patreon.com/NoGodsNoMayors/posts/clint-eastwood-173008088
Life After AI (Brain Bar)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPPa43-n0vI
Terms of Service with Clare Duffy (CNN)
https://www.cnn.com/audio/podcasts/terms-of-service-with-clare-duffy/episodes/458ce968-af5d-11f0-b539-13ed2afe25f8
"Canny Valley": A limited edition collection of the collages I create for Pluralistic, self-published, September 2025 https://pluralistic.net/2025/09/04/illustrious/#chairman-bruce
"Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, October 7 2025
https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374619329/enshittification/
"Picks and Shovels": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about the heroic era of the PC, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2025 (https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865908/picksandshovels).
"The Bezzle": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about prison-tech and other grifts, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2024 (thebezzle.org).
"The Lost Cause:" a solarpunk novel of hope in the climate emergency, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), November 2023 (http://lost-cause.org).
"The Internet Con": A nonfiction book about interoperability and Big Tech (Verso) September 2023 (http://seizethemeansofcomputation.org). Signed copies at Book Soup (https://www.booksoup.com/book/9781804291245).
"Red Team Blues": "A grabby, compulsive thriller that will leave you knowing more about how the world works than you did before." Tor Books http://redteamblues.com.
"Chokepoint Capitalism: How to Beat Big Tech, Tame Big Content, and Get Artists Paid, with Rebecca Giblin", on how to unrig the markets for creative labor, Beacon Press/Scribe 2022 https://chokepointcapitalism.com
"Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027
"Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027
"The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027
Today's top sources:
Currently writing:
"The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.
A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING

This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.
Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
https://pluralistic.net/plura-list
Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):
https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net
Medium (no ads, paywalled):
Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):
https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic
"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla
READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
ISSN: 3066-764X
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 13 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 14 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
Wikimedia Commons picture of the day for November 15 [Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed]
| Picture of the day |
|---|
Véu da Noiva Waterfall, Seixal, Madeira, Portugal
|
| RSS | Site | Updated |
|---|---|---|
| XML | About Tagaini Jisho on Tagaini Jisho | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Arch Linux: Releases | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Carlson Calamities | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Debian News | 2026-11-23 05:00 AM |
| XML | Debian Security | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | debito.org | 2026-11-23 05:00 AM |
| XML | dperkins | 2026-11-22 09:00 PM |
| XML | F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | General Union | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | GIMP | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Japan Bash | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Japan English Teacher Feed | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Let's Encrypt | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Marc Jones | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Marjorie's Blog | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | OpenStreetMap Japan | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | OsmAnd Blog | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Popehat | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Ramen Adventures | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Release notes from server | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect | 2026-11-22 09:00 PM |
| XML | SNA Japan | 2026-11-22 09:00 PM |
| XML | Tatoeba Project Blog | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Techdirt | 2026-11-23 05:00 AM |
| XML | The Business of Printing Books | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | The Luddite | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | The Popehat Report | 2026-11-22 09:00 PM |
| XML | The Status Kuo | 2026-11-22 09:00 PM |
| XML | The Stranger | 2026-11-22 06:00 AM |
| XML | Tor Project blog | 2026-11-23 05:00 AM |
| XML | TorrentFreak | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | what if? | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |
| XML | Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed | 2026-11-20 07:00 PM |
| XML | xkcd.com | 2026-11-23 12:00 AM |