News

Friday 2026-11-20

04:00 AM

Dancing with the trophy shortage [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]

It’s easy to get distracted by (and hooked on) the quest for a trophy. It’s easy to measure and a bright light to focus on.

But this skips the key question: What’s it for?

The Savannah Bananas never won their league. But they made more money (and their fans had more fun) than any other team.

Your favorite episode of the Mel Robbins show might not be the one that got the most views. And of course, the best video on YouTube is unlikely to be the one that went the most viral. That’s simply the easiest to measure.

High school sports seems to be about solving the trophy shortage, but is that what it should be for? Are all the other teams and all their athletes failures? Or is it simply a shortcut that lets the coach off the hook when they hesitate to do the hard work of developing their students?

If it’s easy to measure, it might not be the thing you ought to be measuring. In fact, it probably isn’t.

      

Oh Sure, NOW Nick Clegg Tells Tech Bros They Were Wrong To Back Trump [Techdirt]

I’m getting a bit tired of the so-called “prodigal tech bros” who worked in tech companies, and only really speak out about the terrible decisions made by the leaders of those companies after they leave (at which point they get way more press coverage than anyone who has been criticizing those decisions all along). But this new piece from Nick Clegg in The Atlantic, saying that “Getting Too Close to Trump Was a Mistake“, feels like a new variation on the genre. Like the prodigal tech bros, his message isn’t necessarily wrong, just coming way too late from a messenger who should have actually taken a stand earlier.

If you don’t recall, Nick Clegg is the former UK politician (and deputy Prime Minister) who then went to Facebook/Meta, where he spent a few years as their “President for Global Affairs” (effectively, second in command to Zuck) where he tended to be rolled out to take political heat for unpopular decisions. He was the one who made it clear that Zuck was willing to give up Section 230 to allow governments to “regulate” Facebook… in a manner that would harm Meta’s competitors way more than Meta.

He left in January of 2025 as Trump’s second term was set to begin, allowing Joel Kaplan — who was way more connected to US GOP politics — to take his place. So, in some sense, it’s little surprise that Clegg is now willing to throw Trump under the bus. But also, a bit late for that, Nick. Some of us were calling this shit out right away, when it was still extremely politically inconvenient to do so, rather than waiting until after the American public spoke out loud and clear during the midterms.

As for Clegg’s reasoning as to why Silicon Valley’s leaders lined up behind Trump, he’s right that they basically got none of what they hoped to get:

First, tech leaders said that uniting the power of Washington and Silicon Valley would help America in its fight with China for AI supremacy. Yet over the past 18 months, China has been closing the gap with the United States by most objective measures, including model performance and chip development. In some important respects, China has outpaced America altogether, deploying open-weight models faster, developing a more sustainable energy strategy, and training world-class researchers and engineers at a larger scale.

Second, Silicon Valley leaders said that partnering with the government would help assuage public concerns about AI and overcome the “woke” opposition to Big Tech. Yet societal attitudes toward AI in the U.S. are much more negative now than they ever were under President Biden, and worse than almost anywhere else on the planet. Fostering the very backlash they claimed they were trying to confront is a peculiar triumph of hubris and incompetence.

Third, tech executives hoped that earning Trump’s good graces would allow them to avoid unwelcome regulatory incursions outside the U.S., especially in Europe. The Trump administration has undoubtedly helped with this in some ways. For example, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has become an important ally for tech leaders trying to fight a number of European Union enforcement decisions. But by any other meaningful measure the approach has been a disaster: Anti–Big Tech, and (alas) anti-American, sentiment has never been higher in large parts of the world, and most major economies—including Canada’s, India’s, Germany’s, and Brazil’s—are now scrambling to have less, not more, of what Silicon Valley produces.

Since Silicon Valley pivoted to Trump, then, its scorecard has looked something like this: chief rival (China) strengthened; domestic support weakened; global markets infuriated.

Again, though, there were plenty of people who warned about this as soon as they started up lining up behind Trump (even before the 2024 election). None of this was difficult to predict. So it seems a bit unseemly to bring all this up now.

Clegg’s analysis of why they missed it so much is at least a little bit more interesting. I’m not sure I agree with them all. His first one is that they had “FOMO” about Elon Musk’s close relationship with Trump, and were worried that this would undercut their own company’s efforts while competing with Musk’s companies. I don’t buy that FOMO alone explains it — the miscalculation seems so obvious that almost anyone could have seen it coming from the start.

The more interesting one to me is this one:

Payback. Tech leaders had a lot to be angry about in the run-up to Trump’s reelection. Some felt unfairly treated by traditional media, academia, and cultural elites. Conservatives had long felt unwelcome in the Valley’s traditionally liberal milieu. The Biden administration had clumsily vilified tech leaders rather than work with them on policy and regulation. These factors created a large group of powerful, wealthy, and offended individuals. Stepping into the Trump tent seemed like a good way to even the score.

I actually do think this was a major motivating factor among many (and have pointed that out a few times as well). But Clegg should point out how pathetic and silly this is. Tech leaders are some of the most powerful executives in the world. The fact that they got so offended that the Biden admin didn’t kiss their ass is no reason to throw in with fascism. This has nothing to do with high school popularity and cliques — it’s about having some fucking standards about humanity and basic rights.

On the next point, though, I do think Clegg is spot on:

Misunderstanding politics. As someone who spent nearly two decades in elected office and has spent much of my time since working in and around tech, I am always struck by how eagerly smart and wealthy people expound on subjects about which they know very little—especially politics. Their commercial success seems to foster in them a view that politics is easy, if only dim-witted officeholders would listen to them. It is this hubris that makes the Valley such an exhilarating and exasperating place.

I don’t think this is necessarily limited to tech bros. Indeed, I don’t think it’s necessarily limited to the wealthy. Lots of people have very strong (often ill-informed) opinions on lots of things. The real problem is that with the ultra wealthy, people feel a ridiculous obligation to take their brain farts on other subjects seriously. That’s where the mistakes come in. This is compounded by the assumption that because tech bros create magical-seeming innovations, they must also have special insight into policy and the future. I’m as critical as anyone of politicians not understanding tech, but the same is true in the other direction, where people in tech tend to have a very confused and unrealistic understanding of politics.

But a big part of the problem is that people take the stupid policy ideas from the tech bros seriously because of their wealth and the fact that they once lucked into selling some random business for hundreds of millions of dollars. And it seems like many of the tech bros assumed — incorrectly — that the public adulation they had received for years for their innovations would follow them into the realm of politics.

The reality is the reverse has happened. As they’ve embraced fascism and Trumpism, rather than having the public come along with them, the public (especially younger people) no longer trust them at all. Embracing Trumpism completely burned bridges with young Americans:

But again, this turn of events shouldn’t have been a surprise. Innovators were celebrated when they focused on making people’s lives better, and actually empowering them. But over the last decade, the leaders of the field, the same ones who lined up behind Donald Trump, seemed to totally ignore how the public’s views regarding their own platforms had shifted. And that’s because they had shifted from an era of actually empowering people to one of extracting as much as they could from them, and then demanding more.

The innovations no longer seemed cool and interesting and empowering. They seemed needy and aggressive and extractive.

Clegg’s piece is frustrating in that there are elements of it that are absolutely accurate. But it comes way too late and in too weak a form. As I said right after the election, much of Silicon Valley is actually working on unique and useful innovations and doesn’t support the fascist MAGA project. But too many of the CEOs and the VCs decided to buy in, and now they’re going to face blowback. My fear is that the blowback directed at the shitty leaders of shitty companies will actually do more damage to the underlying internet that people still rely on, rather than just narrowly targeting the actual bad actors.

While Clegg admits that Democrats in Congress are likely to investigate the tech industry for their coziness with Trump, he misses the larger point: the blast radius of those investigations will go beyond just those companies that embraced what they thought was a fascist cheat code to dominance. It’s going to make it much harder for the actual innovation, the smaller companies, and the new services that actually empower people, to exist as well. The end result is going to be a lockdown on the wider industry, because a few shithead leaders of the biggest companies couldn’t think just a few steps into the future.

There’s real collateral damage from the tech bros’ embrace of fascism, and avoiding it starts with not sugarcoating what a mess this was all along — and discussing directly how much damage their embrace of Trumpist fascism will do to the good parts of the internet.

Kanji of the Day: 乱 [Kanji of the Day]

乱

✍7

小6

riot, war, disorder, disturb

ラン ロン

みだ.れる みだ.る みだ.す みだ おさ.める わた.る

混乱   (こんらん)   —   disorder
乱れ   (みだれ)   —   disorder
乱暴   (らんぼう)   —   violence
波乱   (はらん)   —   disturbance
散乱   (さんらん)   —   dispersion
乱射   (らんしゃ)   —   indiscriminate shooting
大乱   (たいらん)   —   rebellion
乱入   (らんにゅう)   —   intrusion
大混乱   (だいこんらん)   —   chaos
反乱   (はんらん)   —   insurrection

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Kanji of the Day: 捻 [Kanji of the Day]

捻

✍11

中学

twirl, twist, play with

ネン ジョウ

ね.じる ねじ.る ひね.くる ひね.る

捻出   (ねんしゅつ)   —   managing (to raise funds, find time, etc.)
捻挫   (ねんざ)   —   sprain
捻り   (ひねり)   —   twist
捻転   (ねんてん)   —   twisting
首を捻る   (くびをひねる)   —   to cock one's head in puzzlement
一捻り   (ひとひねり)   —   fine-tuning
捻じ伏せる   (ねじふせる)   —   to hold down
捻くれる   (ひねくれる)   —   to become twisted
首捻り   (くびひねり)   —   head-twisting throw
頭捻り   (ずぶねり)   —   head pivot throw

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Arranging Buttons and Layout for a Clear Map [OsmAnd Blog]

Think of a painting you really liked. You probably don't remember the frame, and that's the best thing you can say about a frame. It was there to hold the picture, and that's all.

On the OsmAnd screen, the map is the picture. Buttons, widgets and the compass in the corner are the frame. With the phone in your hand on a city street, you hardly see them. Then one day the phone goes onto the handlebar of a motorcycle, sideways, you pull on your gloves, and now the frame is all you see. The zoom buttons sit right on the road you're about to take, the search button hides the next village, and pressing the right thing with a glove on is mostly luck.

The map didn't change. The frame just got too big for it. So let's make it smaller, quieter and easier to hit with gloves, and make sure it stays out of the way when the phone turns.

Motorcycle Ride

Photo by Gijs Coolen on Unsplash

What Stays in the Frame​

The easiest way to give the map more room is to show fewer buttons. In Default buttons, every standard button has its own switch, so you can just turn off the ones you don't use on the bike. Search, for example. You won't be looking anything up while riding, and at a stop you'll take the phone in your hand anyway. The compass can stay, but set it to appear only when the map is rotated.

If there's something you do on almost every ride, you can give it a separate button. Custom buttons are made from Quick Actions. With a helmet headset, for example, it could be a button that turns voice prompts off and back on, so you don't have to go into the settings for that.

Custom buttons can be moved with a long press, so you can put them where they're easier to reach. They snap to an invisible grid in the corners of the screen, and when widgets or panels change, OsmAnd shifts them so they don't overlap.

The map can also make more room for the road ahead. With Display position set to Bottom (on iOS, it's called Location position on screen), your location sits a little below the center, so you see more of what's coming than of what you've already passed.

Default ButtonsCustom Button on the Map

Buttons You Can Hit with Gloves On​

Take the voice prompts button from the previous section. On the map it looks small and tidy, and that's fine right up until you try to press it with a glove on. Every button has its own appearance settings, and on Android you can also change all default buttons in one go (on iOS, it's one button at a time).

Start with the icon, because it can do more than just sit there. A dynamic icon changes with the state of the action, so the button itself tells you what's going on. You can also give a button the icon of one of the actions you've added. And if you'd rather it always looked the same, pick a specific icon and it won't change.

Then make it bigger. Drag Size up, and the button becomes something your thumb finds without searching. Corner radius changes the shape, from sharp square corners to smooth rounded ones. A little rounding is usually enough.

A bigger button covers more of the road, though, and that's what the background is for. On Android, Background opacity goes from 0 to 100%: keep the button solid, make it partly transparent, or turn it down until only the icon with a light shadow is left. On iOS, the Background setting has two types. Solid works the same way, with an opacity slider from 0 to 100%. Liquid Glass turns the button into a piece of glass on top of the map: Clear lets more of the map show through, and Tinted makes it a bit more solid when there's a lot going on behind it.

Every change shows up right away in the preview, so you can play with it until the button feels right, and only then save it.

And if you'd rather not touch the screen with gloves at all, OsmAnd works with external input devices, such as Bluetooth keyboards and WunderLINQ controllers. Their buttons can zoom the map and run Quick Actions, so the voice prompts switch can live on the handlebar instead of the screen.

Button Appearance AndroidButton Appearance iOS

Portrait or Landscape​

Painters had these two words long before phones did. A portrait is tall, a landscape is wide, and nobody expects one picture to work in both. On a motorcycle, you get both in one day. The phone rides sideways on the handlebar, and at a stop you take it in your hand and hold it upright.

By default, OsmAnd uses the same widgets in both orientations, so whatever you set up for the handlebar follows you into portrait too. To keep them apart, turn on Separate layouts on Android or set Screen elements to Independent on iOS. Configure screen then has Portrait and Landscape tabs, and changes in one don't touch the other. You don't have to start from scratch, either: a panel's widget list can be copied from the other orientation and adjusted from there.

Landscape has its own catch. The screen is wide but not very tall, and the top and bottom panels end up right next to the map buttons. Panels layout decides how they share the space. Wide stretches the top and bottom panels across the whole screen, and Compact fits them between the side panels and the map buttons. You can choose it separately for portrait and landscape (on Android, the option appears once Separate layouts is on).

The widgets themselves can be adjusted too, panel by panel: their height, whether icons are shown, text colors for day and night, and the background, which can also be transparent. A custom background color is a paid feature. Each widget also has its own size, Small, Medium or Large. Speed and the next turn are worth making Large, because on the road you read them at a glance. If one panel or another profile already looks the way you like, you can copy its appearance instead of setting everything again. On iOS with Independent screen elements, all of this is set separately for each orientation.

Landscape

A Frame for Every Trip​

All of this belongs to one profile. The screen you put together for the motorcycle stays in the Motorcycle profile, and the ones you use on foot or in the car stay exactly as they were. Nothing you changed for the handlebar follows you into the city.

Even within one profile, the screen doesn't have to look the same all day. The left and right panels can hold up to five pages of widgets, so one page can show what matters on the move and another what you check at a stop.

If another profile should get the same buttons, you don't have to set them up again. In Default buttons, Copy from another profile brings over which buttons are visible and how they look. Custom buttons are shared between profiles, and in each one you just decide whether a button shows up. Switching profiles can be a Quick Action as well, so going from the bike to walking around town takes one tap.

Back to the painting from the beginning. A good frame is the one you don't remember, and after a day on the road, you probably won't remember the buttons either. Just the road.


We appreciate your interest in us and thank you for taking the time to read this article. Join us on social media to keep up to date with the latest news and share your experiences. Your opinion is important to us.

Pluralistic: How to forfeit one of copyright's best labor policies (19 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]

->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->-> Top Sources: None -->

Today's links



A mustachioed gent in a tux sitting on an urban stoop. He is surrounded by long-guns and swords and machetes; he holds a pistol and a rifle; resting on his knees are ammo belts. Behind him in the doorway is a giant antique typewriter and fed into the typewriter is an indistinct typewritten sheet, warped and bent.

How to forfeit one of copyright's best labor policies (permalink)

There's a seeming paradox to copyright. For 50 years (starting with the 1976 Copyright Act) legislatures have monotonically expanded copyright, so that today, copyright lasts longer, covers more works, restricts more activities, and provides for harsher penalties for infringement, all in the name of protecting artists.

After 50 years of this, artists are, on average, poorer than we were in 1976, but the media companies we sell our work to are much, much richer. They're larger and more profitable, and yet our wealth (both in absolute terms and as a share of media company profits) has declined.

This may feel like a paradox, but it's actually easy to understand unless you've had the self-inflicted neurological injury we call "getting an econ degree." That's an injury that leaves the sufferer incapable of reasoning about or even perceiving power.

If you've avoided that fate, then you can see that when an artist sells to one of five publishers, four studios, three labels, two app companies or one ebook/audiobook company, that artist has very little leverage. In that market, giving an artist more to bargain with is just giving them more to bargain away.

I have often compared giving more copyright to creative workers trapped in this oligopoly to giving a bullied schoolchild extra lunch money. No matter how much money you give that kid, they're not going to get fed. The bullies just take whatever money you give to the kid. Indeed, if you indirectly transfer enough money to the bullies, they'll pay for a global ad campaign: THINK OF THE HUNGRY SCHOOLCHILDREN! THEY NEED MORE LUNCH MONEY!

This is exactly what has happened with 50 years of successive copyright expansions. Every time Congress gave a new copyright to creative workers, the cartels we bargain with just amended their non-negotiable contracts to force us to hand over that new right for no extra payment. Then they used those new rights to get richer and more powerful, and to exert more control over the distribution channels we need to reach our audiences, which made us poorer. Then Congress heard their THINK OF THE STARVING ARTISTS pitch, and gave us more copyright…which we promptly handed over to our bosses. Lather, rinse, repeat.

If you want to feed a hungry schoolkid, you have to change the structure of the system. For example, you might open a credit account with the school lunchroom, so that the kid never has any cash for the bullies to take. Likewise, if you want to help artists get more money, you need to make a systemic change.

There are lots of ways to do this. In 2022, Rebecca Giblin and I co-wrote a book called Chokepoint Capitalism, and we devoted half of the book to detailed, shovel-ready proposals for ways to alter the copyright system to benefit artists, not our bosses:

https://www.beacon.org/Chokepoint-Capitalism-P2020.aspx

That section includes a chapter on something called "termination of transfer," which was introduced with the 1976 Copyright Act. Under termination of transfer, any copyright contract (a "transfer") can be unilaterally canceled ("termination") by any creator after 35 years. So even if you sign away your copyrights for the entire term (your life plus 70 years), you can tear up that agreement after 35 years by notifying the company you sold your rights to and then filing some paperwork with the US Copyright Office:

https://pluralistic.net/2021/09/26/take-it-back/

We got really excited about termination. For one thing, Rebecca is one of the world's leading experts on the subject. In 2021, she co-authored the landmark study "U.S. Copyright Termination Notices 1977-2020: Introducing New Datasets," published in the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies:

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3880708

Termination is a uniquely efficient way to make artists richer at the expense of our bosses. The fact that you can only exercise it after 35 years produces some very interesting effects. First, consider that almost no copyrighted works are commercially viable after 35 years (most copyrighted works cease to generate income after 14 years or less, this being the original term of copyright in the USA). The rare works that continue to generate revenue 35 years after their release are the "perennial favorites" that drive a vast share of media industry profits.

Now consider that, between the realities of the human lifespan and the amount of time it takes most artists to master their craft, any given work you produced 35 years ago is almost certainly from the start of your career. That's the moment in which artists are typically most vulnerable. Artists at the start of their careers are unknown quantities and are often crammed into signing terrible deals, even worse than the "standard" media deal.

Put these two facts together and you'll see that termination is disproportionately applicable to a body of work that is wildly profitable for media companies, but the creators of those works are entitled to even less of the money it generates, thanks to the crummy contracts they were railroaded into because they were just starting out when they made them.

Termination lets creators cancel those crummy contracts, take back their rights, and bargain for a better deal with the old media company (or a new one). This time, they bargain from a position of unassailable strength, due to the fact that they're selling a property that's proven itself to be a perennial profit-generator.

Best of all, you can't bargain out of termination. Even if you sign a contract that says, "I promise I will not exercise my termination of transfer right," you can still exercise your termination right. This is a structural change, like the parent who opens a charge account with the school cafeteria so that their kid no longer has any lunch money to hand over to the bullies. The way Congress wrote termination into the 1976 Act, it doesn't matter how hard the media company you initially sign with twists your arm, you literally can't promise them you won't use your termination right 35 years after signing.

That's where that landmark study Rebecca co-authored comes in. Rebecca and her co-authors found that termination was working exactly the way Congress intended: it was making artists richer. It's particularly helpful to marginalized creative workers, for example, Black "heritage" musicians who were railroaded into terrible contracts that meant they never got a dime for decades of airplay, covers and samples of their hits. If this sounds familiar, you might be thinking of my 2024 technothriller The Bezzle, where I use this as a key plot point:

https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865878/thebezzle/

Genre writers have really benefited from termination. The authors of massively popular YA series like The Baby-Sitters Club and Sweet Valley High claimed back their rights under termination. So did Peter Straub and Stephen King, who took back the rights to their early books and resold them on much more favorable terms. Just the threat of termination forced Disney to make giant payouts to Marvel's key creators, like Stan Lee, Steve Ditko and Jack Kirby:

https://deadline.com/2023/12/marvel-court-termination-disney-spider-man-dr-strange-1234843941/

In Chokepoint Capitalism, Rebecca and I point out that most of the 1976 Copyright Act (like longer copyright terms) has failed to help artists, but termination is the rare exception, a proven effective way to put money in artists' pockets. Which is weird, because in the 50 years since the 1976 Act, Congress has repeatedly doubled down on pretty much every measure in the Act, except the one thing that is empirically proven to be good for artists. Of course, all that failed stuff in the 1976 Act is good for giant media companies, and termination is bad for those companies, so it's not hard to see why there's been so little legislative appetite to beef up termination.

But it's also easy to see how we'd do that beefing up. In the original draft of the Copyright Act, termination was automatic, and kicked in after 20 years (meaning that 20 years after signing any contract, every creator would automatically get back all the rights they sold in the contract). The final version of the Act watered down termination so it kicks in after 35 years, and even then only after the artist does a ton of paperwork.

Giving artists the termination rights they were promised in the initial draft of the 1976 Act is a no-brainer. But that's not what we've gotten from Congress. To the extent that Congress acted on termination, it was to take it away from musicians. In 1999, an obscure Congressional staffer named Mitch Glazier snuck a clause into an unrelated bill that made it impossible for most recording artists to exercise their termination rights. This was such a scandal that Congress had to convene a special session to cancel this amendment and restore musicians' rights, and Glazier was drummed out of his Congressional job:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Glazier#Work_for_hire

Don't worry, Glazier landed on his feet: he was immediately hired by the RIAA (the record industry's lobbying arm) as their new CEO and there he perches even today, making more than $1.4m/year to do a job he continues to describe as "defending artists":

https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/131669037

With Glazier as the standard-bearer for "artists' rights," it's no wonder that creators haven't gotten a better deal on termination out of Congress.

Indeed, things are looking very bad for termination of transfer right now, thanks to a string of court decisions that pit a common tax strategy employed by freelance creatives against termination of transfer.

Like many freelancers, creative workers often incorporate limited liability companies that contract with the companies that employ them. These companies then pass the revenue on to creators as "partner distributions." There are lots of reasons to like this arrangement: it simplifies probate and estate planning, helps creators fund their pensions, and offers tax deductions for expenses like a home office or research trips.

This arrangement is especially common in Hollywood, where the companies that writers, directors, and other creative trades work through are called "loan-out companies" (because the company employs the creative, and "loans them out" to movie studios).

Movie studios and other media companies have recently seized on the existence of these loan-out companies to argue (with a great deal of success) that the existence of these loan-out companies nullifies termination of transfer.

You see, termination of transfer is only available for creative works that are independently produced and licensed through a copyright contract. Termination does not apply to "works made for hire," such as the emails and reports you might write in the course of your duties as an employee. The logic here is that termination of transfer is supposed to help artists get more out of their copyrights, but forcing (say) an insurance company to disgorge all the memos you wrote for them 35 years ago would introduce chaos and uncertainty without helping workers in any way (there's not exactly a market for 35-year-old insurance company memos).

The media companies' argument goes that creative workers are employees of their loan-out companies, so if you sell a script or a novel through your LLC, that is a "work made for hire" that the LLC owned, and that means that it can't exercise your termination of transfer rights to get that work back after 35 years.

Aaron Moss, who edits the Copyright Lately website, has been beating the drum about this for years, calling it "a ticking time bomb for copyright-intensive industries." He's been repeatedly vindicated, most recently through a bizarre dispute between Michael Mann, the director and writer of 1995's blockbuster Heat, and New Regency, the studio that released it:

https://copyrightlately.com/michael-mann-heat-copyright-termination/

Moss's article on the dispute is a very entertaining read, unpacking a decidedly weird gambit that Mann has deployed to regain the rights to Heat. But the most important part of the article is the way it describes the state of play for termination's ongoing collision with loan-out companies. The studios and labels have racked up a string of wins using this gambit, with creators settling their cases or losing outright. Take musician John Waite's bid to get his rights back from UMG: the judge ruled in UMG's favor, saying, "people cannot use a corporate structure for some purposes – eg taking advantage of tax benefits – and then disavow it for others":

https://copyrightlately.com/copyright-termination-loan-out-corporations/

This is a bad situation. Termination is a fantastic, artist-friendly legal doctrine, one that lets creators claim back some of our most cherished media. Termination gave George Clinton the rights back to his entire catalog (his sleazy ex-manager forged Clinton's signature on a rights assignment). It let Gary K Wolf take Roger Rabbit back from Disney:

https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/18/im-not-bad/#im-just-drawn-that-way

It let the Spinal Tap crew get a much better deal out of their studio, and paved the way for 2025's (criminally underrated) Spinal Tap II:

https://www.nme.com/news/film/this-is-spinal-tap-creators-and-studiocanal-settle-rights-dispute-2757087

The Wachowskis just announced that they're going to exercise their termination rights to get The Matrix back from Warner Brothers, which is now owned by Trump's cronies, thanks to California Attorney General Rob Bonta's decision to let the Warner-Paramount merger go through:

https://puck.news/hollywood/2026/11/the-wachowskis-are-reclaiming-the-matrix

This clash between termination and loan-outs has been on my radar since 2021, when the artist-defending media lawyer Jeff Trexler told me about it over drinks at Comic-Con. I've since spoken to accountants and lawyers who think there might be a way to finesse this if creators set up contracts with their loan-outs that give the loan-outs the right to collect their royalties and advances, without assigning copyright to the loan-out companies. I don't have any definitive answers on this: if you're worried about it, you should talk to your own lawyers and accountants.

It's a dangerous erosion of one of the few bright spots in copyright, a rule that is an unambiguously good way to benefit artists, not media companies.

In the meantime, if you've got some 35-year-old copyrights you'd like to terminate, I've got a tip for you. The Authors Alliance is a nonprofit that defends the rights of authors (I volunteer for its advisory board); we've got a free online tool that will help you terminate your own transfers and get your rights back:

https://www.authorsalliance.org/resources/termination-of-transfer/


Hey look at this (permalink)



A shelf of leatherbound history books with a gilt-stamped series title, 'The World's Famous Events.'

Object permanence (permalink)

#25yrsago The History of Interlibrary Loan https://web.archive.org/web/20011124021520/https://web.mit.edu/dchud/www/p2p-talk-slides/20011107-p2p-histill.htm

#10yrsago When Mike Pence came to Hamilton, the cast added a special afterword, just for him https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/19/us/mike-pence-hamilton.html

#10yrsago The Snoopers Charter is now law in the UK: “extreme surveillance” rules the land https://web.archive.org/web/20161119071955/https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/nov/19/extreme-surveillance-becomes-uk-law-with-barely-a-whimper

#10yrsago 19 questions to frame a reconciling conversation with your opposite-voting loved ones https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/podcasts/how-could-you-19-questions-to-ask-loved-ones-who-voted-the-other-way.html

#5yrsago Teamsters transformed https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/19/hoffa-jr-defeated/#teamsters-for-a-democratic-union


Upcoming appearances (permalink)

A photo of me onstage, giving a speech, pounding the podium.



A screenshot of me at my desk, doing a livecast.

Recent appearances (permalink)



A grid of my books with Will Stahle covers..

Latest books (permalink)



A cardboard book box with the Macmillan logo.

Upcoming books (permalink)

  • "The Post-American Internet," a geopolitical sequel of sorts to Enshittification, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2027

  • "Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027

  • "Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027

  • "The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027



Colophon (permalink)

Today's top sources:

Currently writing:

  • “Once Is Enemy Action,” a science fiction novel about the origins of modern technofascism. Today's words: 568 (38215 total).

  • "The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.

  • A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING


This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.


How to get Pluralistic:

Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

Pluralistic.net

Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://pluralistic.net/plura-list

Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://mamot.fr/@pluralistic

Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):

https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net

Medium (no ads, paywalled):

https://doctorow.medium.com/

Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):

https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic

"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla

READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.

ISSN: 3066-764X

02:00 AM

Nvidia And The Trump Administration Begin ‘Investigating’ Themselves In Wake Of Blossoming Scandal [Techdirt]

By now I presume everybody has seen how Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has resigned after being caught having multiple overlapping affairs. Two with two different company subordinates, and another with an alleged Chinese spy.

There’s also emerging reporting that Huang may have been helping Nvidia dodge export controls by obfuscating the company’s sales numbers in Singapore (potentially with Howard Lutnick’s help), as well as some growing awareness that the GPU monopoly — as unregulated monopolies in a country without antitrust enforcement tend to do — was intentionally inflating GPU prices to drive artificial scarcity.

As is always the case with this sort of stuff, the scandal is likely to get much worse. And the multiple, overlapping looming investigations (including several of the congressional variety) aren’t likely to restrict themselves simply to extramarital affairs and the alleged Chinese spy.

That’s causing a lot of panic in the AI sector that the hugely profitable GPU monopoly will stop massively subsidizing numerous unprofitable AI companies, exposing the circular, dodgy financing propping up the entire industry. As a result there was a short-lived manufactured effort by guys like Elon Musk and David Sacks over the weekend to demonize the journalists behind the story, frame the whole thing as a conspiracy, and have Huang reinstated before the check comes due for their funny financial math.

The Nvidia board has made it clear they’re not willing to take that risk and put Huang back in place before they know the full scope of what Huang was up to. It would be legal suicide to do otherwise. Huang, for his part, issued a statement saying that he had spent a few days atoning for multiple affairs and potential national security violations, and was ready to get back to work!

after several painful minutes of self-reflection i am willing to return to my position of power and prestige

— shauna (@goldengateblond.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T16:52:26.451Z

I’m personally fascinated with some of the policy reporting around this story related to the looming Trump “investigations” into Nvidia (and ultimately itself). Like this Wall Street Journal story, which indicates that the Trump SEC has “launched an investigation” into Nvidia — but doesn’t bother to inform readers that the SEC has largely been hollowed out by Trump and his corrupt judicial appointments.

You’ll notice the same treatment over at Semafor, which informs us that the Trump DOJ antitrust division has launched an “investigation” into Nvidia (which again, would never have this amount of linchpin power in a country with functional antitrust enforcement):

“One of those probes, on antitrust grounds, is focused specifically on the chipmaker, these people say, while two other inquiries focus on tech companies Megaspeed and Supermicro. The Megaspeed and Supermicro probes have focused on the involvement of Alice Huang, an alleged Chinese spy that Huang admitted to having an extramarital affair with before he resigned. There’s no indication that the DOJ would seek to charge Nvidia, or Huang, criminally at this time.”

Semafor curiously doesn’t think it’s important to note that the Trump administration doesn’t do antitrust enforcement. Or that multiple, previous reports (including at the Wall Street Journal) showed that it was trivial for a tech lobbyist to convince the administration to purge the handful of MAGA-loyalists (like Gail Slater) with even a passing interesting in antitrust reform or reining in monopolists.

The stories reflect at worst a complicity, and at best a strange normalization bias among U.S. journalists, who feel compelled to pretend that U.S. regulators still function in the public interest and haven’t been hollowed out like a cheap Dollar Store chocolate Easter bunny by Trumpism. It clashes strangely with the quality journalism at major outlets that exposed the scandal in the first place.

For whatever it’s worth, Nvidia is trying to comfort everybody by claiming it is busy investigating itself for wrongdoing. The company also announced it had created a committee designed to monitor itself for export control violations (read: pretend that they can self regulate and that government oversight isn’t necessary).

Democrats meanwhile have been warning everybody involved in the blossoming scandal — including Howard Lutnick — to retain all the documents for investigations in the new year. Early indications are that Lutnick may have been helping Nvidia dodge the Trump administration’s incoherent and often xenophobic AI chipset export controls to his own personal benefit.

Hopefully Democrats don’t fuck this up. But you definitely get the sense there are a lot more sordid details to come, with multiple, massive overlapping implications for everyone in the new year.

Thursday 2026-11-19

10:00 PM

Take-Two Targets Hundreds of GTA V Mobile Ports on GitHub Ahead of GTA VI Launch [TorrentFreak]

GTA 5 logoAfter a series of delays, Grand Theft Auto VI finally goes on sale today, more than thirteen years after its predecessor came out.

While fans count down the final hours, Take-Two Interactive is still busy with GTA V.

Yesterday, GitHub published four takedown notices from the company, targeting unofficial ports of the 2013 game that allow it to run on iPhones, Macs, Android phones and Windows PCs.

These ports trace back to early October, when GTA V suddenly became playable in a regular web browser. An unofficial port of the game at playgta5.com went viral on social media. That didn’t last, as the website disappeared within hours.

At the time, press reports credited Rockstar and Take-Two with the removal, but neither company commented on it. Reports that the port was built with help from leaked GTA V source code have not been confirmed either.

While the port was shot down in hours, the genie was out of the bottle and the WebAssembly build of the game lived on. Within days, developers turned this into native apps for Apple devices and Android phones, which were widely shared on GitHub.

Four Notices, Hundreds of Forks

The notices, sent by Rockstar’s parent company Take-Two, target four projects. These are the iOS and macOS port Muguet, the multi-platform runtime glue5, the Android port gta5mobile-android, and three repositories from the developer behind PlayGTA5.

According to Take-Two’s DMCA notices

Project (links to notice) Platforms Forks (per Take-Two) Alleged infringement
Muguet iOS, macOS 263 Infringes and facilitates infringement; “bring your own files” disclaimer
glue5 iOS, macOS, Android, Windows 349 Build workflow on GitHub; streaming of roughly 20 GB of game files
gta5mobile-android Android 14 or 16 (18 repositories listed) APK downloads and tools to load and run the game
PlayGTA5, gtav-mobile, playgta5-enhanced Browser, Android, iOS Not stated Full game (21.2 GB) offered in a GitHub release

In the Muguet notice, Take-Two quotes the project’s own instructions, which tell users to supply their own game files.

“Because I care about me not getting sued, you will need your own copy,” the developer wrote, according to the notice. Take-Two reads this as a confirmation that the developer is aware of potential copyright concerns. “That statement expresses awareness of Take-Two’s rights and what they are facilitating,” the notice adds.

The PlayGTA5 notice goes further. According to Take-Two, a release published in the PlayGTA5 repository on October 9 offered the full game, which totals 21.2 GB.

Before the takedown, the repository’s README file also mentioned that the game data was included in its GitHub release downloads, explaining that some files were too large for regular commits. The developer archived the repository on October 15.

In addition to the main repositories, Take-Two also asks GitHub to disable all their forks, including 263 Muguet forks and 349 glue5 forks by its own count. GitHub’s published notices don’t say how many repositories it processed, but it’s likely several hundred.

When we checked this morning, the Muguet, glue5 and PlayGTA5 repositories, as well as the copies and forks we’ve seen, all showed a DMCA takedown “unavailable” message. The first gta5mobile-android repository listed in the notice now returns a ‘page not found’ error, which typically means that the developer took it offline of made it private.

Unavailable

unavailable

“This repository is currently disabled due to a DMCA takedown notice,” the messages read, adding that developers “have the right to file a counter notice and have the repository reinstated.”

‘Bring Your Own’ Disclaimers

The Muguet, glue5 and gta5mobile-android projects all relied on users supplying the game files themselves. The ‘own copy’ in question is the data of the unofficial web port, not a regular PC or console installation.

The PlayGTA5 case aside, the notices don’t claim that the targeted repositories host Take-Two’s code or game files. Instead, they say that the projects infringe, and that they facilitate copyright infringement.

GitHub Takedown

takedown

Take-Two’s notice against glue5 is more detailed. It describes a GitHub build process that turns the web build users provide into apps, and a streaming option that can transfer roughly 20 GB of game files, including a “Download the whole game” feature.

According to Take-Two, the disclaimers aren’t enough. All four notices make this point, and two of them use the same words: “bring your own” disclaimers “do not automatically shield developers from secondary copyright liability where their conduct knowingly facilitates infringement.”

Bring your own files

bring your own

One Port Survives

Not all GTA V ports were targeted. The 5★ Port, which runs the same web build on iPhones and Macs, went offline in late October, according to PortedGames. It returned in early November and was still online this morning. However, the project no longer offers a way to build the app through GitHub’s workflow system.

The project’s README even invites rights holders to get in touch by email, promising that the repository will be removed promptly.

Not Affiliated

rightsholders

For the targeted developers, not everything is lost. They can file a DMCA counter-notice, after which GitHub has to restore the code, unless Take-Two takes the matter to court.

That has worked before. When the developers of the GTA multiplayer mod Multi Theft Auto disputed a takedown notice reportedly sent by Take-Two last December, no lawsuit followed and GitHub restored the repository.

However, a counter-notice also brought the reverse-engineered GTA code re3 back in 2021. A few months later, Take-Two sued its developers, partly over the counter-notices themselves.

The notices, which GitHub published a day before the release of GTA VI, don’t explain the timing. Whether it’s a coincidence or not is unknown, but Take-Two clearly sees them a threat.

—

Take-Two’s four DMCA notices are available on GitHub and linked in the table above.

From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.

03:00 PM

America Loses Measles Elimination Status As Death Toll Rises To 10 [Techdirt]

As America’s measles crisis continues to rage on, and even ramp up, we discussed recently that international health groups would be meeting this week to decide if the country will lose its measles elimination status. Thanks to the federal government’s complete failure to act on this crisis, the outcome of that meeting always seemed like a foregone conclusion. In the days since publishing that post, two things have happened: word leaked that the WHO would in fact rescind the elimination status for measles and the death toll from measles this year rose to 10.

First, the embarrassment that is our loss of status.

With outbreaks that have been smoldering and flaring since last year, the US has reportedly lost its measles elimination status—as medical and public health experts have widely expected it would. A panel of experts for the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), a regional branch of the World Health Organization, convened last week to review US measles data and assess its elimination status. The PAHO is set to announce its conclusion and the review’s other findings on Tuesday, November 17. But sources broke the news to The Wall Street Journal on Friday that the panel had found that the US had indeed lost its status.

The US earned its elimination status in 2000 after hard-fought vaccination campaigns over several decades. But US vaccination rates have slipped below protective levels in recent years, fueled by the rise of anti-vaccine rhetoric and vaccine misinformation from fierce anti-vaccine advocates, including current US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. As vaccination rates slipped, measles cases skyrocketed. The current case tally is the highest seen since 1991.

While this is unsurprising, it’s still painful to witness the country take such a massive and preventable step backwards in public health. Putting the anti-vaxxers in charge is how you get the return of measles. Putting the anti-vaxxer’s scion in charge of the nation’s health is how you get more people sick.

And doing all of the above is how you get more people dying of diseases that could have been easily prevented with collective action to achieve herd immunity.

Health officials in Pennsylvania and Wisconsin announced two more measles deaths late last week, bringing the national tally of confirmed measles deaths this year to 10. The total includes the deaths of at least four infants: two in Pennsylvania, one in New York, and one in Wisconsin.

In reporting the PAHO’s determination, the Journal quoted Noel Brewer, chair of an independent US committee who presented findings about the country’s measles outbreaks to PAHO, on the country’s lamentable status: “Runaway measles outbreaks in the United States, as well as the needless deaths, are all due to low measles vaccination coverage. We’ve gotten comfortable letting children be stopped by a deadly disease and die from it.”

Just…let that sink in for a moment. We are still not doing anything at the level of the federal government about the measles situation in America because we’ve gotten “comfortable” with children, some of them too young to be vaccinated even if their parents wanted them to be, getting sick and dying.

There’s a lot to be angry about in our current state in America. A lot. But sick and dying children sure should be at the forefront of that anger. Appointing Kennedy as HHS Secretary is a mistake so obvious it barely needs stating. But what was Kennedy’s reaction to the GOP’s historic midterm loss? How is he dealing with the announcement that Stephen Goebbels Miller would be taking over as Trump’s Chief of Staff?

Miller, a right-wing hardliner, and Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the Trump administration’s unconventional health and human services secretary, met last week for dinner with their wives at the Millers’ home. There, Miller reportedly made a “radical” promise to RFK Jr., which the Kennedy scion later divulged to a room of Make America Healthy Again activists.

“During that dinner, [Miller] said to me, ‘I’m the only one in the administration who’s more radical than you are on MAHA,'” Kennedy said at an event hosted by the advocacy group MAHA Action, according to The Washington Post.

Kennedy celebrated Miller’s promotion and Susie Wiles’ ouster, declaring on social media: “Next to me, Stephen Miller is the strongest MAHA supporter in the administration. It’s time to unleash the Kraken.”

These cretins are somehow, in the shadow of tiny little funeral caskets being lowered into the ground alongside children that died from a preventable disease, pledging to make things worse. Kennedy is so maniacally sociopathic that he can’t handle being wrong and must double down on his bullshit beliefs and policies. What Miller is up to is anyone’s guess, though it’s not hard to believe that a shared belief in eugenics with Kennedy has something to do with it.

But these are just two men. Horrible, terrible men, to be sure, but just two men. They only get away with this if we let them.

Don’t. Don’t let them. No more children should die from measles.

Patch Me If You Can [The Status Kuo]

Image courtesy of Reuters

It’s been a Skynet preview kind of week. Emails around the world went down on Thursday, with users in more than 70 countries reporting that Microsoft Outlook had failed. Then thousands of flights sat on the tarmac or at gates on Friday afternoon during the FAA’s longest nationwide ground stop since 9/11. By Monday, customers at major banks—Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, U.S. Bank and Truist—reported problems accessing accounts, while United delayed departing flights for about 90 minutes. On Tuesday, iPhones were hit as Apple’s iCloud, App Store and Apple Music stumbled, and a classified network at the NSA went down. For good measure, hackers slipped code designed to steal credit card details onto the websites of 178 organizations.

The outages came with frustratingly unremarkable explanations from the companies and agencies: a network upgrade, a router, a software release, an internal update, routine maintenance. Everyone says no cyberattack was involved.

Good news, but there was still no getting around the magnitude and frequency of what was happening. And the more conspiracy-prone began stoking fears. “Americans aren’t stupid,” posted Tricia McLaughlin, the former assistant secretary for public affairs at the Department of Homeland Security, tempting fate with that one. “We want and deserve to know what’s really going on.” Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) added his own kindling, telling reporters that if “this is all a coincidence, it’s like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world.” (I’m reminded here of the saying that everything is a conspiracy when you don’t understand how anything works.)

On cue, Fox News saw another ratings opportunity—better than mystery drones in the sky!—and has been feeding the skepticism. Host Jesse Watters told viewers Monday that the string of outages was “a little eerie,” adding, “What are the chances of all this happening in the same couple of weeks? Why is every computer on the fritz?”

It turns out the chances are good. And there’s a fairly straightforward explanation. I was excited when I thought I had come up with it on my own yesterday. Hooray for pattern-recognition skills! But then within hours, my theory got scooped by the Washington Sun and a few online experts. At least they confirmed my (non)-expert suspicions.

AI, they claim, isn’t the direct cause of these crashes and outages. But it likely plays an important role, and we all need to understand what that is.

Subscribe now

Blame the toasters!

The natural inclination these days when anything goes bigly wrong in a large system is to blame AI. The government isn’t helping. Indeed, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin floated the idea on Fox News that the FAA’s ground stop was AI-driven.

But Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA), the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, offered a different theory yesterday, and it starts with AI doing its job well. The latest AI tools excel at finding flaws in software, sometimes in about an hour. And that has become a big headache.

“Because some of the AI tools have discovered so many vulnerabilities,” Warner said, “companies and others are rushing to patch all those vulnerabilities and if you’re suddenly trying to push through the system, literally dozens of patches at a time, that increases the chance for the kind of… flaws that are taking place.”

Tuesday evening, that theory got its first press confirmation. Jeff Stein reported in the Washington Sun that Wall Street executives and the NSA had told lawmakers privately that their outages came from attempts to fix flaws that AI had found.

To this I’d add one intriguing fact. Three of the big companies that stumbled this week share another distinction: They were among the few firms Anthropic gave early access to a powerful bug-finding model in April.

Mullin’s house call

Mullin, who had already told reporters Friday that government upgrades overwhelmed the FAA’s older system, went on “Hannity” Monday night to tell Americans to breathe, putting the odds of a cyberattack at about 2 percent. Then he shared a theory from a tech-industry contact who asked to remain anonymous and who, Mullin felt he needed to specify, was someone other than Elon Musk. Mullin said the contact told him, “I believe that it’s the SI”—the regime’s awkward but preferred shorthand for “super intelligence,” which the White House keeps trying to make happen.

Mullin’s colleagues were on a different page. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford had said two days earlier that he saw “zero evidence of anything AI-related” in the ground stop, and Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the agency’s new AI traffic tool played no role.

As Mullin relayed it, his contact described software that writes and repairs its own code, running faster than older systems can handle. Mullin then offered up an image. “When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing,” he told Hannity. Fortune’s Nick Lichtenberg observed that the house line sounds more like the companies’ own explanations than like a rogue superintelligence, but hey. By Tuesday, thankfully, Mullin had dropped the superintelligence references. He told CNBC that new technology is being pushed onto very old computer systems and warned that more outages are coming.

Mullin speaks like someone who understands neither the problem nor the solution, let alone how the solution is causing new problems. And his off-the-cuff remarks are feeding public hysteria at a time when we need cooler heads with bigger brains in them. But his last statement, in fairness, isn’t far off the mark.

The man, the mythos

In April, I listened to an episode of the Hard Fork podcast in which the hosts discussed Anthropic’s launch of a new AI model called Claude Mythos Preview. Anthropic claimed the model was better than all but the most skilled human experts at finding security holes in software and at figuring out how to break in through them. (Disclaimer: My family’s company made a modest investment in Anthropic back in 2024, when AI was still mostly about chatbots.)

Then came the wild part. The company decided the model was too risky to release to the public, since bad actors could use it to find vulnerabilities in computer systems at major banks and other institutions. So it gave early access to about a dozen large partners and more than 40 other organizations that maintain widely used software. The idea was that they could find and repair their own weak spots first, before the tool fell into the wrong hands.

By Anthropic’s account, the model delivered. In a May 22 update, the company said about 50 partners had used it to find more than 10,000 serious security flaws, and that Mozilla had fixed 271 in a single release of its Firefox browser. The update also carried a warning: Finding the holes had become the easy part, Anthropic said; the hard part was the human work of confirming and repairing them. Some software maintainers had asked the company to slow down.

OpenAI, the maker of ChatGPT, said much the same a month later when it expanded its own program for security teams. “The bottleneck is now patching vulnerabilities,” the company wrote.

Security professionals warned early about where this could lead. In May, The Register’s Jessica Lyons reported that Palo Alto Networks, a cybersecurity company that typically finds about five flaws a month in its own products, had found 75 after scanning its code with the newest AI models. Katie Moussouris, a veteran security executive, told Lyons that the expensive part is building fixes that leave working systems intact and getting customers to install them, and that “nobody has funded it for this volume.” Another expert warned that customers who already distrust software updates would trust them even less if AI-related fixes started breaking things.

The number of fixes has climbed since. Microsoft’s monthly security updates repaired 1,413 flaws in October and 1,094 in November, its two largest monthly totals ever. Whether that pressure played a part in this week’s outages was, until Tuesday evening, an open question.

One hour, two hundred dollars

On Tuesday, the same day Apple’s services stumbled, CyberScoop’s Greg Otto reported that researchers had used AI to uncover a serious security hole in Java. This made me sit up.

Most people never see Java. It’s software that runs quietly behind a great deal of the technology we use every day. (Confusingly, Java has no relation to JavaScript, the web language used in this week’s card-theft attack.) The security firm that found the hole, Calif, says Java is in use at about 90 percent of Fortune 500 companies, including in banking, aviation and telecom.

So, no bueno.

According to Otto’s report, a Calif researcher named Quang Luong set OpenAI’s coding tool, Codex, loose on Java’s code. The tool turned up the problem in about an hour, at a cost of under $200. Calif rated the flaw a 9.2 on the industry’s 10-point, Richter-like severity scale, though Oracle scored it lower, at 8.1, calling it difficult to exploit. Luong said an attacker could use it to take over a server without needing a password. (Think about that.) The firm’s own write-up said the hunt felt like “looking for copper and found gold.”

Oracle, which maintains Java, released a fix the same day as part of an update covering 652 flaws across its products, Otto reported.

Java4Shell, as the flaw is called, was Calif’s second AI-assisted discovery in recent weeks. After the first one, known as PHP2Shell, many websites were deliberately taken offline while their operators installed emergency fixes, the security firm Malwarebytes reported.

Reading the tea leaves

According to the Washington Sun piece, government and banking officials told lawmakers that the fixes temporarily overwhelmed their systems. A congressional official briefed on the matter told Stein, “They’re trying to push through a lot of patches all at once.” The account covers the banks and the NSA. It leaves out Microsoft, and Stein reported that the cause of the FAA’s failure remains unclear.

On the record, the theory has an unexpected backer. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told Fox Business that the outages were likely the result of system upgrades that went wrong, with no sign of a coordinated attack. “This is just an upgrade in patching, an upgrade in systems,” he said.

The companies themselves have said far less, and that’s understandable. Microsoft blamed a bug dating to July that surfaced after a network change. JPMorgan Chase cited a software bug, and the FBI traced the trouble to a software release the bank put out that day. Apple pointed to an “internal update.” The NSA described routine maintenance. None of them has said publicly what the release, the update or the maintenance contained, or whether security fixes were part of it.

As I hinted earlier, Microsoft, Apple and JPMorgan Chase all appear on Anthropic’s list of launch partners for the bug-finding tool Mythos. Perhaps the companies with the earliest access to the strongest tool also had the most repairs to make, but that’s something only the companies would know.

It’s life

Asked Monday about the ground stop, Trump told reporters, “I don’t take any responsibility,” and blamed old equipment and his predecessors. Asked Tuesday in the Philippines about the wider run of outages, he said, “It’s life, it’s life.” He added, “When you’re big and powerful and you have all the money, things like that happen. It’s fine.”

That’s not reassuring.

Even his former press secretary wanted more. Karoline Leavitt, who left the White House over the summer and joined Fox News as a contributor this month, said on “Fox & Friends” Tuesday that the regime needs to be transparent about what is happening.

Some lawmakers have now heard privately from banks and the NSA, the Washington Sun reported. Others are asking for a full accounting. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY) called for a briefing of both chambers, and Hawley wants the full Senate briefed. But briefings may be harder to come by. A day before those calls, Axios and PBS News each reported on a memo from White House counsel Will Scharf directing every federal agency to get White House approval before agreeing to testify before congressional committees.

The regime has also spent the past year clearing the road for the AI industry. Last December, Trump signed an executive order aimed at stopping states from writing their own AI rules. Gary Marcus, a professor emeritus at New York University and a longtime AI critic, wrote Tuesday that he doubts the public is getting the full story on these outages, and he urged the government to require prompt and candid reports from any organization seriously affected.

Breaking and entering

I take only small comfort in knowing that AI is not the direct cause of these outages but is putting companies and agencies in a position where such system failures become inevitable. And in the AI-driven patching war against vulnerabilities and bugs, it isn’t clear who will come out on top.

Nicole Perlroth, the former New York Times cybersecurity reporter, posted a long thread about the outages, noting that AI now lets attackers find and use software flaws far faster than software makers can fix them. By her account, AI has tripled the number of flaws being discovered compared with the same period last year, and powerful AI-driven attack tools have landed in the hands of minor governments and ordinary criminals.

That, she wrote, puts enormous pressure on companies to patch faster, which raises the odds that a fix breaks something. She is also hearing that the firms companies normally call after a break-in are backlogged six months.

Perlroth warned that we now depend on software almost nobody understands from end to end, and she asked whether, in the name of progress, we have built “the ripest attack surface in human history.”

If things get much worse, Trump might even promise that the problems will disappear one day, just as he said during the pandemic.

But hey, no biggie. “It’s life, it’s life,” right?

10:00 AM

Can You Regulate ‘Fairness’? The EU’s Digital Fairness Act Is Going To Try [Techdirt]

Last week the EU presented its long-awaited “Digital Fairness Act” proposal, an attempt to expand its consumer protection laws to deal with what it believes are shady practices online. Now, you might be thinking that the EU already has a ton of internet laws — the GDPR, the ePrivacy Directive, the DSA, the DMA, the AI Act, and more — with somewhat mixed results. And you’d be right. But that’s not going to slow down the EU.

Dealing with scammy practices online is a laudable goal, but there are a lot of ways that could go wrong, especially if the end result is just giving more control to the biggest companies to “get things right” rather than letting users themselves control their own data and experiences online.

As with many EU proposals, there’s a lot in this proposal that will likely get support, because it targets a bunch of things that people claim to hate. And, some of what the Commission lays out actually looks good:

  • A ban on manipulative marketing tactics (so-called “dark patterns”) such as fake claims that a product is almost sold out that pressure consumers into purchasing decisions they might not otherwise make.
  • Clear and transparent pricing, particularly prices of purchases made with virtual in-app currencies and when dynamic pricing is used for cultural and sports events. In virtual queues, companies will have to show the current price in real time and the highest possible price.
  • Fairness by design, with the option for consumers to turn off addictive design features that encourage excessive or compulsive spending, such as persistent prompts. The proposal will also restrict unfair practices that encourage overspending, for example by banning gambling-like features for minors, such as pay-to-win and pay-to-progress.
  • Clear disclosure of influencer marketing, requiring influencers to be transparent about commercial content and preventing the exploitation of the trust of minors in their audience.
  • A restriction on unfair personalised ads and prices that target minors or take advantage of sensitive data.
  • Digital contracts and subscriptions that are easier to cancel and an end to unwanted automatic renewals and free trials turning into subscription traps. Consumers will have the right to communicate with a human in customer service and will have clear rights when using an AI agent to buy products on their behalf.

The key aspect of the proposal — and this is the subject of a lot of debate on both sides — is that it won’t ban most of the so-called “addictive” features (though it does ban a specific list of so-called “dark patterns”) but would require companies to give consumers the option of turning those features off. To me, that’s better than an outright ban, which would create lots of issues, but others complain that this then puts the burden on the user. Of course, one person’s “burden on the user” is another’s “user empowerment,” so it depends a bit on through which prism you view all this. I’d rather put control in users’ hands than give companies more levers to pull.

Giving people the option to turn off these features actually seems like a mostly reasonable compromise. Many of the practices described above… absolutely suck. And being able to opt out of them seems good, though the devil is very much in the details. And some of the features being targeted can actually be useful in certain circumstances. I’ve talked about how the claims of “addictive design” are often quite overblown — mainly in confusing “addiction” and “habits.”

And that can become problematic, because in addition to bad habits, there can also be good habits — and there are even specialized tools out there designed to help you learn good habits, like getting regular exercise, or practicing mindfulness, or getting a good night’s sleep. Just as an example, Wired notes that a language-learning service like Duolingo or an exercise app like Strava might both be negatively impacted by the law. Both apps rely on features (like Duolingo’s infamous streaks) that nudge you to keep up with your language-learning and exercise habits. And, generally speaking, most people consider that a good thing. If it remains optional to turn these features off, then I guess that’s fine, though it still feels out of place in apps literally designed to try to get you to establish a habit (not an “addiction.”) At the very least, it will require they spend a bunch of engineering time to build a tool to turn off the main reason why people use those apps.

But also, what starts as an “option” to turn off can quickly become required under the law. Indeed, some of the complaints about the proposal that we’re seeing are that many wish there were outright bans, rather than the option to turn off. Of course, in that same article, others are complaining that the existing rules are already too much of a regulatory burden, so you can see there will be efforts to pull the proposal in both directions as the negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council heat up over the final rules.

The group EDRi, who does amazingly good consumer digital rights work in the EU, is largely supportive of the EU’s push to stop anti-consumer tricks online, but warns that the way the law is written might just create a repeat of the “cookie banner” nonsense, which was written to deal with a legitimate concern (people giving up privacy without realizing what they were doing) but when it came to implementation, resulted in just… annoying everyone and doing little to actually protect privacy.

As EDRi’s Itxaso Domínguez de Olazábal points out, the end result of that fiasco was to generally turn the public against efforts to actually protect privacy, and there’s some fear that the same could happen here:

There is also a too familiar political risk: we’ve spent years watching companies turn cookie consent from a perfectly valid legal and protective basis into an obstacle course, only for the resulting frustration to become an argument against EU privacy and data protection regulation.

Now imagine another set of inconvenient controls, confusing settings and repeated choices: people will inevitably become frustrated, industry will complain about Brussels ruining the user experience, and eventually someone will suggest weakening the rules (they will call it ‘simplification,’ though). I’d rather we didn’t repeat that exercise.

There are also bits in the proposal targeting video game “loot boxes” and “pay-to-win” features, which… definitely feel more scammy. The proposal seeks to ban them in games targeted at children and provide much more clear transparency about what’s going on for adult gamers. Of course, the video game industry is already out complaining about these rules, but given how much of the world has been taken over by subtle attempts to make people gamble away everything they have… I’m not as convinced that rules on those kinds of things are as problematic as the industry makes them out to be.

It also looks like the proposal did not take up the request to include the “stop killing games” proposal as a part of the DFA, though that may also be subject to change during the negotiation.

In the end, I have a mixed opinion on much of this. I agree with most people that the scammy tactics some companies use really suck and make everyone’s life worse. But I’m skeptical you can legislate “fairness” broadly in a way that won’t backfire long term (see: cookie banners) or that takes into account all the edge cases. I’d prefer they target specific, proven, malicious behavior rather than writing sweeping rules.

Part of the problem is that politicians can’t seem to think of the internet as anything more than Facebook, Instagram, X, and TikTok. To them, everything is social media, so anything that keeps you engaged must be “bad” and “addictive.” They legislate with that in mind, and when other services (Duolingo, Strava, etc.) push back, the fix is to make the rules “opt-out” rather than an outright ban. But that still puts compliance costs on those services, and it could also lead to some services never being built at all.

A better solution, as always, is for people to have more overall control over their digital experiences, and I worry that laws like this could actually make that harder, because the compliance costs that giants can easily absorb can price out the smaller companies that are often the ones giving users more control in the first place. Small companies are already pointing out that this could really harm them, noting that the compliance costs are large, but they’re generally not the ones doing really scammy tactics in the first place. So to them, this would make them bear the cost, without much benefit to their users.

Yes, giving users the option to turn off certain features would be a step towards more user control, which I appreciate, but the broadness of the law and the mandate makes me worry about how it will be gamed by the largest players, and prove too costly for the smaller ones.

Indeed, we keep seeing big companies (and their lobbyists) shape these rules to benefit themselves long term, while leaving smaller competitors unable to comply.

That is to say that I appreciate the underlying goals of this regulation, and agree that the state of the internet today often sucks. But that doesn’t mean that this regulation will actually make things any better — and there’s a decent enough chance it could make things worse.

07:00 AM

Automakers Ramp Up Scare-Mongering Push To Ban Chinese EVs. You Know, ‘For Privacy’ [Techdirt]

Automakers are aggressively ramping up their efforts to pass a new law outright banning Chinese EVs. They obviously want to do this because they don’t want to compete with better, often significantly cheaper products, but they can’t just say that. Instead, we get a lot of bizarre pretense about how an industry with the worst privacy ratings in America is just super concerned about privacy.

The Alliance for Automotive Innovation (AAI), which ​represents GM, Toyota, Volkswagen, and other domestic and foreign car makers already doing business in the U.S., are wasting no time in calling for a permanent ban on Chinese EVs after the midterm elections.

The auto industry’s preferred new law, the Connected Vehicle Security Act of 2026, cleared the Senate Commerce Committee in July, and a House version of the bill now has more than 100 co-sponsors. Last September, Senate bill sponsors, Sens. Bernie Moreno (a Republican) and Elissa Slotkin (a Democrat), agreed to delay efforts to fast-track the legislation until this month.

To goad additional lawmakers into action, AAI boss John Bozzella is ramping up the fear mongering in public statements, and routinely brings up privacy and national security concerns as the industry’s primary motivation:

“We need to ​protect the US market from a flood of Chinese imports that carry ​surveillance risk and disadvantage current manufacturers that have made generational investments in ⁠American communities.”

If there’s going to be rampant unchecked surveillance abuses, they should most assuredly be domestic only, I guess.

This idea that Chinese EVs pose some unique privacy and national security threat to Americans is a common refrain from Bozzella and the auto industry. The argument is that Chinese EVs will collect oceans of data on American consumer driving and behavior habits, then funnel that data back to the Chinese government, who’ll then engage in all manner of ambiguous, nefarious behaviors.

There are several problems with the argument.

The biggest being that these same automakers do a disastrous job securing their own vehicles. Studies repeatedly show that U.S. automakers have some of the worst privacy and security standards in all of tech. An ocean of U.S. consumer driving, behavior, phone, and location data is already hoovered up at scale by your car, often left unencrypted, and sold to a laundry list of dodgy partners (including insurance companies, which will jack up your rates based on your driving habits with no transparency into the process).

The other problem: the U.S. is routinely too corrupt to pass modern internet privacy laws or even competently regulate a vast international web of dodgy data brokers. Most of the data collected by U.S. vehicle makers is already available via these data brokers; who’ll in turn sell this data to literally any random nitwit with two nickels to rub together (including Chinese intelligence).

Failing to secure your own vehicles and fighting tooth and nail against any privacy safeguards… then ranting incoherently about the threat of Chinese tech on U.S. shores is not serious tech policy. Our failure to regulate data brokers or pass modern privacy laws means the Chinese simply buy this same data from any of dozens of dodgy companies already, making a lot of this stuff lazy pantomime.

Unfortunately, this kind of lazy protectionism is a truly bipartisan affair. You saw how Democrats tripped over themselves to help Trump’s billionaire friends steal TikTok under the pretense this would somehow make Americans safer, more secure, and less prone to propaganda.

Democratic lawmakers in Michigan also recently tried to ban Chinese EVs from even visiting the state, suggesting that automakers are afraid of Americans even looking at cheaper overseas alternatives. The justification (by folks who are are, again, completely absent when it comes to any sort of domestic U.S. privacy standards and enforcement) is they were just very concerned about U.S. consumer privacy.

I get the impulse to try and protect U.S. domestic automaker jobs (even though U.S. automakers have a long and detailed history of anti-labor behaviors), but there’s simply no coherent consistency to any U.S. policies. We don’t meaningfully protect labor generally, we don’t enforce consumer protection law, we’re too corrupt to pass a privacy law that reins in data monetization and hyper surveillance, and U.S. policymakers largely pay empty lip service to concepts like “affordability.”

We’ll see how much the new Democratic blood in the House and Senate shifts some of these dynamics, but as it stands now you can expect the new year to be filled with the brim with all sorts of expanded bipartisan xenophobic protectionism across the entirety of tech — from AI to electric vehicles. Ignoring that it will be bumbling Trump zealots like Brendan Carr tasked with a lot of enforcement (see: Carr’s rank incompetence surrounding the Chinese drone ban).

And you can expect all of it to be propped up by bad faith arguments that the bill backers are exclusively, suddenly, and very uncharacteristically concerned about your personal privacy. And in turn propped up by a shitty tech press oddly oblivious to their own nationalism biases.

I maintain that the best path forward is to allow Chinese drones, AI, EVs, vacuums, and assorted other tech into the U.S. market, but properly fund, staff, and legally support our privacy, labor, competition, and consumer protection regulators to ensure a level playing field and healthy markets. Large corporations hate that idea, so instead we get this bizarre and performative protectionist pantomime.

NYC Mayor Mamdani Disbands NYPD Unit That Treated Protesters Like Terrorists [Techdirt]

It’s taken pretty much forever, but finally one of the NYPD’s worst specialist units is being disbanded. The catalyst here was the election of a mayor who was finally serious about holding the NYPD in check. For years, the city’s mayors have done whatever they can to keep the cop shop happy, including the last mayor, who went deep down a corruption hole to make sure both he and NYPD remained happy, even if his constituents weren’t.

Here’s what’s happening to the NYPD’s “Strategic Response Group” now that the city is run by a mayor that’s not going to allow a decade-plus of constant civil rights abuses to continue.

A controversial New York Police Department unit accused of using excessive force against protesters has been disbanded, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Monday, fulfilling a key campaign promise from the mayor to separate protest policing from counterterrorism.

Along with the elimination of the Strategic Response Group, certain aggressive crowd-management tactics are now banned and new dialogue-focused units will be established in the NYPD and the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety to ensure a coordinated response to protests, the mayor and commissioner said in a statement.

If you’re wondering about the controversy of this particular unit, you have to take a trip in the wayback machine to 2015, which was when NYPD Commissioner and the mayor who never was the reformer he pretended to be (Bill de Blasio) decided a single unit could handle three very different aspects of policing, somehow without causing collateral damage to Constitutional rights. (Or maybe they didn’t actually belive this and chose to do it anyway.)

The SRG got folded in with an existing counterterrorism unit, apparently because the mayor and police commissioner decided fighting terrorism and policing protests was roughly the same thing. A few years later, documents obtained by journalists made it clear SRG officers were routinely brutalizing peaceful protesters. This wasn’t much of a surprise, considering its counterterrorism unit was known for routinely violating rights while engaging in extremely biased policing/surveillance. That this infection would spread to the SRG is completely unsurprising. Bad apples, etc.

This unit should have been disbanded once this information was made public. But it wasn’t. Given that regular NYPD patrol officers are just as capable of violating people’s rights, it hardly made sense to provide specialist pay for rote thuggery. But the SRG kept on keeping on… right up until NYC residents made it explicitly clear they were sick of the same old bullshit from their mayors.

The disbanding of this unit has the support of the current police commissioner. And it goes further than just rearranging some deck chairs so SRG officers can get back to the rights-violation business elsewhere. It also establishes a “First Amendment Support Team” in the NYPD that will help train and support officers who are asked to police protests.

In addition, “kettling” protesters is no longer an option. The popular — and extremely abusive — tactic is used by plenty of PDs around the nation. Under the guise of breaking up a demonstration, officers surround protesters, physically force them into a confined area, and then rain down pepper balls and tear gas on protesters whose only other option is to physically force their way out of the “kettle.” This, of course, leads to even more police violence, as well as trumped-up “assaulting an officer” charges as people try to escape this form of mass imprisonment.

The dissolution order also says this, which is pretty fucking wild:

[T]he use of bicycles as weapons will be allowed only when preventing death or physical injury to an officer or another person.

That’s the sort of thing I would normally only expect from CIA operatives who moonlight as folk singers (watch all the way to the end):

[If you haven’t watched the Prime series “Patriot,” you’re only hurting yourself.]

You can’t reform a unit that has been given the greenlight to be as awful as it can be for nearly a decade. The only fix is shutting it down and starting over with an emphasis on making officers realize that people’s rights are just as important as their safety. If this leads to more officers resigning or retiring because they don’t want to work for an employer that expects them to respect the law… GOOD. New York City residents are better off without them.

Daily Deal: Microsoft Windows 11 Pro [Techdirt]

Get a lifetime Windows 11 Pro license for a one-time price of $9.97. Install it on your PC and you’re set with no recurring fees and no subscription. This is the full Pro version of Windows 11, built for professionals who need enterprise-grade tools alongside the core Windows experience.

Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.

Our Dipshit DHS Secretary’s Outage Expert: “One Guy That’s Very Smart With Tech” [Techdirt]

Yes, everything is stupid right now, including that every few hours it feels like another system has broken. In just the last week we’ve had Microsoft web services go down, the FAA comms system collapse (supposedly due to a contractor’s router flooding the network during a routine upgrade?), bank websites go down, United Airlines systems go down, a bunch of tech companies (including Zoom and Salesforce) get exploited via Optimizely, Apple’s iCloud go down, and even the NSA’s super duper top secret network go down. Of all these, only the Optimizely mess appears to definitely be an exploitation, though many people are asking questions about the rest.

It should be no surprise that people are also connecting the dots and wondering if these things are all connected. I mean, how could you not? For what it’s worth, I tend to agree with the experts Prof. Kate Klonick has spoken to who suggest the most likely explanation is a benign one — old systems do break down, and it can be a bit of a coincidence that a bunch of big-name systems all broke down around the same time, but humans (as pattern-matching animals) are just paying closer attention to all of them breaking down at once.

WHY IS EVERYTHING BREAKING? 🧵A thread on the internet suddenly going to hell 🧵So in 5 days, Outlook went down, US air traffic control went down, banking systems went down, NSA confidential telephone systems go down and just now that Apple services are downWTAF is happening?!?!1/

— Kate Klonick (@klonick.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T21:10:38.324Z

If there is a throughline here, my guess is that a lot of the tech companies have been quick to push layoffs lately, stupidly believing that they can replace people with AI (which, as we’ve been saying, is a dumb plan), and that means a lot of expertise — including the kind of tacit knowledge AI can’t easily capture — has walked out the door. When the people who actually know how to keep these old systems running are gone, those systems become a bit more likely to fail. That is, while lots of people jumped to “AI” being to blame, my guess (and it is a guess) is that it’s less the direct impact of AI systems, and much more the downstream indirect results of stupid CEOs cutting corners by laying off the kind of people who could keep these systems online.

Still, it does no one any favors to have the dumbest fucking people alive in charge of all of this, but we do. Back on Friday when the FAA ground stop situation happened, the first one to talk about it was DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin (who, back when he was a senator, was long considered one of the dumbest people in the Senate). When asked if the FAA situations had anything to do with AI he responded by refusing to rule it out (“You just can’t rule out anything at this point”) and with the absolutely ridiculous retort: “We call it SI around here, remember?” He also said that it wasn’t “another 9/11” which is an awfully odd comparison to make, and only served to make many people wonder if we should be even more worried.

Later that evening he appeared next to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, where there were awkward exchanges where Duffy and Mullin didn’t appear to be on the same page about what happened or what was to blame. However, both the FAA and the contractor behind its newly expanded $875 million AI system insisted that system had nothing to do with it.

Then, on Monday evening Mullin went on Sean Hannity’s show and… reminded everyone just how clueless he still is. The video clips are remarkable, mainly this one that shows him first suggesting that all the outages don’t appear to be a cyberattack, based on his conversations with CISA, and then saying how he spoke to some successful tech bro who he says asked not to be named (though he says it’s not Elon) who fed him some nonsense that, once it makes it through the empty caverns of Mullin’s brain, came out even more garbled:

It's one thing to watch two random guys bullshitting about what's behind the tech outages. We're all used to that on TV.But this is literally the SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY just wildly speculating. This dude is supposed to be following the facts and actually figuring it out right now.

— Matt Novak (@paleofuture.bsky.social) 2026-11-17T04:19:34.098Z

Mullin mentions that he had the folks at CISA (the Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency) look into all of these events, and they told him that it doesn’t appear to be an interrelated cyberattack.

“[W]hen we start looking at the cyber world, I start asking CISA, hey, what’s going on here? And they said, sir, we’re not seeing any traffic that would make us think that this is a cyberattack, they’re all individually unrelated.”

First up, mentioning CISA is fascinating, given that MAGA’s conspiracy theory-level false belief that CISA engaged in “censorship of conservatives” meant that many MAGA Republicans wanted to kill the entire agency. Even though that didn’t happen, there were massive cuts. Also, as we’ve previously reported, the second Trump Administration was so obsessed with their false belief regarding the work CISA did that froze a bunch of the infrastructure security work it did, and instead moved those infrastructure security experts into roles processing deportation paperwork.

Yes, that’s right, the federal government gutted its cybersecurity infrastructure staff and put many of those who remained on “deportation paperwork processing” instead. And that hollowed-out agency is the one we’re now relying on to tell us everything’s fine.

Anyway, the next bit of Mullin’s ramblings to Hannity is just absolutely bizarre:

“And so I started talking to the tech industry, and one guy that’s very smart with tech…it’s not Elon…I said, what could be causing all these separate outages, and he says, I believe that it’s the SI. He said because these programs aren’t designed to work as fast as SI is, and so, when they…put in a program that’s able to write codes, and it goes in, it self-fixes itself, as it starts self-fixing itself, it’s like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing, and it’s a ripple effect, and it causes these systems to be over[run] that weren’t designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today. That was the conversation I had today. That kind of makes sense to me.”

Sooooooo… you can kinda piece together what someone probably told Mullin if we backtrack it through the reverse-stupid filter. From Mullin’s description, it sounds like someone explained to him what recursive self-improvement (RSI) means (“self-fixing”) and he then tried to apply that to the outages? Except that RSI is on the training new models side of things, not the keeping basic infrastructure working side of things. The whole “work as fast as” and “self-fixing” thing really sounds very much like someone who was told a few things about how AI systems work and are trained and not understanding the technology even slightly, and regurgitating it to the press in the stupidest way possible.

Also, dude, you’re the Secretary of Homeland Security, speaking to “one guy that’s very smart with tech” is not exactly the way you should be going around trying to get a handle on what’s happening with our technology systems these days.

As mentioned, it’s very possible AI played an indirect role here, and some of these outages may even have more direct AI-related causes. But so far almost everyone involved has denied that AI tools had anything to do with it, so it’s not very reassuring when the Homeland Security Secretary who goes around saying “this is not another 9/11” also decides to call up random tech bros to get their take, which he will then explain badly in a manner that doesn’t make much sense. There may be more to all of this, but I have zero faith that Mullin would either understand or be able to explain to the public what AI’s role was.

At this point, I am way less worried about all these system outages (and I say that as someone who got stranded 3,000 miles from home for five days due to the FAA mess, and am writing about this on the first flight I could finally get back towards home many days later) than I am about the fact that we really have the dumbest, most credulous, conspiracy-theory believing dipshits in charge of any sort of coordinated response to all of these outages.

04:00 AM

Two point oh! [F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository]

This Week in F-Droid

TWIF curated on Tuesday, 17 Nov 2026, Week 47

F-Droid core

F-Droid 2.0 is finally rolling out to all the users! And that’s great but not yet perfect. While we had a dozen pre-releases to polish the experience, there are still some devices that move slow to upgrade. If you see the blank screen after the latest update please have patience, it should be done eventually. But, if after 10 minutes it’s still there do reach out so we can try to debug and conquer this issue too.

Community News

@Licaon_Kter notes that the old Invoice Ninja is removed:

The new app has been added already. The users of the old app will see the warning in the new F-Droid client 2.0. Please migrate to the new app.

An Italian guide of FMD has been located at “FMD, ritrova il telefono perso anche con un SMS”.

@linsui notes the Magisk update:

Magisk was updated to 31.1. This version brings official support for Googlebooks. As a result, the repackaging and stub management mechanisms are also removed. See the full changelog for more details.

Archived Apps

6 apps were Archived

…and you’ll get notified in F-Droid client MyApps page if you are impacted!

  • Best-Before: App for monitoring the best-before date of products
  • Invoice Ninja: Invoice your clients, accept payments, track expenses & time billable-tasks
  • LibreTranslator: LibreTranslator a translator based on LibreTranslate
  • MMRL: A modules manager for Magisk & KernelSU.
  • Soft Sound: Play relaxing sounds
  • WPGen: Wallpaper generator

Newly Added Apps

14 apps were newly added
  • 21Life: Commander life counter, playgroup stats, deck history, and live match tools
  • Buddy: Claude Code, Codex, OpenCode, Antigravity or Grok in a chat bubble on your phone
  • c3lingo audio: Listen to live interpretation and hall audio at Chaos events
  • ClipHistory: Private clipboard history with an authorised Shizuku recorder
  • Contour: Parametric EQ for CrinEar, FiiO, SnowSky, TRN, Moondrop and Kiwi Ears DACs
  • DPIMech: Open sites your provider blocks with DPI – only for the apps you choose, no root
  • Fieldsmith: Parametric CAD, 3D FEA & RF VNA solver with Haven MCP & remote compute
  • MediaDateFix: Put your photos back in the correct order!
  • Nudge: Privacy-first app blocker with breathing exercises and delay-to-open
  • Open Grind: Unofficial Grindr client. Free, libre, privacy-centered and community-driven
  • Position - Private Location Sharing: Ask a trusted contact for their location; their phone answers by encrypted SMS
  • SeniorPath: From mid-level to senior: system design, real outages, AI at work. Offline.
  • Skywire: Run a Skywire node on your phone: private chat, VPN, SOCKS proxy and a wallet
  • Sudoku — Hand-drawn Puzzle: Hand-drawn Sudoku with notes, hints, themes and offline play. No ads.

Updated Apps

457 apps were updated
(expand for the full list)

Thank you for reading this week’s TWIF 🙂

Please subscribe to the RSS feed in your favourite RSS application to be updated of new TWIFs when they come up.

You are welcome to join the TWIF forum thread. If you have any news from the community, post it there, maybe it will be featured next week 😉

To help support F-Droid, please check out the donation page and contribute what you can.

How One Member Built a Union Branch [General Union]

“I want to go on strike!”

The message landed hot in the General Union’s inbox, with a member demanding to exercise her constitutional right to strike. Many workers feel strongly about issues in their workplace, but this email was straight to the point.

General Union has a process for dealing with workplace grievances and wanted to make sure it was followed. A meeting was quickly arranged with the member to find out what was going on and what could be done.

From the conversation, the situation became clear. There was indeed an issue in the workplace, and she wasn’t the only one who felt strongly about it. An announcement made earlier that day had set everything in motion.

Her demand to strike was understandable, but the reality was that one voice wasn’t likely to accomplish much on its own.

It was decided that the member would direct her efforts towards organizing her workplace. It was recommended that she first take the Individual Organizing Training. There were some light protests from the member, who insisted she had already tried talking to others about the union, but she agreed to try the training first.

She quickly completed the Individual Organizing Training, but then hit a snag. The Workplace Organizing Training is usually done with a small group of people, and she only knew of one other union member at her workplace. Unfortunately, he was rather busy.

Not deterred, she asked if she could do it on her own. Seeing that this member was dedicated and willing to put in the work, another union officer agreed to act as a quasi-member of her workplace so that the training could begin.

The organizing training required a lot of work, but her attention to detail and willingness to overcome obstacles were impressive. This was especially true because she worked remotely and had never met the people she was planning to reach out to.

Little by little, she found solutions to the roadblocks, built connections, and eventually held the first open meeting.

Employees from her workplace attended, eager to share their concerns, experiences, and thoughts about what was happening at work. Notes were taken, questions were asked, and issues were discussed. The attendees left the meeting, and there was a sense of accomplishment — but only momentarily.

The member and the union officers acknowledged that even though the meeting felt like a success, there was still a lot of work to do. Questions needed to be answered, follow-up emails needed to be sent, and gentle reminders about the union needed to be carefully delivered to those who had shown interest.

The member got right to it. More meetings were set up while conversations and messages continued to keep those interested informed and involved. In just a few short months, several open meetings have been held, and membership has grown to the point that a workplace branch has been formed. Workers became comfortable not only with joining the union but also with openly declaring their membership when it came time to submit demands to their employer.

With the branch nearing 20 members in just a few short months, this is perhaps one of the best organizing success stories we’ve seen in some time. And to think, it all started with one member who wanted to go on strike.

Her passion and determination were there from the beginning. What she needed were the tools, training, and support to turn that passion into something bigger.

One member’s frustration became a collective effort, and an entire workplace now has a stronger voice because of it. Could you be the one to do it next?

Interested in learning how to put your rights into action? Join our Individual Organizing Training

Kanji of the Day: 彰 [Kanji of the Day]

彰

✍14

中学

patent, clear

ショウ

表彰   (ひょうしょう)   —   commendation
表彰式   (ひょうしょうしき)   —   commendation ceremony
表彰台   (ひょうしょうだい)   —   victory stand
顕彰   (けんしょう)   —   honoring (publicly)
表彰状   (ひょうしょうじょう)   —   testimonial
彰徳   (しょうとく)   —   public praise

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

OpenStreetMap Advent Calendar 2026 [OpenStreetMap Japan]

OpenStreetMapの2026年アドベントカレンダーです。12月1日から25日まで、参加者が日付を選んで記事を登録できます。 今年の振り返りや自己紹介など、内容は問いません。Qiitaのほか、OpenStreetMapのユーザー日記やZenn、noteなどの記事でも参加できます。 参加方法や詳しい情報は、カレンダーのページをご覧ください。 https://qiita.com/advent-calendar/2026/osmjp

地図で囲んだ街がマイクラに。道路には車、線路には電車まで走り出す [OpenStreetMap Japan]

OpenStreetMapと標高データから実在の街をマインクラフト内に生成するツール「Arnis」を紹介しています。地元の街をゲームで再現したい方や、地図データの活用に関心がある方におすすめです。

岡山の街歩きで点字ブロック情報収集 中学生が開発したアプリで [OpenStreetMap Japan]

中学生が開発したアプリ「Step By」で点字ブロックなどの情報を集める、岡山での街歩きイベントを紹介しています。11月23日のイベントではOpenStreetMapへの情報の反映も予定されており、歩行支援や地図づくりに関心のある方におすすめです。

RSSSiteUpdated
XML About Tagaini Jisho on Tagaini Jisho 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Arch Linux: Releases 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Carlson Calamities 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Debian News 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Debian Security 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML debito.org 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML dperkins 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML General Union 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML GIMP 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Japan Bash 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Japan English Teacher Feed 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Kanji of the Day 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Kanji of the Day 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Let's Encrypt 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Marc Jones 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Marjorie's Blog 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML OpenStreetMap Japan 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML OsmAnd Blog 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Popehat 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Ramen Adventures 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Release notes from server 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML SNA Japan 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Tatoeba Project Blog 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Techdirt 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML The Business of Printing Books 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML The Luddite 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML The Popehat Report 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML The Status Kuo 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML The Stranger 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Tor Project blog 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML TorrentFreak 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML what if? 2026-11-20 04:00 AM
XML Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed 2026-11-12 07:00 PM
XML xkcd.com 2026-11-20 04:00 AM