Can You Regulate ‘Fairness’? The EU’s Digital Fairness Act Is Going To Try [Techdirt]
Last week the EU presented its long-awaited “Digital Fairness Act” proposal, an attempt to expand its consumer protection laws to deal with what it believes are shady practices online. Now, you might be thinking that the EU already has a ton of internet laws — the GDPR, the ePrivacy Directive, the DSA, the DMA, the AI Act, and more — with somewhat mixed results. And you’d be right. But that’s not going to slow down the EU.
Dealing with scammy practices online is a laudable goal, but there are a lot of ways that could go wrong, especially if the end result is just giving more control to the biggest companies to “get things right” rather than letting users themselves control their own data and experiences online.
As with many EU proposals, there’s a lot in this proposal that will likely get support, because it targets a bunch of things that people claim to hate. And, some of what the Commission lays out actually looks good:
- A ban on manipulative marketing tactics (so-called “dark patterns”) such as fake claims that a product is almost sold out that pressure consumers into purchasing decisions they might not otherwise make.
- Clear and transparent pricing, particularly prices of purchases made with virtual in-app currencies and when dynamic pricing is used for cultural and sports events. In virtual queues, companies will have to show the current price in real time and the highest possible price.
- Fairness by design, with the option for consumers to turn off addictive design features that encourage excessive or compulsive spending, such as persistent prompts. The proposal will also restrict unfair practices that encourage overspending, for example by banning gambling-like features for minors, such as pay-to-win and pay-to-progress.
- Clear disclosure of influencer marketing, requiring influencers to be transparent about commercial content and preventing the exploitation of the trust of minors in their audience.
- A restriction on unfair personalised ads and prices that target minors or take advantage of sensitive data.
- Digital contracts and subscriptions that are easier to cancel and an end to unwanted automatic renewals and free trials turning into subscription traps. Consumers will have the right to communicate with a human in customer service and will have clear rights when using an AI agent to buy products on their behalf.
The key aspect of the proposal — and this is the subject of a lot of debate on both sides — is that it won’t ban most of the so-called “addictive” features (though it does ban a specific list of so-called “dark patterns”) but would require companies to give consumers the option of turning those features off. To me, that’s better than an outright ban, which would create lots of issues, but others complain that this then puts the burden on the user. Of course, one person’s “burden on the user” is another’s “user empowerment,” so it depends a bit on through which prism you view all this. I’d rather put control in users’ hands than give companies more levers to pull.
Giving people the option to turn off these features actually seems like a mostly reasonable compromise. Many of the practices described above… absolutely suck. And being able to opt out of them seems good, though the devil is very much in the details. And some of the features being targeted can actually be useful in certain circumstances. I’ve talked about how the claims of “addictive design” are often quite overblown — mainly in confusing “addiction” and “habits.”
And that can become problematic, because in addition to bad habits, there can also be good habits — and there are even specialized tools out there designed to help you learn good habits, like getting regular exercise, or practicing mindfulness, or getting a good night’s sleep. Just as an example, Wired notes that a language-learning service like Duolingo or an exercise app like Strava might both be negatively impacted by the law. Both apps rely on features (like Duolingo’s infamous streaks) that nudge you to keep up with your language-learning and exercise habits. And, generally speaking, most people consider that a good thing. If it remains optional to turn these features off, then I guess that’s fine, though it still feels out of place in apps literally designed to try to get you to establish a habit (not an “addiction.”) At the very least, it will require they spend a bunch of engineering time to build a tool to turn off the main reason why people use those apps.
But also, what starts as an “option” to turn off can quickly become required under the law. Indeed, some of the complaints about the proposal that we’re seeing are that many wish there were outright bans, rather than the option to turn off. Of course, in that same article, others are complaining that the existing rules are already too much of a regulatory burden, so you can see there will be efforts to pull the proposal in both directions as the negotiations between the European Parliament and the Council heat up over the final rules.
The group EDRi, who does amazingly good consumer digital rights work in the EU, is largely supportive of the EU’s push to stop anti-consumer tricks online, but warns that the way the law is written might just create a repeat of the “cookie banner” nonsense, which was written to deal with a legitimate concern (people giving up privacy without realizing what they were doing) but when it came to implementation, resulted in just… annoying everyone and doing little to actually protect privacy.
As EDRi’s Itxaso Domínguez de Olazábal points out, the end result of that fiasco was to generally turn the public against efforts to actually protect privacy, and there’s some fear that the same could happen here:
There is also a too familiar political risk: we’ve spent years watching companies turn cookie consent from a perfectly valid legal and protective basis into an obstacle course, only for the resulting frustration to become an argument against EU privacy and data protection regulation.
Now imagine another set of inconvenient controls, confusing settings and repeated choices: people will inevitably become frustrated, industry will complain about Brussels ruining the user experience, and eventually someone will suggest weakening the rules (they will call it ‘simplification,’ though). I’d rather we didn’t repeat that exercise.
There are also bits in the proposal targeting video game “loot boxes” and “pay-to-win” features, which… definitely feel more scammy. The proposal seeks to ban them in games targeted at children and provide much more clear transparency about what’s going on for adult gamers. Of course, the video game industry is already out complaining about these rules, but given how much of the world has been taken over by subtle attempts to make people gamble away everything they have… I’m not as convinced that rules on those kinds of things are as problematic as the industry makes them out to be.
It also looks like the proposal did not take up the request to include the “stop killing games” proposal as a part of the DFA, though that may also be subject to change during the negotiation.
In the end, I have a mixed opinion on much of this. I agree with most people that the scammy tactics some companies use really suck and make everyone’s life worse. But I’m skeptical you can legislate “fairness” broadly in a way that won’t backfire long term (see: cookie banners) or that takes into account all the edge cases. I’d prefer they target specific, proven, malicious behavior rather than writing sweeping rules.
Part of the problem is that politicians can’t seem to think of the internet as anything more than Facebook, Instagram, X, and TikTok. To them, everything is social media, so anything that keeps you engaged must be “bad” and “addictive.” They legislate with that in mind, and when other services (Duolingo, Strava, etc.) push back, the fix is to make the rules “opt-out” rather than an outright ban. But that still puts compliance costs on those services, and it could also lead to some services never being built at all.
A better solution, as always, is for people to have more overall control over their digital experiences, and I worry that laws like this could actually make that harder, because the compliance costs that giants can easily absorb can price out the smaller companies that are often the ones giving users more control in the first place. Small companies are already pointing out that this could really harm them, noting that the compliance costs are large, but they’re generally not the ones doing really scammy tactics in the first place. So to them, this would make them bear the cost, without much benefit to their users.
Yes, giving users the option to turn off certain features would be a step towards more user control, which I appreciate, but the broadness of the law and the mandate makes me worry about how it will be gamed by the largest players, and prove too costly for the smaller ones.
Indeed, we keep seeing big companies (and their lobbyists) shape these rules to benefit themselves long term, while leaving smaller competitors unable to comply.
That is to say that I appreciate the underlying goals of this regulation, and agree that the state of the internet today often sucks. But that doesn’t mean that this regulation will actually make things any better — and there’s a decent enough chance it could make things worse.
Automakers Ramp Up Scare-Mongering Push To Ban Chinese EVs. You Know, ‘For Privacy’ [Techdirt]
Automakers are aggressively ramping up their efforts to pass a new law outright banning Chinese EVs. They obviously want to do this because they don’t want to compete with better, often significantly cheaper products, but they can’t just say that. Instead, we get a lot of bizarre pretense about how an industry with the worst privacy ratings in America is just super concerned about privacy.
The Alliance for Automotive Innovation (AAI), which represents GM, Toyota, Volkswagen, and other domestic and foreign car makers already doing business in the U.S., are wasting no time in calling for a permanent ban on Chinese EVs after the midterm elections.
The auto industry’s preferred new law, the Connected Vehicle Security Act of 2026, cleared the Senate Commerce Committee in July, and a House version of the bill now has more than 100 co-sponsors. Last September, Senate bill sponsors, Sens. Bernie Moreno (a Republican) and Elissa Slotkin (a Democrat), agreed to delay efforts to fast-track the legislation until this month.
To goad additional lawmakers into action, AAI boss John Bozzella is ramping up the fear mongering in public statements, and routinely brings up privacy and national security concerns as the industry’s primary motivation:
“We need to protect the US market from a flood of Chinese imports that carry surveillance risk and disadvantage current manufacturers that have made generational investments in American communities.”
If there’s going to be rampant unchecked surveillance abuses, they should most assuredly be domestic only, I guess.
This idea that Chinese EVs pose some unique privacy and national security threat to Americans is a common refrain from Bozzella and the auto industry. The argument is that Chinese EVs will collect oceans of data on American consumer driving and behavior habits, then funnel that data back to the Chinese government, who’ll then engage in all manner of ambiguous, nefarious behaviors.
There are several problems with the argument.
The biggest being that these same automakers do a disastrous job securing their own vehicles. Studies repeatedly show that U.S. automakers have some of the worst privacy and security standards in all of tech. An ocean of U.S. consumer driving, behavior, phone, and location data is already hoovered up at scale by your car, often left unencrypted, and sold to a laundry list of dodgy partners (including insurance companies, which will jack up your rates based on your driving habits with no transparency into the process).
The other problem: the U.S. is routinely too corrupt to pass modern internet privacy laws or even competently regulate a vast international web of dodgy data brokers. Most of the data collected by U.S. vehicle makers is already available via these data brokers; who’ll in turn sell this data to literally any random nitwit with two nickels to rub together (including Chinese intelligence).
Failing to secure your own vehicles and fighting tooth and nail against any privacy safeguards… then ranting incoherently about the threat of Chinese tech on U.S. shores is not serious tech policy. Our failure to regulate data brokers or pass modern privacy laws means the Chinese simply buy this same data from any of dozens of dodgy companies already, making a lot of this stuff lazy pantomime.
Unfortunately, this kind of lazy protectionism is a truly bipartisan affair. You saw how Democrats tripped over themselves to help Trump’s billionaire friends steal TikTok under the pretense this would somehow make Americans safer, more secure, and less prone to propaganda.
Democratic lawmakers in Michigan also recently tried to ban Chinese EVs from even visiting the state, suggesting that automakers are afraid of Americans even looking at cheaper overseas alternatives. The justification (by folks who are are, again, completely absent when it comes to any sort of domestic U.S. privacy standards and enforcement) is they were just very concerned about U.S. consumer privacy.
I get the impulse to try and protect U.S. domestic automaker jobs (even though U.S. automakers have a long and detailed history of anti-labor behaviors), but there’s simply no coherent consistency to any U.S. policies. We don’t meaningfully protect labor generally, we don’t enforce consumer protection law, we’re too corrupt to pass a privacy law that reins in data monetization and hyper surveillance, and U.S. policymakers largely pay empty lip service to concepts like “affordability.”
We’ll see how much the new Democratic blood in the House and Senate shifts some of these dynamics, but as it stands now you can expect the new year to be filled with the brim with all sorts of expanded bipartisan xenophobic protectionism across the entirety of tech — from AI to electric vehicles. Ignoring that it will be bumbling Trump zealots like Brendan Carr tasked with a lot of enforcement (see: Carr’s rank incompetence surrounding the Chinese drone ban).
And you can expect all of it to be propped up by bad faith arguments that the bill backers are exclusively, suddenly, and very uncharacteristically concerned about your personal privacy. And in turn propped up by a shitty tech press oddly oblivious to their own nationalism biases.
I maintain that the best path forward is to allow Chinese drones, AI, EVs, vacuums, and assorted other tech into the U.S. market, but properly fund, staff, and legally support our privacy, labor, competition, and consumer protection regulators to ensure a level playing field and healthy markets. Large corporations hate that idea, so instead we get this bizarre and performative protectionist pantomime.
NYC Mayor Mamdani Disbands NYPD Unit That Treated Protesters Like Terrorists [Techdirt]
It’s taken pretty much forever, but finally one of the NYPD’s worst specialist units is being disbanded. The catalyst here was the election of a mayor who was finally serious about holding the NYPD in check. For years, the city’s mayors have done whatever they can to keep the cop shop happy, including the last mayor, who went deep down a corruption hole to make sure both he and NYPD remained happy, even if his constituents weren’t.
Here’s what’s happening to the NYPD’s “Strategic Response Group” now that the city is run by a mayor that’s not going to allow a decade-plus of constant civil rights abuses to continue.
A controversial New York Police Department unit accused of using excessive force against protesters has been disbanded, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced Monday, fulfilling a key campaign promise from the mayor to separate protest policing from counterterrorism.
Along with the elimination of the Strategic Response Group, certain aggressive crowd-management tactics are now banned and new dialogue-focused units will be established in the NYPD and the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety to ensure a coordinated response to protests, the mayor and commissioner said in a statement.
If you’re wondering about the controversy of this particular unit, you have to take a trip in the wayback machine to 2015, which was when NYPD Commissioner and the mayor who never was the reformer he pretended to be (Bill de Blasio) decided a single unit could handle three very different aspects of policing, somehow without causing collateral damage to Constitutional rights. (Or maybe they didn’t actually belive this and chose to do it anyway.)
The SRG got folded in with an existing counterterrorism unit, apparently because the mayor and police commissioner decided fighting terrorism and policing protests was roughly the same thing. A few years later, documents obtained by journalists made it clear SRG officers were routinely brutalizing peaceful protesters. This wasn’t much of a surprise, considering its counterterrorism unit was known for routinely violating rights while engaging in extremely biased policing/surveillance. That this infection would spread to the SRG is completely unsurprising. Bad apples, etc.
This unit should have been disbanded once this information was made public. But it wasn’t. Given that regular NYPD patrol officers are just as capable of violating people’s rights, it hardly made sense to provide specialist pay for rote thuggery. But the SRG kept on keeping on… right up until NYC residents made it explicitly clear they were sick of the same old bullshit from their mayors.
The disbanding of this unit has the support of the current police commissioner. And it goes further than just rearranging some deck chairs so SRG officers can get back to the rights-violation business elsewhere. It also establishes a “First Amendment Support Team” in the NYPD that will help train and support officers who are asked to police protests.
In addition, “kettling” protesters is no longer an option. The popular — and extremely abusive — tactic is used by plenty of PDs around the nation. Under the guise of breaking up a demonstration, officers surround protesters, physically force them into a confined area, and then rain down pepper balls and tear gas on protesters whose only other option is to physically force their way out of the “kettle.” This, of course, leads to even more police violence, as well as trumped-up “assaulting an officer” charges as people try to escape this form of mass imprisonment.
The dissolution order also says this, which is pretty fucking wild:
[T]he use of bicycles as weapons will be allowed only when preventing death or physical injury to an officer or another person.
That’s the sort of thing I would normally only expect from CIA operatives who moonlight as folk singers (watch all the way to the end):
[If you haven’t watched the Prime series “Patriot,” you’re only hurting yourself.]
You can’t reform a unit that has been given the greenlight to be as awful as it can be for nearly a decade. The only fix is shutting it down and starting over with an emphasis on making officers realize that people’s rights are just as important as their safety. If this leads to more officers resigning or retiring because they don’t want to work for an employer that expects them to respect the law… GOOD. New York City residents are better off without them.
Daily Deal: Microsoft Windows 11 Pro [Techdirt]
Get a lifetime Windows 11 Pro license for a one-time price of $9.97. Install it on your PC and you’re set with no recurring fees and no subscription. This is the full Pro version of Windows 11, built for professionals who need enterprise-grade tools alongside the core Windows experience.
Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.
Our Dipshit DHS Secretary’s Outage Expert: “One Guy That’s Very Smart With Tech” [Techdirt]
Yes, everything is stupid right now, including that every few hours it feels like another system has broken. In just the last week we’ve had Microsoft web services go down, the FAA comms system collapse (supposedly due to a contractor’s router flooding the network during a routine upgrade?), bank websites go down, United Airlines systems go down, a bunch of tech companies (including Zoom and Salesforce) get exploited via Optimizely, Apple’s iCloud go down, and even the NSA’s super duper top secret network go down. Of all these, only the Optimizely mess appears to definitely be an exploitation, though many people are asking questions about the rest.
It should be no surprise that people are also connecting the dots and wondering if these things are all connected. I mean, how could you not? For what it’s worth, I tend to agree with the experts Prof. Kate Klonick has spoken to who suggest the most likely explanation is a benign one — old systems do break down, and it can be a bit of a coincidence that a bunch of big-name systems all broke down around the same time, but humans (as pattern-matching animals) are just paying closer attention to all of them breaking down at once.
If there is a throughline here, my guess is that a lot of the tech companies have been quick to push layoffs lately, stupidly believing that they can replace people with AI (which, as we’ve been saying, is a dumb plan), and that means a lot of expertise — including the kind of tacit knowledge AI can’t easily capture — has walked out the door. When the people who actually know how to keep these old systems running are gone, those systems become a bit more likely to fail. That is, while lots of people jumped to “AI” being to blame, my guess (and it is a guess) is that it’s less the direct impact of AI systems, and much more the downstream indirect results of stupid CEOs cutting corners by laying off the kind of people who could keep these systems online.
Still, it does no one any favors to have the dumbest fucking people alive in charge of all of this, but we do. Back on Friday when the FAA ground stop situation happened, the first one to talk about it was DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin (who, back when he was a senator, was long considered one of the dumbest people in the Senate). When asked if the FAA situations had anything to do with AI he responded by refusing to rule it out (“You just can’t rule out anything at this point”) and with the absolutely ridiculous retort: “We call it SI around here, remember?” He also said that it wasn’t “another 9/11” which is an awfully odd comparison to make, and only served to make many people wonder if we should be even more worried.
Later that evening he appeared next to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, where there were awkward exchanges where Duffy and Mullin didn’t appear to be on the same page about what happened or what was to blame. However, both the FAA and the contractor behind its newly expanded $875 million AI system insisted that system had nothing to do with it.
Then, on Monday evening Mullin went on Sean Hannity’s show and… reminded everyone just how clueless he still is. The video clips are remarkable, mainly this one that shows him first suggesting that all the outages don’t appear to be a cyberattack, based on his conversations with CISA, and then saying how he spoke to some successful tech bro who he says asked not to be named (though he says it’s not Elon) who fed him some nonsense that, once it makes it through the empty caverns of Mullin’s brain, came out even more garbled:
Mullin mentions that he had the folks at CISA (the Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency) look into all of these events, and they told him that it doesn’t appear to be an interrelated cyberattack.
“[W]hen we start looking at the cyber world, I start asking CISA, hey, what’s going on here? And they said, sir, we’re not seeing any traffic that would make us think that this is a cyberattack, they’re all individually unrelated.”
First up, mentioning CISA is fascinating, given that MAGA’s conspiracy theory-level false belief that CISA engaged in “censorship of conservatives” meant that many MAGA Republicans wanted to kill the entire agency. Even though that didn’t happen, there were massive cuts. Also, as we’ve previously reported, the second Trump Administration was so obsessed with their false belief regarding the work CISA did that froze a bunch of the infrastructure security work it did, and instead moved those infrastructure security experts into roles processing deportation paperwork.
Yes, that’s right, the federal government gutted its cybersecurity infrastructure staff and put many of those who remained on “deportation paperwork processing” instead. And that hollowed-out agency is the one we’re now relying on to tell us everything’s fine.
Anyway, the next bit of Mullin’s ramblings to Hannity is just absolutely bizarre:
“And so I started talking to the tech industry, and one guy that’s very smart with tech…it’s not Elon…I said, what could be causing all these separate outages, and he says, I believe that it’s the SI. He said because these programs aren’t designed to work as fast as SI is, and so, when they…put in a program that’s able to write codes, and it goes in, it self-fixes itself, as it starts self-fixing itself, it’s like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing, and it’s a ripple effect, and it causes these systems to be over[run] that weren’t designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today. That was the conversation I had today. That kind of makes sense to me.”
Sooooooo… you can kinda piece together what someone probably told Mullin if we backtrack it through the reverse-stupid filter. From Mullin’s description, it sounds like someone explained to him what recursive self-improvement (RSI) means (“self-fixing”) and he then tried to apply that to the outages? Except that RSI is on the training new models side of things, not the keeping basic infrastructure working side of things. The whole “work as fast as” and “self-fixing” thing really sounds very much like someone who was told a few things about how AI systems work and are trained and not understanding the technology even slightly, and regurgitating it to the press in the stupidest way possible.
Also, dude, you’re the Secretary of Homeland Security, speaking to “one guy that’s very smart with tech” is not exactly the way you should be going around trying to get a handle on what’s happening with our technology systems these days.
As mentioned, it’s very possible AI played an indirect role here, and some of these outages may even have more direct AI-related causes. But so far almost everyone involved has denied that AI tools had anything to do with it, so it’s not very reassuring when the Homeland Security Secretary who goes around saying “this is not another 9/11” also decides to call up random tech bros to get their take, which he will then explain badly in a manner that doesn’t make much sense. There may be more to all of this, but I have zero faith that Mullin would either understand or be able to explain to the public what AI’s role was.
At this point, I am way less worried about all these system outages (and I say that as someone who got stranded 3,000 miles from home for five days due to the FAA mess, and am writing about this on the first flight I could finally get back towards home many days later) than I am about the fact that we really have the dumbest, most credulous, conspiracy-theory believing dipshits in charge of any sort of coordinated response to all of these outages.
Two point oh! [F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository]
F-Droid 2.0 is finally rolling out to all the users! And that’s great but not yet perfect. While we had a dozen pre-releases to polish the experience, there are still some devices that move slow to upgrade. If you see the blank screen after the latest update please have patience, it should be done eventually. But, if after 10 minutes it’s still there do reach out so we can try to debug and conquer this issue too.
@Licaon_Kter notes that the old Invoice Ninja is removed:
The new app has been added already. The users of the old app will see the warning in the new F-Droid client 2.0. Please migrate to the new app.
An Italian guide of FMD has been located at “FMD, ritrova il telefono perso anche con un SMS”.
@linsui notes the Magisk update:
Magisk was updated to 31.1. This version brings official support for Googlebooks. As a result, the repackaging and stub management mechanisms are also removed. See the full changelog for more details.
…and you’ll get notified in F-Droid client MyApps page if you are impacted!
1.7.61.3.61.8.01.2.93.00.31.22.2.121.16.02.67.00.8.115.4.715.4.715.4.715.4.71.0.41.0.22.6.81.0.01.0.251.1.07.4.61.10.21.20.01.1.22.7.11.15.100.8.41.23.02026.11.1-banglejs94.1.983.1.72.14.02.4.52.31.0.41.0.851.2.01.7.11.7.12.7.22.0.92.6.15.7.11.14.010.5.50.70.8.00.25.00.2.113.86.1500.4.11.7.01.4.12.3.70.67.01.9.12026.11.12173.3.342.9.281.10.01.0.40.5.221.650.28.02.17.00.3.63.2.22.1.01.1.013.131.0.102.3.0v0.9.62.21.1+free1.3.01.2.53.0.21.44.1.2.43.10.04.0.501.46.3593.44.00.1.252.69.01.4.01.5.00.1.17-fdroid3.3.03.1.07.12.5.132.2.410.17.01.4.353.2026110600.98.03.5.34.8.41.0.31.0.302.2.71.0.121.3.691.0.59-oss0.3.61.7.10.17.680.6.01.23401.21.0160.0.01.0.32.0.1093.2.852.11.22.5.02.2.425.13.02.11.51.0.31.9.813.2.1.013.1.6.01.12.21.2.11.6.41.14.20.52.03.32026.11.11.3.90.53.41.0.42.114.916.12.12.3.2(2696)2.3.2(2696)4.2.015.1.00.2.101.41.9.13.2.74.2.31.2.30.5.02.1.46.4.10.8.42.3.05.2.12.1.05.94.263.0.11.9.00.1.121.2.10.4.01.3.813.1p2.14.13.4.00.12.95.1.230.9.51.1020261106-014.4.00.20.00.303.2.0-FOSS2.1.03.025.01742026.11.101.4.01.1.54.7.0-foss1.17.01.17.00.233.27.00.8.12.1.62.7.62.11.00.14.02.2.12.2.5-fdroid0.6.01.4.10.2.03.9.03.1.22.5.5.1.2a0850a10.0.31-fdroid1.30.15.5.20.2.124.9.22.6.3-rc.10.29.11.13.1-release4.0.05.18.01.91.5.61.9.0740.7.00.1.85.4.131.14.9.22026-11-08-dce858b0a01.7.202611110149151.0.1181.3.42.43.02.43.02.13.61.0.141.18.25v4.0.101.7.71.0.491.0.42.0.926.11.11.4.01.0.91.201.5.713.2.1.113.2.1.10.2.30.4.90.5.11.3.30.6.01.21.01.12.12.37.01.1.62.0.71.3.23.2.11.3.172.1.01.9.11.0.3260.35.212.21.1.80.24.11.10.0v0.1.44.3.11.138.00.0.561.5.01.4.01.0.43.2.00.3.02.4.016.20.8.1202611102.11.0.41.2.10.8.1270.8.1273.25.02.11.461.12.03.3.01.0.71.7.10.20.01.6.00.8.21.0.391.4.326.11.16-fdroid0.4.00.81.06.3.1581.3.03.22.11-beta3.5.2.10.1.11.5.01.422.16.01.25.00.12.02.6.4.10.5.12.2.191.1.11.1.2610.7.11320.9.11.3.52.2.32.1.01.28.02.0.71.11.03.60.0.831.1.111.0.3v9.8.51.2.00.11.23.41.9.73.1.12.0.11.4.42.5.00.9.9.212.19.026.11.01.1.02.11.52.0.02026.11.06.3191.0.501.0.22v1.4.22.2.21.10.00.8.30.8.00.1.3-rc30.1.51.18.50.8.61.7.14.171.87.420.2611091.5.33.2.01.0.0-beta.65.6.01.0.1v26.11.00.311.0.311.2.01.15.00.1.121.0.21.5.14.7.11.1.31.31.37.1.21.10.212.5.03.1.13.8.102.3.1:Cassini1.3.832.713.7.11.30.01.5.01.0.701.1.21.3.75.21.1.31.9.21.0.40.7.11.6.70.13.22.8.01.7.01.88.1-fdroid20.0.00.9.1.41.2.42026.11.11.2.31.104.6-t3b273a64c-g08d3d325a5.7.01.4.415.131.1.111.6.02.6.01.0.33.4.13.0.01.2.42.12.05.1.2126.0b325.07.9.02.4.11.3.01.16.03.1.01.0.3162.9.11.4.10.7.9368.261109.0368.261109.01.71.18.11.1.020261108001.16.2-store4.22.191.1.101.7.64.2.32.0.01.4.31.5.03.6.1v3.4.9-Stable2.4.01.15.01.0.252.0.10.26.262.2.192026.11.08.23.0.11.6.14.40.6.52.11.0161.3.1560021.6.06.0.01.1.0-alpha0.0.1361.0.833.30.2.132.1.31.0.15Thank you for reading this week’s TWIF 🙂
Please subscribe to the RSS feed in your favourite RSS application to be updated of new TWIFs when they come up.
You are welcome to join the TWIF forum thread. If you have any news from the community, post it there, maybe it will be featured next week 😉
To help support F-Droid, please check out the donation page and contribute what you can.
How One Member Built a Union Branch [General Union]
“I want to go on strike!”
The message landed hot in the General Union’s inbox, with a member demanding to exercise her constitutional right to strike. Many workers feel strongly about issues in their workplace, but this email was straight to the point.
General Union has a process for dealing with workplace grievances and wanted to make sure it was followed. A meeting was quickly arranged with the member to find out what was going on and what could be done.
From the conversation, the situation became clear. There was indeed an issue in the workplace, and she wasn’t the only one who felt strongly about it. An announcement made earlier that day had set everything in motion.
Her demand to strike was understandable, but the reality was that one voice wasn’t likely to accomplish much on its own.
It was decided that the member would direct her efforts towards organizing her workplace. It was recommended that she first take the Individual Organizing Training. There were some light protests from the member, who insisted she had already tried talking to others about the union, but she agreed to try the training first.
She quickly completed the Individual Organizing Training, but then hit a snag. The Workplace Organizing Training is usually done with a small group of people, and she only knew of one other union member at her workplace. Unfortunately, he was rather busy.
Not deterred, she asked if she could do it on her own. Seeing that this member was dedicated and willing to put in the work, another union officer agreed to act as a quasi-member of her workplace so that the training could begin.
The organizing training required a lot of work, but her attention to detail and willingness to overcome obstacles were impressive. This was especially true because she worked remotely and had never met the people she was planning to reach out to.
Little by little, she found solutions to the roadblocks, built connections, and eventually held the first open meeting.
Employees from her workplace attended, eager to share their concerns, experiences, and thoughts about what was happening at work. Notes were taken, questions were asked, and issues were discussed. The attendees left the meeting, and there was a sense of accomplishment — but only momentarily.
The member and the union officers acknowledged that even though the meeting felt like a success, there was still a lot of work to do. Questions needed to be answered, follow-up emails needed to be sent, and gentle reminders about the union needed to be carefully delivered to those who had shown interest.
The member got right to it. More meetings were set up while conversations and messages continued to keep those interested informed and involved. In just a few short months, several open meetings have been held, and membership has grown to the point that a workplace branch has been formed. Workers became comfortable not only with joining the union but also with openly declaring their membership when it came time to submit demands to their employer.
With the branch nearing 20 members in just a few short months, this is perhaps one of the best organizing success stories we’ve seen in some time. And to think, it all started with one member who wanted to go on strike.
Her passion and determination were there from the beginning. What she needed were the tools, training, and support to turn that passion into something bigger.
One member’s frustration became a collective effort, and an entire workplace now has a stronger voice because of it. Could you be the one to do it next?
Interested in learning how to put your rights into action? Join our Individual Organizing Training
Kanji of the Day: 彰 [Kanji of the Day]
彰
✍14
中学
patent, clear
ショウ
表彰 (ひょうしょう) — commendation
表彰式 (ひょうしょうしき) — commendation ceremony
表彰台 (ひょうしょうだい) — victory stand
顕彰 (けんしょう) — honoring (publicly)
表彰状 (ひょうしょうじょう) — testimonial
彰徳 (しょうとく) — public praise
Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.
OpenStreetMap Advent Calendar 2026 [OpenStreetMap Japan]
OpenStreetMapの2026年アドベントカレンダーです。12月1日から25日まで、参加者が日付を選んで記事を登録できます。 今年の振り返りや自己紹介など、内容は問いません。Qiitaのほか、OpenStreetMapのユーザー日記やZenn、noteなどの記事でも参加できます。 参加方法や詳しい情報は、カレンダーのページをご覧ください。 https://qiita.com/advent-calendar/2026/osmjp
地図で囲んだ街がマイクラに。道路には車、線路には電車まで走り出す [OpenStreetMap Japan]
OpenStreetMapと標高データから実在の街をマインクラフト内に生成するツール「Arnis」を紹介しています。地元の街をゲームで再現したい方や、地図データの活用に関心がある方におすすめです。
岡山の街歩きで点字ブロック情報収集 中学生が開発したアプリで [OpenStreetMap Japan]
中学生が開発したアプリ「Step By」で点字ブロックなどの情報を集める、岡山での街歩きイベントを紹介しています。11月23日のイベントではOpenStreetMapへの情報の反映も予定されており、歩行支援や地図づくりに関心のある方におすすめです。
OpenStreetMapとCanvaで自走する、社会的処方マップ「せやさかい」(Social Everyday Your Art in SAKAI)をデザイン設計した件 [OpenStreetMap Japan]
堺市の社会的処方マップ「せやさかい」を、OpenStreetMapやCanvaなどを使って更新し続けられるよう設計した取り組みを紹介しています。地域の居場所を伝える地図づくりや、その運用に関心のある方におすすめです。
Trump Is Very Mad Because CBS Under Larry Ellison Still Does Real Reporting Sometimes [Techdirt]
So I’ve written a lot about how Trump billionaire friend Larry Ellison bought CBS (and now Warner Brothers and CNN) with the very clear goal of turning it into a right wing propaganda mill.
This transformation under out-of-her-depth troll blogger Bari Weiss hasn’t been subtle. It’s ranged from letting Benjamin Netanyahu pick his own softball interviewer to help him downplay war crime allegations, to censoring stories critical of the president’s concentration camps. That sort of stuff has been peppered in between all sorts of other incompetence resulting in a ratings disaster at the new network.
Like any good right wing propaganda mill, you have to pepper in just enough “normal” reporting to try and maintain something vaguely resembling credibility. And it can take a while for people like Weiss to purge existing journalists still loyal to the public interest.
So the network will sometimes still run a story that still has something with teeth; like this recent 60 Minutes report featuring a whistleblower who made it clear that the government has been covering up the damage caused by Iranian aerial strikes during Trump’s pointless and disastrous war in Iran. Worse; they appear to have ignored warnings of some attacks, resulting in the avoidable deaths of U.S. troops.
Trump is now mad at the fact there’s still honest reporting coming out of Larry Ellison’s media and infotainment empire. In a post to his personal propaganda website, he wrote:

If you can’t read that, Trump writes:
“The new people running 60 Minutes are even worse than their predecessors. A recent study on an attack in the early stages of Iran was not correctly stated. Since February 28, 2026, the start of Epic Fury, Iran has fired between 8,000-9,000 One-way Attack Drones. Only 2 of them got through, resulting in U.S. fatalities, both on the first day, hitting Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. Likewise, Iran has fired about 2,000 Ballistic Missiles. Only 1 out of the 2,0000 got through, and caused U.S. fatalities (Jordan). Translation: 99.99% of Iranian missiles and drones have been shot down or, in any event, not caused U.S. deaths. CENTCOM defensive measures have been historically effective. No one in the World has the ability to do so well. All of this being left out of the 60 Minutes “report.” Thank you for your attention to this matter. President DONALD J. TRUMP.”
Given the depth of other reporting on the extensive impact of Iranian drone and missile attacks on U.S. infrastructure (like this Associated Press investigation from earlier this month, or this Washington Post investigation from last May), it’s pretty clear the President is, once again, lying.
It’s also been very clear throughout the war that Trump, and his advisors, didn’t really understand how drones have changed warfare before bumbling into Iran. And ironically, even having a Trump ally specifically buy up news organizations with the unsubtle goal of glazing the president hasn’t been enough to cover up the stink.
That’s not to say that CBS — like most of the U.S. press — can’t and won’t get worse. Weiss only started at CBS a little over a year ago, and it’s going to take her and Ellison a while to truly shape CBS into the kind of agitprop mill they’re looking for, much to the chagrin of all the actual reporters and journalists still employed there.
The goal for U.S. oligarchs is to very clearly buy up what’s left of U.S. corporate media and create a right wing autocrat and oligarch safe space. A massive industry of pseudo-journalism, trolling, and agitprop that’s somehow going to be even worse than a lot of the soggy, feckless corporate journalism Americans have come to expect.
But historically, thin-skinned autocrats and fascists are never happy, and there’s simply no bottom to their desire for feckless obedience and glowing adulation from the press and public alike. There’s no debasement that will ever be enough. And while CBS leadership seems happy to oblige, it’s nice that actual journalism still sometimes manages to leak through the cracks.
Pluralistic: Enshittifiers groom us for scammers (18 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]
->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->
Top Sources:
None
-->

We live in a scam economy: there's a presidential memecoin, a public health system run by a supplement peddler (who sold his trademark for "MAHA" to a pal before taking the job), and Spacex got to debut into the NASDAQ 100 and turn your retirement savings into exit liquidity for Musk's Emirati and tech oligarch cronies:
Then there's AI: voice cloning, deepfakes, and image-genned documents (including convincing IDs) have ushered in a golden age of account takeovers, identity theft and good, old-fashioned impersonation:
https://www.404media.co/the-confessions-of-an-ai-fraud-kingpin-onlyfake-owner-nazarenko/
AI summarization is a priceless gift to fraudsters, who can comb through otherwise intractable mountains of breach data to customize precision-targeted spear-phishing campaigns for millions of potential victims at once. These summarization tools have a lot to summarize, thanks to a string of catastrophic breaches that saw (for example) the escape of the credit histories of nearly every person in America:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Equifax_data_breach
The companies involved in those breaches were not meaningfully punished. Quite the contrary, they were allowed to buy up and merge more of their competitors, combining these new divisions' creaking servers with their own spit-and-baling-wire frankensystems, even as they fired the people who had built and maintained those systems (in the name of "efficiency").
The commercial surveillance sector has repeatedly proven itself to be more interested in profits than security or accuracy, and yet we continue to entrust them with crucial public functions, including purging electoral rolls:
https://mississippitoday.org/2026/11/10/u-s-senate-election-mississippi-andrew-goodman/
For margin-obsessed corporate leadership, IT cuts represent a unique hazard. When a manager fires the person who maintains the assembly line, the shop-floor quickly seizes up. But managers who fire IT staff inherit software that keeps chugging along long after the people who built it are gone…until it stops, and the company no longer knows how to restart it. This is one of the unique challenges of unionizing tech workers: when the tech workers go on strike, the scab software they wrote crosses the picket line on them:
https://pluralistic.net/2026/11/07/aeiou-but-sometimes-why/#unrecognizable-playbook
Tech debt has a long maturity: you can incur a lot of tech debt before the margin call comes and you find yourself in technological bankruptcy. Corporate management has spent decades playing IT Jenga, removing every available block, leaving behind a skeletal skyline of teetering towers that now routinely collapse:
https://www.404media.co/breaking-everything/
The entire IT system is grossly overleveraged and technological bankruptcies are everywhere. This is very bad, because the USA hasn't had a new consumer privacy law since 1988 (when Congress banned disclosure of your VHS rental history), which means that these eggshell-thin servers are jammed with the most sensitive data imaginable about everyone, everywhere:
https://pluralistic.net/2026/11/02/agony-verification/#great-turnbulls-ghost
Far from breaking this cycle of overaccumulation and breach of sensitive data, the AI sector is accelerating it, claiming that a single person's "consent" to use pervert glasses, always-on mics, or other surveillance equipment can stand in for the consent of everyone they meet, see, or converse with:
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/11/tech-companies-are-trying-shift-entire-concept-privacy-again
This is the new normal: everything is broken, everything is breached. It's completely normal to wake up and read panicked headlines advising companies to shut off their servers until the latest showstopper bug can be patched. Half the email you get is from companies announcing new security protocols in the wake of a fresh data breach (the other half is from companies announcing changes to their terms of service to allow them to collect even more of your data, and to ban you from suing them when that data leaks):
https://pluralistic.net/2026/10/26/abandon-hope/#all-ye-who-enter-here
So it's also normal to get phone calls, emails and texts from your bank, employer, insurer and broker asking you to verify a transaction or requiring you to sign up for a new two-factor authentication system. What's more, it's normal for these entities to insist that you immediately install a new app or go through a new authentication process that is totally unlike any of the other ones you're already using.
It's normal to log in to a service you use every day and be confronted with an entirely different login flow – a CAPTCHA unlike any you've ever seen, a requirement to visit a third-party site to complete an authentication step (which may involve taking selfies and transmitting copies of sensitive ID documents using an app from a company you've never heard of), an embedded widget that only works if you disable your browser's advanced privacy settings that prevent cross-site scripting and other horrors.
We're told to hang up on anyone who calls us from our bank or credit-card issuer and to call them back using the number on the back of our cards. But when we call our banks, we get shunted to AI chatbots that "hallucinate" nonsensical advice for accessing our accounts. If we try to reach a human, we're stuck in lengthy hold queues whose soundtrack is a looping announcement scolding us for not using a faulty chatbot or the company's broken website to solve our problems. When a human does come on the line, they often seem to be improvising a new security protocol that was created five minutes before to deal with the latest state of exception.
This is the security storm: a world of zero visibility, shifting gale-force winds, and blockages that impede your usual route and force you down unfamiliar paths every time you venture forth.
It is the perfect environment for fraudsters.
It's not just that fraudsters can impersonate anyone with AI voice-cloning or generate undetectable document forgeries: it's also the fact that your bank, HR department, insurer, credit card company and government have groomed you to expect a chaotic process that requires you to do something different every time you try to access a service.
They've groomed you to turn off your browser's advanced protections. They've groomed you to ignore your carefully created, carefully saved random passwords in favor of clicking on links that get texted or emailed to you by third-party services you've never heard of. They've groomed you to expect cold-calls from outsource fraud prevention companies that don't know how to pronounce your bank's name.
This isn't new. As far back as 2009, the cryptographer Ben Laurie was railing against "Verified by Visa," which required you to enter sensitive data into a page hosted on a domain that was separate from both your bank and the merchant you were paying, which Laurie called "Phished by Visa":
https://web.archive.org/web/20090331094020/http://www.links.org/?p=591
No one listened to Laurie. Instead, the banks got worse. I've been a customer of HSBC subsidiary Firstdirect for nearly 20 years, and in that time, I've been told to make note of a "customer ID number," a "telephone passcode", eight password recovery answers, a "web username", a web password, a "digital secure key password", a "digital secure key PIN", and a regular PIN.
Despite all this, I haven't been able to access my bank account for two months, ever since they "upgraded" their system to block app log-ins on mobile devices running the open, secure Android fork Graphene (Firstdirect doesn't use a standard two-factor authenticator; you have to use its app to generate a one-time PIN in addition to all those other authentication details every time you log in, even via a browser).
When I spoke to Firstdirect about why they'd blocked Graphene, they told me that they "considered open source to be insecure." Talk about grooming for fraudsters: telling your customers that they should only trust systems that can't be independently inspected and validated is grossly irresponsible.
(Don't worry, we're going to use the UK's excellent open banking system to switch back to the Co-Op Bank, which we left after it was mismanaged to the brink of bankruptcy and flogged to private equity; it's since been restructured as a co-op again:)
https://www.banktrack.org/success/the_cooperative_bank_bought_back_into_mutual_ownership
The perfect mark is someone who thinks they can't get scammed. The more technologically savvy and security conscious you are, the more you've encountered the incoherence of the official system and the less surprised you'll be when you're told to do something obviously insecure in order to complete a transaction: Boy, that stupid, dangerous requirement is even stupider and more dangerous than all the other stupid, dangerous things I've been forced to do this year.
That's the story of Uri Bram, a technological sophisticate who edits Atoms vs Bits and nearly got scammed trying to buy an Amtrak ticket:
https://www.atvbt.com/expected-incompetence-enables-fraud/
Bram tried to buy his Amtrak ticket on the web but found himself on a nonfunctional site that put him through a bizarre stopgap process that required him to enter his email address, click a link, log in to his Paypal account… Each step was more out-of-place than the last, but all of them had the eerie ring of plausibility, given the dysfunction of Bram's other interactions with giant, creaking companies like Amtrak. As Bram puts it: "Expected incompetence enables fraud."
The corollary is that technological excellence makes fraud easier to spot and harder to pull off. Most of our anti-fraud measures demand that you be more vigilant and more discerning. We'd be much better off if we insisted that our official institutions invest in coherent, orderly practices that are thoughtfully designed, well maintained, and staffed by easily reached experts who can guide us through our problems. It's much harder to impersonate a system where you can get through to a thoroughly trained, in-house customer service rep in a few minutes than it is to impersonate a system that's typically worse than the fraudster's vibe-coded scam website, whose "customer service" has been replaced by broken chatbots.
The ongoing collapse of all of our technology has created a permanent state of exception in which fraudsters' demands are no weirder than the ad-libbing our own essential institutions engage in every time we deal with them. The answer can't be to demand superhuman fraud-detection skills from the public: rather, we must demand excellence from our institutions:

AI-Powered Copyright Hell https://www.404media.co/ai-powered-copyright-hell/
Canadians: donate old computers to charity https://www.era.ca/
Catching AI’s mistakes is a mental burden – and a drag on productivity https://theconversation.com/catching-ais-mistakes-is-a-mental-burden-and-a-drag-on-productivity-291748
Who Controls You? https://whocontrolsyou.org/
#25yrsago SF fans have an accent https://groups.google.com/g/rec.arts.sf.fandom/c/q84niLJ1Ces/m/N86jJnyVWh4J?hl=en&pli=1
#25yrsago Photoshopping is fun https://web.archive.org/web/20011119202811/https://www.wired.com/news/culture/0,1284,48342,00.html
#25yrsago Douglas Adams' widow retrieves sixth Hitchhikers novel http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/arts/1663306.stm
#25yrsago Larry Ellison's new email server is "unbreakable" https://web.archive.org/web/20011120031748/http://www.zdnet.com/anchordesk/stories/story/0,10738,2825352,00.html
#20yrsago UK regulator: Dragon Sausages MUST contain dragon! https://web.archive.org/web/20061211183555/http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,2-2458696,00.html
#20yrsago Norway’s world-beating ebook stupidity https://appliedabstractions.com/2011/11/18/fulfilling-the-status-role-of-books/
#15yrsago More absurdity in the trial of G20 hacker, Byron Sonne https://web.archive.org/web/20111120183057/http://toronto.openfile.ca/toronto/text/lies-and-videotape-byron-sonne-trial-continues
#15yrsago Tumblr users give Congress an earful about SOPA https://staff.tumblr.com/post/12930076128/a-historic-thing
#15yrsago Congress: pizza is a vegetable when it is fed to children https://web.archive.org/web/20111119160044/http://healthyschoolscampaign.typepad.com/healthy_schools_campaign/2011/11/pizza-is-a-vegetable-how-the-spending-bill-in-congress-could-unravel-progress-on-school-nutrition.html
#10yrsago Tech companies: you have 63 days to make these 5 changes to protect your users before Trump is sworn in https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2016/11/tech-companies-fix-these-technical-issues-its-too-late
#10yrsago Hugely successful Facebook fake news author considers himself a “satirist” https://web.archive.org/web/20161117151755/https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2016/11/17/facebook-fake-news-writer-i-think-donald-trump-is-in-the-white-house-because-of-me/
#10yrsago Trump called climate change a Chinese hoax but he wants a massive seawall around his resort https://web.archive.org/web/20161119025054/https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/17/donald-trump-ireland-golf-resort-wall-climate-change
#10yrsago Entrepreneurs explain how Obamacare let them found businesses and create jobs https://web.archive.org/web/20161118234128/https://money.cnn.com/2016/11/18/news/economy/obamacare-entrepreneurs-trump/index.html
#10yrsago Tax Inspectors Without Borders: poor countries send each other ninja tax collectors to nail looting multinationals https://taxjustice.net/2016/11/17/tax-inspectors-without-borders-us-president-trump-tax-justice-november-2016-podcast/
#10yrsago Nimona: a YA graphic novel that raises serious, unanswerable moral quandries with snappy dialog and slapstick https://memex.craphound.com/2016/11/18/nimona-a-ya-graphic-novel-that-raises-serious-unanswerable-moral-quandries-with-snappy-dialog-and-slapstick/
#5yrsago Harvard is full of rich, white low-achievers https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/18/bipartisan-consensus/#meritocracy
#5yrsago This is your Congress on drugs https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/18/bipartisan-consensus/#corruption
#1yrago Disney has lost Roger Rabbit https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/18/im-not-bad/#im-just-drawn-that-way

Sheffield: Reverse Centaur at Juno Books, Nov 25
https://www.outsavvy.com/event/40274/cory-doctorow-in-conversation
Virtual: Enshittification, AI, and the Future of Technology (UBC Master of Educational Technology), Nov 28
https://met.ubc.ca/2026/09/met-speaker-series-cory-doctorow-enshittification-ai-and-the-future-of-technology/
Oxford: Bennett Oxford Symposium on Open Code in Science, Dec 9
https://www.bennett.ox.ac.uk/events/2026-bennett-institute-symposium/
Santa Barbara: UCSB Reads, Apr 29
https://www.library.ucsb.edu/events-exhibitions/ucsb-reads-2027-presents-author-cory-doctorow
Montreal: World Science Fiction Convention, Sep 2-6
https://montreal2027.ca/en
Life After AI (Brain Bar)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPPa43-n0vI
Terms of Service with Clare Duffy (CNN)
https://www.cnn.com/audio/podcasts/terms-of-service-with-clare-duffy/episodes/458ce968-af5d-11f0-b539-13ed2afe25f8
AI, Work, and Power (Software Engineering Daily)
AI, Work, and Power https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/podcasts/cory-doctorow-on-ai-work-and-power/
AI, Corporate Power, and the Fight for Worker Control (Plutopia)
https://plutopia.io/cory-doctorow-ai-corporate-power-and-the-fight-for-worker-control/
"Canny Valley": A limited edition collection of the collages I create for Pluralistic, self-published, September 2025 https://pluralistic.net/2025/09/04/illustrious/#chairman-bruce
"Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, October 7 2025
https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374619329/enshittification/
"Picks and Shovels": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about the heroic era of the PC, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2025 (https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250865908/picksandshovels).
"The Bezzle": a sequel to "Red Team Blues," about prison-tech and other grifts, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), February 2024 (thebezzle.org).
"The Lost Cause:" a solarpunk novel of hope in the climate emergency, Tor Books (US), Head of Zeus (UK), November 2023 (http://lost-cause.org).
"The Internet Con": A nonfiction book about interoperability and Big Tech (Verso) September 2023 (http://seizethemeansofcomputation.org). Signed copies at Book Soup (https://www.booksoup.com/book/9781804291245).
"Red Team Blues": "A grabby, compulsive thriller that will leave you knowing more about how the world works than you did before." Tor Books http://redteamblues.com.
"Chokepoint Capitalism: How to Beat Big Tech, Tame Big Content, and Get Artists Paid, with Rebecca Giblin", on how to unrig the markets for creative labor, Beacon Press/Scribe 2022 https://chokepointcapitalism.com
"Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027
"Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027
"The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027
Today's top sources:
Currently writing:
"The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.
A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING

This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.
Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
https://pluralistic.net/plura-list
Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):
Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):
https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net
Medium (no ads, paywalled):
Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):
https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic
"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla
READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.
ISSN: 3066-764X
Pirate Site Movix’s Source Code Survives Four Rounds of GitHub Takedowns [TorrentFreak]
In March, a Paris court ordered French Internet providers Orange, SFR, Free and Bouygues Telecom to block Movix, together with 21 other pirate sites.
Like many pirate sites, the streaming portal simply moved on to new domain names. However, Movix also stands out in another way. The code that powers the site is shared openly on GitHub, for anyone to copy and use.
The repository includes the site’s frontend and backend, as well as a browser extension and mobile apps. The README presents Movix as France’s first open source streaming site with an AI twist, adding that it was entirely vibe-coded.
The shared code didn’t go unnoticed, of course. ALPA, the French anti-piracy group whose members include the local arms of major Hollywood studios, the MPA and music rights group SACEM, has been sending takedown notices to GitHub over the Movix code since March.
The first two notices were sent in March and April, targeting Movix repositories uploaded by the same GitHub account. GitHub blocked both repositories at the time. In the second notice ALPA also asked the platform to ban the uploader, but the account is still active today.
While the repositories were taken offline, the source code soon resurfaced. A new GitHub account was created two weeks after the April takedown, and archived copies show that it hosted a fresh copy of the code by early May. By late June, the repository had 94 stars and 21 forks.
ALPA eventually went after that repository too, sending a new takedown request in September, and GitHub blocked it the next day. That still left the forks online, however, which ALPA eventually targeted last week.
“We are now targeting forks which are exact copies,” ALPA writes in its notice, which lists 38 forks. The forks we checked were blocked by GitHub a day later.

The notice doesn’t mention any specific movies or TV shows either. ALPA writes that its members own the rights to the titles “listed below”, but there are none mentioned.
ALPA also repeats its request to ban the uploader of the September repository, linking it to the March and April copies. Its September notice made the same claim about that second GitHub account, using the exact same words.
“This is the third repost from this user […] please ban this user as well,” ALPA’s latest notice reads.
| Notice | Target | Blocked by GitHub |
|---|---|---|
| March 26 | First Movix repository | March 26 |
| April 14 | Second repository, same account (ban requested) | April 14 |
| September 22 | New repository, second account | September 23 |
| November 12 | 38 forks | November 13* |
ALPA’s recent notices point to the blocking order from the Paris Judicial Court. This was issued following a request from several French film industry groups, ordering Internet providers to block 22 pirate sites for 18 months.
This order also shows how popular Movix was. According to the evidence presented to the court, the site offered 7,236 movies and 2,956 series without permission.
The same evidence, provided by ALPA’s sworn agents, shows that Movix drew more than 387,000 unique French visitors in a single month. That’s more than any of the other 21 sites in that blocking order.

ALPA’s Github takedowns removed the targeted repositories, but now the code itself is leading a life of its own. A fresh copy is still online today, under yet another new GitHub account.
Data from GitHub shows that both the GitHub account and the repository were created on September 24, less than a day after GitHub blocked the previous version.
According to its commit messages, the repository mirrors the full Movix code excluding some private files. The most recent sync was on November 15, which is three days after ALPA’s latest notice. These updates are credited to the GitHub user that ALPA asked GitHub to ban in April.
In addition to the code, there is no shortage of full streaming sites using the Movix brand today. Whether ALPA will target these and the new GitHub copy, which already has 21 forks of its own, has yet to be seen.
—
ALPA’s latest takedown notice is available on GitHub. The Paris court order can be found here (in French).
From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.
Two Video Games With Identical Names Went Way Beyond Managing To Coexist [Techdirt]
In the video game industry, trademark disputes over similarly named games are not remotely uncommon. Usually when this happens, we’re talking about one same or similar word amongst games names: “scroll”, or “rage”, or “wasteland”. Those tend to annoy us, because they seem certain to fail the real test of trademark law in most cases, which is whether or not the buying public will be confused about an association or similar source between the products.
But what if there were two games named identically that were released in close proximity to each other? We saw that exact thing happen earlier this year, when two unrelated games that shared the title Piece by Piece were released on Steam.
Earlier this year, Piece by Piece launched on Steam. Then another game, also called Piece by Piece, launched on Steam.
“Back when we announced the Steam launch date for our Piece by Piece in March, a day later the Piece by Piece from Neon Polygons also announced their launch date, and it was two days after ours,” said Mike Rose, co-founder of No More Robots. He said he got a nervous email from Neon Polygons, concerned that No More Robots would go after them for having a game of the same name.
This sort of thing happens all the time, of course. Two companies or developers working separately on projects that have similar, or identical in this case, titles for their work by pure happenstance. There’s nothing malicious here. There’s no intent to confuse anyone, or to ride off of someone’s coattails.
But because this is business and the only way to really protect your investment is to participate in the IP-maxing of your product… right?
As it turns out, no, you can just be human and awesome instead.
“I got back to them and said ‘Well, that’s just hilarious. Do you wanna bundle up on Steam? I did it partially because it was a nice / fun thing to do, but I also kinda did it because I love chaos.”
It’s a beautiful story about how not being an asshole can lead to other joint business opportunities, so long as you don’t default to IP protectionism. The games are different, nobody is confused, but why not bundle them together.
It’s a great little tale if that’s as far as it went. But it gets funnier when they decided to keep teaming up for a release on Nintendo’s Switch.
Now they’re launching together on the Switch under the same publishing label, because sometimes video games and the people who make them are good.
“We had to explain over and over again, to each separate Nintendo organization (Europe, Japan, America), that ‘No, sorry but those are two separate games. Yes, they have the same name. Yes, they have the same release date. Yes, we are very sorry. We promise we won’t do this again,’” Rose said.
It apparently took repeated conversations to explain to Nintendo why the two companies were working together instead of slugging it out either in court or with the USPTO over trademark concerns. It’s quite fun for me to picture Nintendo execs and lawyers sitting around a conference room phone, being told by these two developers that they’re not going to war over the shared titles, as they sit their with confused looks because that just doesn’t compute to Nintendo.
More of this please. More people choosing humanity over IP maximalism. It’ll make the world a better, more fun place, I promise you.
China in the Spotlight: Nvidia Honeypot, Iranian Oil and the APEC Summit [The Status Kuo]
I’ve got a special Big Picture edition today, with help from one of the world’s leading observers of China, Kaiser Kuo—who also happens to be my brother! Kaiser hosts the Sinica podcast, and he’s got a front row seat at his home base in Beijing.
There’s a lot lately to cover. An alleged Chinese honeypot spy has brought down Nvidia’s Jensen Huang. Beijing is still buying Tehran’s oil as the war with Iran grinds on. And Trump heads to an APEC summit this week with fellow autocrats Xi and Putin.
Kaiser has keen insights into the Chinese perspective on all this. And as a bonus he named for me the one thing Americans most consistently get wrong about China.
Look for my piece later today if you’re a subscriber to The Big Picture. If you’re not, you can sign up for free or become a valued paid supporter of our work here:
https://thinkbigpicture.substack.com/subscribe
I’ll be back tomorrow with my regular edition of The Status Kuo.
Jay
Robbie Williams Defends Olivia Rodrigo, Calls Song-Similarity Claims ‘Ambulance Chasing’ [Techdirt]
Over the last decade and a half we’ve seen a flood of very stupid copyright lawsuits, often from old, washed-up artists (or worse, their estates), demanding money from younger artists because new songs have some similarities — a feel, a melodic snippet, the same chord progression, whatever. The worst example of this, obviously, was the infamous Blurred Lines case, which ended stupidly, and kicked off a bunch of other similar lawsuits (many of which haven’t been as successful). It’s gotten so ridiculous that some artists now film their entire writing process in case they later have to go to court to defend their creative process.
Anyway, it looked like we might be getting another one of those silly situations when some people started pointing out that Olivia Rodrigo’s recent release, take me home (4 christmas), sounds similar to Robbie Williams’s Candy, from back in 2012. Of course, making this even more complicated is that Rodrigo has said her song was inspired by the 1981 song Christmas Wrapping from the band The Waitresses, and claims she spoke to that band’s Christopher Butler before writing her own song.
What usually happens next is that the online murmurings get louder and louder until the older artist finally says or does something — often demanding a cut of the royalties. But this time, Robbie Williams did something different: he published a rant (in image form on Instagram) defending Rodrigo while knocking musicians who rush to “go after” anyone whose songs sound a bit like their own.
Since reading text in images is perhaps the most annoying way to do anything, I’ve transcribed his 4 image rant below:
There’s something about the music industry that’s been bothering me for a while.
People coming after people because they’ve spotted a similarity between two songs.
Some of it I completely understand. Some of it is absolutely justified.
Most of it, I think, is complete bollocks.
I’ve had plenty of people come after me over the years because something I’ve released apparently sounds like something somebody else released.
And sometimes I listen and think, fair enough, I can hear that.
Other times I think, are you having a fucking laugh?
There are only so many notes. Only so many chords. Only so many ways of putting them together before you inevitably find yourself somewhere somebody else has been.
Music has been around for a very long time.
We’re all going to bump into each other eventually.
Which brings me to Olivia Rodrigo.
I love Olivia Rodrigo.
I’ve loved her since Brutal. What a fucking record. I wish I’d made it.
Also, I cannot believe how much she swears on stage. And that’s coming from me. I’m a Sweary Mary, but she’s making me look like a Victorian schoolmistress.
Anyway.
It sounds to me as though she may have accidentally stumbled across a musical echo of mine in one of her new songs.
And do you know what?
I couldn’t care less.
I don’t know whether there’s technically a publishing issue, a copyright issue, or no issue whatsoever.
And I don’t want to know.
I’m not going after her.
Because I think at some point, some fucking sanity has to prevail.
Now, I appreciate I’m in a position in my career where I can afford to take that view. Not everybody is. And genuine theft is genuine theft. Artists deserve to be protected. But there’s a difference between protecting your work and treating every vaguely familiar sequence of notes as a winning lottery ticket.
Some of this stuff has become ambulance chasing.
And I think it’s disgusting.
We all stand on the shoulders of people who came before us. Sometimes consciously. Sometimes without even knowing it.
That’s how music works.
If we keep punishing people for accidentally arriving somewhere somebody else has already been, eventually we’re going to frighten the creativity out of everyone.
Anyway.
Olivia, if you’re reading this, I think you’re fucking brilliant. But please stop swearing so much.
It makes me feel like I have to keep up.
And frankly, I’m already swearing far more than is necessary.
Lots of love and Happy Christmas
Rob x
There are a bunch of good points there (some of which we’ve made before), including that this is how music works. Almost all musicians start out by imitating their favorite artists and then learning how to add their own style and signature to the music. Sometimes they add in bits as an homage. Sometimes they just do it accidentally because — as Robbie notes — there are only so many notes (and even fewer combinations of them that actually sound good together).
Of course there may be some complicating factors. Williams can say all of that, but it looks like there may be other copyright interests in the song, considering that he co-wrote it with some others, and it includes a riff from a different song (from one of the people listed as a co-author of Candy, Terje Olsen). It’s also not clear if Williams owns his own publishing, and publishing companies can be especially annoying. And that’s not even getting into the complications regarding the 1981 song by The Waitresses as well.
It’s also worth noting that Rodrigo has had to give up royalties to other artists in the past as well, which some are suggesting means that Rodrigo “has a history” of this kind of thing, but to me suggests (again) that lots of music borrows ideas — consciously or unconsciously from others — and people should just be more chill about it. Like Robbie Williams here.
In this era when everyone wants to lawyer up and demand things, it’s always nice when someone just comes out and says “yo, this is fucking crazy, I don’t want any part of it, the music is great, can we please just enjoy that.”
Vice-President Grassley And The Bipartisan Politics Of An Imminent Trump Impeachment [Techdirt]
There was always a deal to be made similar to the one that is described here, had Democrat leadership ever had the vision, skill, and courage to pursue it. But now, after the last election, it is even easier to play the political musical chairs that impeachment would involve, and to everyone’s satisfaction.
There never was a reason to wait to impeach Trump, and there certainly isn’t one at this point. There is plenty of evidence upon which to predicate it (pretty much any two Truth Social posts would provide sufficient basis), and the Constitution requires little more than two votes on it: one in the House to impeach, and one in the Senate to convict. Trump could be gone in a day, and given all the damage he causes every minute he remains, there is no time to lose to get started.
One of the main arguments people have nevertheless put forth to try to justify the Democrats’ refusal to pursue impeachment against Trump has been “they don’t have the votes.” Already it was a ridiculous argument: in the House, if the Democratic caucus had been united in pursuing it, they would have only needed to peel off a few Republicans to come join them, and, depending on absences, potentially very few. And had the Democrats been united behind impeachment it would have changed the political math enough for the GOP to think seriously about joining them—whereas given the Democrats abject refusal to get on board with it there was never any reason for any Republican to ever even consider it either.
(Meanwhile, even if Democrats were somehow correct to have been deterred from moving forward with an actual impeachment attempt, the numbers certainly didn’t justify not even beginning to pound the drum on eventually impeaching. After all, if you don’t have the votes today, the job is to work towards getting them tomorrow. And then using them once you do, as they most definitely do now.)
Still, while having enough votes in the House is not an issue—come January the Democrats will have plenty of their own, without needing GOP help—there is still the question of the Senate, which is what this post is about. Like with the House getting the votes needed to convict and actually remove Trump always was possible, if only Democrat leadership had the vision to see it. And now, after the election, it is even more possible, if only Democrats would finally do what is needed to line them up.
Obviously at 56 Senators (or 55 with the Fetterman discount) Democrats cannot vote to remove Trump from office by themselves. But there has always been a deal to be done, which is now even easier to do, to get Republicans on board by making it worth their while politically. Especially after the drubbing this November even the most politically obtuse Republicans must understand that Trump is an albatross hanging around their neck, destroying their political futures and the prospects for any policy they hoped to advance. While they might have been afraid to try to make a move against Trump before November, fearing his cult-like popularity would make it impossible to politically survive such an attempt, they now know that his popularity is at best fragile if not illusory. Even many MAGA adherents, even if still generally on Team Trump, have been openly speaking about their dismay in him not delivering on what he promised (and instead delivering the exact opposite). In any case, there is now evidence of a nation-wide appetite to be done with Trump, which everyone, including and especially the Senators up for reelection in 2028, both Republican AND Democrat, needs to heed. Their future political fortunes depend on it, and everyone now knows it.
But for Republicans, their political interests are not just limited to being rid of Trump. Impeachment also creates political opportunity due to all the vacancies it creates, starting in the Presidency itself. With the Presidency empty, the Vice President is automatically promoted into it, which then leaves the Vice Presidency empty and waiting to be filled. Which is where things get interesting, because it is not filled automatically but by presidential appointment. And if it’s filled with a sitting Senator, then it also creates an opportunity to appoint another to replace them in the Senate. Thus it is time for Democrat leaders with vision to start choreographing the political dance that impeachment could soon have everyone on both sides of the aisle moving to.
Obviously whether such a deal should be seen as a win for Democrats and the country depends on accepting one thing: that just about any alternative is better than Trump. Even the most craven and crooked Republican is still better than Trump, who is corrupt on a scale even regularly corrupt politicians could hardly imagine. Even the most sinister and cynical Republican is still better than Trump because, unlike Trump, they don’t have a cult of personality to fuel their administration’s malevolence. And the reality remains: Trump is a volatile, reckless, exigent, and uncontained threat to the security of the nation every moment he remains in office. Any alternative who is even slightly less of a danger is a necessary and imminently needed improvement.
Which is why, yes, even J.D. Vance is still an improvement, awful though he is. He is at least a little smarter, and also less popular, which means people will be able to say no to him where they have been unable to say no to Trump. But there is also an opportunity here: if the Democrats play their cards right there is a chance that instead of just a bad but better deal that elevates Vance, they could get one that brings them even more advantage.
Any deal of course does begin with Vance. He obviously has aspirations for the Oval Office, and since the election has shown himself willing to knife Trump. He is, for purposes of saving our democracy from Trump, an available ally, however inadvertently, for Democrats who are serious about that country-saving mission to work with. And there is a definitely a deal to be made with him: help him get his dream job in exchange for his agreement on policy that Democrats are obviously not going to be able to get from Trump and his vindictive veto (no matter how much they delude themselves to the contrary).
The downside to this deal—apart from just having to live with President Vance for two years—is that there is a presumed incumbent advantage come the next presidential election, but a strong Democratic majority can keep him on a short enough leash to keep the political momentum for Democrats heading into 2028. (Whereas refusing to anything about the Trump problem essentially crashes the momentum into a wall—why should anyone reward Democrats with more power ever again when they are content to use what they have to so willingly surrender the country to Putin’s puppet?). Also, this is VANCE that we’re talking about, someone whom people have rarely ever actually wanted to vote for, which is unlikely to change after the public sees him in action. Which is also why this deal may start to be palatable to Republicans as well, particularly those with their own presidential ambitions that an incumbent Vance is unlikely to obstruct.
Especially because there is a more immediate benefit for Republicans, whose votes are still needed for removal, if the right deal is done. Vance’s promotion would leave a vacancy in the Vice Presidency. There is no automatic successor, which means that filling the office requires a Presidential appointment. So part of the deal to elevate Vance would involve pre-emptively deciding whom Vance would appoint to replace him. And it could entice impeachment votes if that choice is a GOP Senator.
From the standpoint of defending the nation, ANY GOP Senator would do, but if the Democrats can present a strong front, they can probably make a strategic suggestion on whom that GOP Senator should be. And someone like Iowa Senator Grassley would be a good choice, for both parties, for several reasons.
From the Republican perspective, in light of his age, he will not have much of an incumbent advantage come 2028 and thus not be an obstacle to anyone else’s presidential ambitions either. Also, by being quite senior it means that his departure from the Senate will create the opportunity for those Republicans remaining in the Senate to seek better positions on committees once he is no longer filling his—everyone gets to move up. In other words: when he’s gone, they get more power.
Grassley is also a good choice for Democrats because he would create a Senatorial vacancy that would now be filled by a Democratic governor. Not every state allows the governor to fill a Senate vacancy (such was the issue with replacing McConnell, because Kentucky was not one that allowed for such gubernatorial appointments), and even of the ones that do, sometimes they are limited in whom they can appoint, but Iowa is not one of these limited states. Come January the governor of Iowa will be a Democrat who can appoint another Democrat to replace Grassley.
Granted, Republicans might not be too cheerful about this prospect, losing another Senate seat and one the Democratic incumbent is likely to keep, but they would still be getting a lot out of the deal, and the substitute Senator for Grassley’s seat would only have a two year term anyway, at which point a young Republican would be able to mount a challenge for it. In fact, given the results from November, which suggest Republicans would lose the seat anyway, and Grassley’s incumbency, which would potentially prevent a newcomer, Republicans still are, on balance, potentially better off elevating Grassley to the Vice Presidency than not.
In sum, with a deal like this Republicans get a marginally more politically competent but unpopular incumbent in the White House, and an older one in the Vice Presidency, with new opportunity for others in the party to advance in the Senate, while Democrats get another Democratic Senator. Plus it would allow for the Cabinet to be quickly cleared out of its barbarous and/or billionaire boobs and replaced by people even marginally more competent without anyone having to spend the time and political energy individually impeaching anyone currently there (which would also be part of the deal with Vance).
And we all get rid of Trump. By January 4, even, if they all start working out the details now.
Parodist Threatened By Lauren Boebert Gets The Last Laugh [Techdirt]
Back in 2021, we wrote about the incredibly stupid threat letter that Rep. Lauren Boebert’s office had sent to parodist Toby Morton, who had put up a parody campaign website for her at TheLaurenBoebert.com (it appears the site itself is no longer up). The letter, from her press secretary, was one of the dumbest I’d seen in a while, claiming that the images of Boebert on the site “are copyrighted property of the U.S. Federal Government. They are the property of the office of Congressman Lauren Boebert, and your use of them is unauthorized and illegal.” Also, “the entire website is a defamatory impersonation, and it goes against relevant terms of service and U.S. law.”

That was absolute garbage at the time and our original article explained why they were wrong on basically every legal claim. I had also emailed the press secretary directly with a list of six questions (including: “Did you speak to a lawyer before sending that email?” and “What law does ‘defamatory impersonation’ refer to?”). I never heard back.
Anyway, you may have heard that Lauren Boebert has had a not-so-happy ending to her congressional career after losing her seat in the midterms to retired Navy rear admiral Eileen Laubacher. Morton decided that the moment the race was called was the perfect time to finally respond to an undated follow-up email from Boebert’s office. That one skipped the bumptious legal threats and instead just predicted that Boebert’s career prospects were looking up compared to Morton’s:
Subject: Fake Website
Mr. Morton, Despite your continued attempts to undermine Congresswoman Boebert through your websites and public ridicule, she remains confident in her political future.
She looks forward to advancing her career while watching your efforts ultimately fail and your relevance fade.
Her success will speak for itself. As will your failure.
Years later, with the news of Boebert’s loss just hitting the headlines, Morton responded:
Subject: Re: Fake Website
My sincerest apologies for taking over four years to respond to this email.
I’ve been terribly busy building websites visited by millions, growing an audience of hundreds of thousands, and receiving national media coverage. You know, failing.
I do hope you’ll forgive my tardiness. I remember your adorable little prediction about my inevitable irrelevance and Congresswoman Boebert’s glorious political future. How’s that coming along, by the way?
My websites are thriving. My audience keeps growing. And your email has aged with all the dignity of a gas station hot dog. I’m actually having it framed.
My favorite part remains: “Her success will speak for itself. As will your failure.” Such confidence. Such conviction. Such an extraordinary misunderstanding of how the future works. Four years later, I wanted to personally thank you for providing a punchline so devastating that even I couldn’t have written it better.
I make a living humiliating powerful people, but watching you do it to yourselves, in writing, completely unsolicited, has been a genuine professional pleasure.
Please extend my warmest regards to the former congresswoman. And thank you again for reminding me that sometimes the most effective satire is simply allowing stupid people to finish their sentences.
Dog Bless, and go fuck yourselves.
Toby Morton
That has to be one of the most satisfying emails anyone has ever sent. Mocking the powerful is about as American as it gets, and those who try to shut it down with a pile of nonsense legal claims deserve to have it come back around on them, preferably in writing, and preferably framed.
Daily Deal: Toybox Alpha Four 3D Printer Starter Bundle [Techdirt]
Get the Toybox Alpha Four compact 3D printer and a coconut Printer Food spool in one bundle for $299.99, so you have the printer and filament to start making toys at home. Automatic mesh bed leveling calibrates the print bed for you. Typical print speeds of 240 mm/s, with a maximum of 300 mm/s, mean less waiting between prints.
Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.
Pissed-Off Judge Orders Release Of Canadian Man Arrested By ICE During Green Card Interview [Techdirt]
This is what ICE has been doing for months now. It hasn’t been looking for the “worst of the worst” because that means actually engaging in targeted investigations and relying on the experience and training of officers to make sure these criminals are arrested without incident.
ICE can no longer rely on “training and experience” because those aspects have been sidelined as the Trump administration seeks pretty much un-vetted bodies to hurl into its various “surges” — all of which have focused on cities and states where Trump failed to carry a majority of the vote.
Taking down actual threats to public safety is actual work, and ICE doesn’t want anything to do with that. After spending a month or so standing around with its hands in its pockets at airports, ICE officers are still roaming the streets, lurking around construction sites, and nodding off in immigration court buildings — two places officers are likely to find migrants, even though these migrants are definitely not dangerous.
And so it goes here. Here’s the desperado ICE officers managed to “hunt” down in Minnesota by doing nothing more than ambushing him when showed up for a scheduled green card interview.
[Dr. William] Lizardo moved to the U.S. on a student visa in 2019 to study at the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry, according to court documents. He graduated in 2023 and married an American that same year. They had a daughter two years later.
Lizardo’s wife filed a petition for an alien relative in September 2023, while Lizardo applied to adjust his status to permanent residency. The relative petition was approved in January 2025, according to the court.
Lizardo practised dentistry in federally-designated shortage areas until his work authorization was revoked, at which time he started volunteering at a low-cost clinic in Burnsville, Minn., according to the court documents.
Wow. What an absolute fiend. Look at this “illegal,” who continued to help the less fortunate even when he was no longer being paid to do so.
The government argued it had all the right in the world to arrest Dr. Lizardo (not the one you’re thinking of, if you think anything like me). It said that Lizardo had violated the terms of his ongoing residence by failing to show up for permanent residency hearings, despite being notified by the government.
The court, however, sees it differently (and far more accurately.) Lizardo did everything he was supposed to do to keep the government informed of his whereabouts as he continued to seek permanent residency. That the government failed to put in the same effort Lizardo did is not Lizardo’s fault:
The judge called the facts of the case “appalling” — noting that while the couple moved several times, each time Lizardo “filed changes of address” with the post office and with U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services (USCIS). “In turn, USCIS communicated with Petitioner at each new address.”
While that paraphrasing by the CBC might suggest the government was still technically correct, the full court order [PDF] makes it clear the government engaged in opportunism, rather than actual justice, when kidnapping Lizardo following a scheduled check-in with immigration officials.
First off, no one cared about the things that happened back in 2023 (the notices sent by the government to the wrong addresses despite having updated address information) until Trump resumed his control of the White House. Only then did ICE, etc. get shitty about this paperwork mixup that was almost entirely the government’s fault. After years of once-a-year scheduling, USCIS decided to file (and mail) a flurry of communications about Lizardo’s residence application beginning on January, 25, 2026. Five weeks later, the government unilataterally decided a lack of response meant Lizardo no longer cared to reside in the country legally.
Lizardo, however, did not receive these notices, at least according to the court that handled his sworn statements and testimony. Rather than give Lizardo a chance to catch up with an unexpected surge of status changes by USCIS, ICE officers decided to perform a crime of opportunity:
Petitioner first learned about the NTA, the hearing, and his removal order when he appeared with counsel at an October 23, 2026 immigration interview in St. Paul, MN. Petitioner was arrested by two ICE agents at the end of the interview on a Form I-205 Warrant of Removal signed by David Easterwood. (Exs. A ¶ 5; B ¶ 4; C ¶ 3; D-2.) Petitioner was transported to the Sherburne County Jail where he remains in ICE custody.
If the name “David Easterwood” sounds familiar, it’s only slightly more than a coincidence. My browsing of Distributed Denial of Secrets’ DHS files featured a screenshot of this very person’s contact info — which indicates he’s a “deputy field office director” operating out of the Whipple Federal Building (which is also an ICE detention center) in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
While that’s immediately relevant and possibly only somewhat interesting, Easterwood isn’t necessarily the problem, even if he’s the one making the problematic calls at this field office. What really matters is that any of this was done at all, no matter whose finger was on the proverbial button.
The government argued the case is now moot, now that it’s unilaterally decided Lizardo is being held under a different statute than the one he cited in his habeas motion. The court won’t abide this procedural bullshit, however, going on to berate ICE for its general shittiness.
Respondents now admit that the reason Petitioner was arrested and detained no longer applies. However, they still insist he must be detained without the opportunity for release under § 1225(b)(2). The hubris of admitting that USCIS made a big mistake, but not even offering any sort of relief is galling, although not surprising. There is no combination of facts or legal argument that can support this position.
And while I, personally, would have thoroughly enjoyed another dozen pages or so of the court specifically pointing out each and every aspect of ICE’s bullshit, the court isn’t writing for me. It’s writing for Dr. Lizardo, whose rights have been so obviously violated that expounding on the violations at length would not only delay justice, but possibly allow the government to further delay justice by submitting an emergency appeal full of stupid, self-serving nitpicks.
Because the facts presented here are so appalling and so well supported, the Court could issue a long order, complete with colorful details about, and commentary on, the abuses suffered by Petitioner. However, because the Court is determined that Petitioner will not spend another night in the Sherburne County Jail, the following order cuts to the legal necessities.
And while this obviously addresses the Fourth Amendment violations contained in Lizardo’s arrest, it also touches on the due process rights he was denied when ICE decided to do the easiest thing and arrest someone who was attempting to become legally nationalized under existing laws.
ICE agents had no reason to believe Petitioner was a flight risk. He has appeared for every hearing for which he received notice and has never been involved with American law enforcement. He also kept USCIS apprised of address changes, which, of course, is the whole reason we are where we are. He has a family; deep ties to the community, as shown, in part, by his selfless provision of free dental services to Minnesota residents; and a community ofsupporters, including many Americans, as demonstrated by over a dozen letters of support in the record. It strains credulity to think that such a petitioner would flee.
Is Lizardo finally free to go? Well, we would assume this order makes it explicitly clear that he is. However, ICE’s new tactic of choice is re-arresting people who’ve been freed by orders like this one, resetting the clock on due process and forcing arrestees, legal representation, and federal courts to engage in the DHS’s sick, cruel game of “hide the detainee”. If the DHS wins, the person will be expelled to whatever country is willing to take them first. If the system of checks and balances wins, ICE will just “rinse, repeat” since it has all the money, personnel, and presidential support it needs to do whatever the fuck it wants until a regime change forces it to actually respect the law and the US Constitution.
| RSS | Site | Updated |
|---|---|---|
| XML | About Tagaini Jisho on Tagaini Jisho | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Arch Linux: Releases | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Carlson Calamities | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Debian News | 2026-11-19 02:00 PM |
| XML | Debian Security | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | debito.org | 2026-11-19 02:00 PM |
| XML | dperkins | 2026-11-19 02:00 AM |
| XML | F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | General Union | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | GIMP | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Japan Bash | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Japan English Teacher Feed | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Kanji of the Day | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Let's Encrypt | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Marc Jones | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Marjorie's Blog | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | OpenStreetMap Japan | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | OsmAnd Blog | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Popehat | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Ramen Adventures | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Release notes from server | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect | 2026-11-19 02:00 AM |
| XML | SNA Japan | 2026-11-19 02:00 AM |
| XML | Tatoeba Project Blog | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Techdirt | 2026-11-19 02:00 PM |
| XML | The Business of Printing Books | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | The Luddite | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | The Popehat Report | 2026-11-19 02:00 AM |
| XML | The Status Kuo | 2026-11-19 02:00 AM |
| XML | The Stranger | 2026-11-19 04:00 AM |
| XML | Tor Project blog | 2026-11-19 02:00 PM |
| XML | TorrentFreak | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | what if? | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |
| XML | Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed | 2026-11-12 07:00 PM |
| XML | xkcd.com | 2026-11-19 09:00 AM |