News

Tuesday 2026-11-17

08:00 AM

Trump DOJ Folds, Agrees To Permanent Ban On Censoring ICE Tracking Group And App [Techdirt]

Despite years of hype and nonsense about the Biden admin supposedly “censoring” people on social media, when that case finally went to court, it became clear that there was nothing behind it beyond a conspiracy theory. Yet when the Trump administration openly took credit for getting social media sites to suppress speech it didn’t like, it barely got any coverage at all. But, at least someone sued, and in a much lower profile case than the one during the Biden era, Trump’s Justice Department has now thrown in the towel and promised to stop censoring at least one ICE tracking group on social media.

You may recall that, back during the Biden admin, there was the huge Murthy case, involving two states (Missouri & Louisiana) and a crew of MAGA influencers insisting that the Biden admin had caused social media sites like Facebook and Twitter to “censor” their “conservative” views. While the case got some headline-grabbing rulings in the lower courts from famously Trump-supporting judges, by the time it reached the Supreme Court, most of the court (including Amy Coney Barrett, who wrote the opinion) realized that there was basically no actual evidence of Biden-admin coercion because it was almost entirely a MAGA-brained conspiracy theory.

The real issue in the case was understanding the difference between persuasion and coercion. The government is absolutely allowed to explain to platforms why it thinks that information should be removed, so long as there is no threat involved. Indeed, when the Murthy case was heard, two Justices from opposite ends of the Court’s ideological spectrum, both of whom had spent time as White House lawyers — Elena Kagan and Brett Kavanaugh — both mocked the lawyer representing the states for acting like it was a huge breach of decorum for the government to try to persuade private companies to do something.

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Do you think on the anger point, I guess I had assumed, thought, experienced government press people throughout the federal government who regularly call up the media and — and berate them. Is that — I mean, is that not —

MR. FLETCHER: I — I — I don’t want

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: — your understanding? You said the anger here was unusual. I guess I wasn’t —

MR. FLETCHER: So that —

JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: — wasn’t entirely clear on that from my own experience.

And then Kagan:

JUSTICE KAGAN: I mean, can I just understand because it seems like an extremely expansive argument, I must say, encouraging people basically to suppress their own speech. So, like Justice Kavanaugh, I’ve had some experience encouraging press to suppress their own speech.

You just wrote about editorial. Here are the five reasons you shouldn’t write another one. You just wrote a story that’s filled with factual errors. Here are the 10 reasons why you shouldn’t do that again.

I mean, this happens literally thousands of times a day in the federal government.

When the eventual ruling came out, ACB pointed out five separate times the near total lack of evidence of coercion, and (in a footnote) pointed out that the lower court rulings arguing the opposite relied on “clearly erroneous” factual findings.

But, that didn’t mean the Supreme Court said it was fair game for government censorship, even if MAGA folks pretended that’s what the court said. Because the very same day that the Supreme Court heard the Murthy case, they also heard the Vullo case, which involved actual government coercion against intermediaries to suppress speech, in this case, targeting the NRA. The 9-0 ruling in that case (Vullo) made it quite clear that if there is actual government coercion against a third party to suppress speech, that violates the First Amendment.

Fast forward to the second Trump administration, which got into office partly based on the false claims that they supported free speech while the Democrats did not. They almost immediately set about creating a vast censorship machine (“we can do this the easy way or the hard way“) that they proudly bragged about.

One of those involved was then Attorney General Pam Bondi, calling up Apple and Facebook to get them to remove ICE tracking groups and apps. At the time, we wondered aloud why all the “free speech warriors” who spent years screaming about the “censorship industrial complex” under Biden suddenly went silent. Especially given that both Pam Bondi and then DHS Secretary Kristi Noem seemed gleeful about their abuse of power to censor people online:

In February of this year, Kassandra Rosado (who ran a Chicago-focused ICE tracking group on Facebook) and Mark Hodges (who created the Eyes Up app for archiving videos of ICE enforcement actions) sued the government, represented by FIRE. In April, the judge found that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in showing that Bondi violated the First Amendment in demanding such takedowns, and granted a preliminary injunction. In the ruling, Judge Jorge L. Alonso pointed out that, unlike in the Murthy case, here there was direct evidence that the companies only made their decisions because Pam Bondi threatened them:

First, Facebook had previously reviewed the Chicagoland group, and Apple had previously reviewed Eyes Up. In both cases, Facebook and Apple had determined that the content met their requirements. Second, Facebook and Apple changed their positions and removed the content immediately after Defendants contacted them about it. And third, Defendants made public statements taking credit for the fact that Facebook and Apple had removed the content.

[….]

Bondi and Noem also intimated that Facebook and Apple may be subject to prosecution for failing to comply with Bondi and Noem’s demands. For example, after stating that we “had Apple and Google take down the ICEBlock apps,” Bondi further stated: “We’re not going to stop at just arresting the violent criminals we can see in the streets.” … And in the same social media post where Noem wrote that “[p]latforms like Facebook must be PROACTIVE in stopping the doxxing of our [ICE] law enforcement,” she added: “We will prosecute those who dox our agents to the fullest extent of the law.” … Although these statements may not be direct threats to prosecute Facebook and Apple, they are intimations of a threat. And thinly veiled threats such as these constitute sufficient evidence on which Plaintiffs are likely to succeed on their claim.

On Thursday it became clear that the Trump DOJ was giving up. The two sides filed a joint motion to convert the preliminary injunction into a permanent injunction, which Judge Alonso quickly granted on Friday. In short, the government gave up even trying to justify its actions regarding the Eyes Up app and the Chicagoland ICE Sightings group. There’s no formal admission of wrongdoing here, but there doesn’t need to be. Rather than defend the very conduct Bondi and Noem had publicly bragged about, the DOJ agreed to be permanently barred from doing it again, and to send written notice of that to its own officials, Meta, and Apple within a week. Agencies that think they did nothing wrong don’t usually agree to letting an injunction stay in place, and to send a letter to companies notifying them of such a result.

The DOJ clearly knew it was going to lose badly, and agreed to the permanent injunction to get the case over with.

Of course, the injunction only applies to that one app and that one Facebook group, meaning that the DOJ could still try to suppress speech of other apps and other groups, but that would be just as unconstitutional, and Judge Alonso’s preliminary injunction ruling lays out exactly why. That said, there’s still a separate lawsuit, filed by EFF on behalf of the ICEBlock app under similar circumstances, where we’re still waiting for the judge to rule.

Federal Judge Permanently Kicks DOJ Lawyer To The Curb For Lying To The Court [Techdirt]

My immediate apologies for the steady stream of acronyms immediately following this apology. But there’s no better way for this to be said than by co-opting the vernacular of mooks who love these acronyms right up until they’re applied to them.

What’s happening here is perhaps the most logical conclusion to everything the Trump DOJ has been doing since Trump took over the DOJ (for a second time!) following the 2024 elections. The MAGA boys were all about the FAFO as the administration flooded the zone with broken Overton windows and never ending attacks on the principles that actually make America great.

FAFO! these rubes gloated as masked kidnapping squads disappeared people into foreign torture prisons. FAFO! they gloated as the military started sinking boats and killing presumptively innocent people in international waters. FAFO! they blood-lustily hollered as immigration officers murdered American citizens and the Trump administration bombed Iran into…um… well, something pretty far from “submission (and the United States into insolvency).

FO is happening. It has been delayed but it’s as inevitable as a Thin Blue Line decal on a rolling coal truck. The DOJ has been in a constant state of Fuck Around with Trump in charge, abandoning any legitimate crime-fighting efforts to engage in vindictive prosecutions of Trump’s political does, devoted limited resources to Trump’s illegal deportation efforts, and then spend even more resources defending these illegal actions in court.

The courts have long recognized the “fucking around.” The zone is now constantly being flooded by the consequences of these actions by the administration. Tens of thousands of decisions have gone against the administration in immigration cases. The DOJ has been drained of personnel, forcing the few that remain to scuttle their own careers in hopes of… I don’t know… becoming part of Trump’s perennially unpaid legal reps following his exit from office.

How bad are things for DOJ lawyers? Maybe just ask AUSA Thomas Price, who has been just been evicted entirely by a federal judge in New York for, well… let’s not sugarcoat it… lying to the court.

On Monday, a federal district court judge barred a Department of Justice attorney from ever appearing again in a particular case, and promised to review whether two other Department attorneys would suffer a similar fate. In the case, Benitez v. Department of Homeland Security, the plaintiffs allege that federal immigration officers operating in New York have engaged in a practice of arresting people on the basis of their ethnicity and without obtaining required warrants. 

In a hearing on Monday before issuing the sanction, U.S. District Judge Sanket J. Bulsara of the Eastern District of New York said the Justice Department’s letter to the court on Nov. 4, 2026 grossly misrepresented the scope of an injunction in another case. Judge Bulsara said Assistant U.S. Attorney Thomas Price’s signed letter was done in “bad faith, a deliberate attempt to mislead the Court, perpetuate a fraud on the tribunal, and violate[s] obligations under Rule 11.”

That’s right, Judge Bulsar just called a Trump AUSA a bad faith liar who attempted to engage in fraud on the court. Those are extremely serious charges. The underlying case deals with the government’s ongoing refusal to stop engaging in stops and detentions that appears to based solely on the perceived racial makeup of those being stopped and detained. While Justice Kavanaugh did kind of say these sort of stops were probably just okay enough to avoid further discussion by this fully compromised version of the Supreme Court, lower courts aren’t nearly as willing to just paper over blatant racism with a few shaky analogies and a deliberate refusal to engage with the facts of the case.

Existing court orders forbade DHS components from performing these sorts of stops. The DHS simply pretended these orders didn’t exist. The DOJ stepped in to defend the DHS, only to find its actions couldn’t actually be defended. The letter [PDF] that resulted in AUSA Price being ejected from the court for the entirety of this litigation deliberately misrepresented the previous orders by the court. Unwisely, these misrepresentations were made in the same federal court jurisdiction that had previously barred the actions the DOJ lawyer now claimed were perfectly legal actions supported by court precedent.

Most specifically (and egregiously), the government (through AUSA Price) pretended an injunction forbidding the entirety of the federal government from engaging in racially biased stops only applied to the single complainant in a one of dozens of similar cases brought against the government in New York.

The injunction granted by Judge Gary Brown in May covered the entire district. The government refused to comply with it. And when asked why, the only explanation given was that it believed (conveniently) that it only applied to officers seeking to stop, detain, or arrest the plaintiff in the cited case, Sanchez Alfaro.

The judge expressed his disbelief and disgust in a brief conference with the DOJ’s lawyers:

“When I issued the order that I issued in this case, I actually did it fully expecting I was giving a gift horse to the respondents. Because it was my expectation and understanding that there were portions of the relief that the plaintiffs in this case were seeking had been moot because of the existence of an injunction that was already put in place. … so what I got back here was astounding. I was flabbergasted by the response.”

While multiple lawyers’ names appear in the letter, it’s AUSA Thomas Price’s signature on the bottom line. Consequently, Price is the first against the wall. The order issued by the court (via docket entry) makes it clear Price is persona non grata in perpetuity when it comes to this case. But it also makes it clear the ice that the rest of the DOJ’s lawyers are standing on is pretty fucking thin:

The Court orders and notes the following: 1. AUSA Price is barred from continuing appearances in this case and must file a notice of withdrawal no later than November 13, 2026. 2. Every future filing in this docket must be signed by Richard Hayes, Chief of the Civil Division of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of New York, or someone at his supervisory level or higher. Submissions signed by other AUSAs will be rejected. 3. Mr. Hayes, or someone at his supervisory level or higher, must appear at every future hearing held by either the undersigned or Judge Wicks in this case. 4. Pursuant to Rule 11(c)(3), the U.S. Attorney’s Office is directed to show cause why Rule 11 sanctions should not be imposed or imposed pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1927 or the Court’s inherent power, based upon the concerns and preliminary findings made by the Court articulated on the record, by November 16, 2026. 5. The Court has issued a warning about the consequence should the Court discover any future misrepresentation or false statement (either by counsel or any witness or declarant): after an opportunity to be heard, should preliminary findings be confirmed, the Court will enter a default judgment in this case in favor of Plaintiffs, with the only issue for resolution to be remedies to be imposed. 

Without a doubt, some idiots will claim these are the actions of an “activist judge” because no judge has ever done the same thing to DOJ lawyers prior to this point in history. Some of those idiots will undoubtedly hold federal cabinet positions. But the reason this sort of thing hasn’t happened before isn’t because there’s a sudden groundswell of activism by federal judges. It’s because the DOJ has never dared to behave this way prior to this point in history. And it’s solely because the DOJ has become little more than the personification of Trump’s worst impulses that it’s being routinely run out of court by the people who actually run the courts. And, as everyone has ever gloated ever, if you don’t like the “finding out,” maybe knock off all the “fucking around.”

Daily Deal: Dodad Dept. Magi Print Pro + 5 Paper Rolls And 5 Sticker Rolls [Techdirt]

The Dodad Dept. Magi Print Pro turns spoken ideas into something you can hold, color, stick, and create with. This compact thermal printer combines voice interaction, image creation, and ink-free printing in a playful design made for creative projects, family activities, and hands-on learning. Get the printer, 5 paper rolls, and 5 sticker rolls on sale for $65.

Note: The Techdirt Deals Store is powered and curated by StackSocial. A portion of all sales from Techdirt Deals helps support Techdirt. The products featured do not reflect endorsements by our editorial team.

03:00 AM

Alex Karp Took The Mask Off For Fascism. Now He’s Pretending It Never Came Off. [Techdirt]

Early in the Trump II administration, after pointing out that the biggest issue in tech policy was no longer tech policy, but democracy, I wrote a piece called “Fascism for First Time Founders,” as a warning shot for tech founders and CEOs who were quick to embrace Trumpism as a permanent new world order. Many did so primarily in the belief that having friends in the White House might wipe away some annoying red tape that the Democrats were insisting on regarding little things like the environment and consumer protection. Given that most of Silicon Valley isn’t actually down with fascism, it seemed like the crew of Thiel-pilled founders who felt otherwise might want to think beyond the immediate environment, regarding how it would look in the long term.

But, then again, the nature of being Thiel-pilled is that you don’t think about long-term strategy; you just keep seeking short-term opportunities to gain an advantage and take it at any cost, assuming you can keep grabbing those advantages over and over and over again.

Anyway, one of those Thiel-pilled CEOs is Palantir’s Alex Karp, who spent years in the past cosplaying as a half-hearted anti-war progressive, which was always suspect for the founder/CEO of a company whose entire mission was about empowering the state to surveil everyone. Karp, who tends to show up at conferences and on TV news shows as an erratic, confused person who is quite sure he’s the smartest person in the world, spent 2025 and 2026 making sure no one would ever again associate him with the progressive values he never really held.

He went full on MAGA, realizing that it would be a huge boon to his own bottom line.

A federal contractor profile for Palantir Usg features a line graph showing obligations increasing from FY21 to $1.3 billion in FY26, accompanied by summary metrics for contract awards and growth.

And, as he’s known to do, Karp went at it with gusto. He embraced the grifting scam that was DOGE, announced Palantir was “completely anti-woke” while supporting the indiscriminate extrajudicial murder of people in boats, and supported Trump’s illegal war in Iran (while claiming to be against such wars). He also seemed pretty pleased that his technology was being used to kill people. Very “progressive.” Oh, and who can forget that time, just months ago, when he dunked on “female voters, who mostly vote Democrat,” claiming that in the new manly age of AI, “male, working class voters” would have way more power. And also the bit where he called Democrats beholden to a “woke pagan ideology.” This is not someone who believes in actual democracy.

Indeed, it became clear that Karp really, really enjoyed being on the side of fascism. He seemed to revel in it. Earlier this year, Palantir released a manifesto summarizing Karp’s book, The Technological Republic, and it reads like the work of a true believer in a MAGA-techno-futurist fascist future. We called it out as such at the time — and warned it was unlikely to end well, given the public backlash and clear hatred for Trumpian fascistic incompetence.

It talks about using Silicon Valley smarts “in the defense of the nation.” It mocks weak petty tech like smartphone apps and free email in favor of “A.I. weapons” and “hard power… built on software.” For no clear reason it attacks US post-WWII foreign policy, explicitly saying “the postwar neutering of Germany and Japan must be undone.” It also embraces surveillance tech and whines about the exposure of “the private lives of public figures” (hmm…)

And it closes on a truly fascistic note:

Some cultures have produced vital advances; others remain dysfunctional and regressive. All cultures are now equal. Criticism and value judgments are forbidden. Yet this new dogma glosses over the fact that certain cultures and indeed subcultures . . . have produced wonders. Others have proven middling, and worse, regressive and harmful.

We must resist the shallow temptation of a vacant and hollow pluralism. We, in America and more broadly the West, have for the past half century resisted defining national cultures in the name of inclusivity. But inclusion into what?

It is the silly rantings of a foolish person with little understanding of history, culture, or anything one learns in a basic liberal arts education.

But, after the recent midterms, Karp is suddenly trying to pretend that he’s always been “progressive” and is pulling a Steve Buscemi “how do you do, my fellow libs” act as he makes the media rounds.

“I’ve been a Democrat my whole life. I grew up in a far left environment. I know more about being a progressive than almost anybody on the planet, and I absolutely believe Palantir — all of our products are essentially progressive,” Karp said….

“My giving is equal Democrat, Republican,” Karp said. “I can tell you, without going into things I’m not gonna disclose, I’m very balanced, and everyone in the political arena knows it. And I’ll tell you what, I’m also not the village idiot.”

My “I’m not the village idiot” t-shirt has people asking a lot of questions already answered by my t-shirt. For example, does Alex Karp not know that political giving is public? As Catherine Rampell showed using public FEC records, in the last two years Karp has given nearly $2 million to Republicans and less than $100k to Democrats:

That doesn’t seem that equal. Now, perhaps he’s quietly funneling millions to Democrats through 501(c)(4) dark money groups that don’t have to disclose donors. Or maybe he’s talking about pre-2024 (he did donate to Biden and Harris back in 2023). But at least from the public info available, there’s little to support the larger claim, and plenty to support the idea that he went all in for MAGA. Without any evidence other than “I say so” it’s tough to take his claims of equal support seriously.

Now, you can argue that Karp has no actual principles beyond what is best for his bottom line, and that he’ll switch positions overnight like a weather-vane, based on which way the wind is blowing. And, perhaps there’s some truth to that (and it’s also why he just hired former Democratic Senator Jon Tester as a lobbyist). But we should never forget that he bought into the idea of a 1000-year Nerd Reich, and publicly embraced MAGA fascism and cruelty, while helping power the tools and systems still being used today to disappear your neighbors — and Karp bragged about it, saying he didn’t understand why anyone found it controversial that Palantir “powers” ICE.

In my Fascism for First Time Founders piece, I pointed out that those who embrace fascist ideologues for expediency in their quest for commercial success usually find out it doesn’t end well. I also pointed out that it almost always burns trust with, and support from, other parts of the infrastructure stack that turn out to matter quite a bit. Karp’s sudden rediscovery of his supposed lifelong progressivism is a weak and cynical attempt to pretend he never embraced fascism, and to avoid taking responsibility for both his actions and his statements.

We shouldn’t let him get away with it. If he wants to admit that he was mistaken, he should say that and detail the actions he’s taken in support of dangerous authoritarianism, along with an explanation of how he’s going to fix all the damage he’s done. But don’t let him sit there and pretend he was never one of the leading captains in the MAGA-tech-industrial complex.

One Member Can Speak Up. A Branch Can Change a Workplace [General Union]

The Constitution protects your right to organize. But, of course, a union doesn’t magically appear in your workplace. Someone has to build it.

More often than not, it starts with something very simple: talking to a coworker. Maybe you’ve been frustrated about a scheduling problem for months and assumed it was just affecting you. Then you mention it to someone else and discover they’re frustrated too. Then another coworker says the same thing. The same confusing rule. The same scheduling problem. The same unpaid work. The same worry about whether your contract will be renewed.

Suddenly, your problem isn’t just your problem anymore. That’s where organizing starts. General Union wants workers to know how to have those conversations and build their union within their own workplaces. That’s why we offer Individual Organizing Training.

You don’t need to become an expert organizer. The training covers practical things: how to start conversations with coworkers, how to listen and find out what they’re concerned about, how to explain what the union can actually do, and how workers’ rights can be used when workplace problems arise.

And organizing doesn’t mean walking around trying to convince every person you meet to join the union. Talk to people. Listen. Find out what matters to them. The problem that’s bothering you the most might also be the biggest issue for everyone else. On the other hand, it might not be. A coworker may be dealing with something you knew nothing about, or several people may raise another issue that needs attention first.

Building a union presence means making room for those voices too. It’s not just about getting coworkers behind your issue. It’s about listening to their ideas, understanding their concerns, and deciding together what should be targeted.

As more coworkers get involved, something starts to change. People share their frustrations, but more importantly, they start sharing information. They hear different points of view. They support each other. And when it’s time to take an issue to the company, there are more workers standing behind it. That’s how one or two members in a workplace can eventually bring enough people together to form a branch in our greater union.

And once you’ve built that branch, it doesn’t disappear just because the first problem gets resolved. It’s still there for the next workplace issue, the next negotiation, and the next coworker who walks through the door and discovers they need some help.

One member can speak up. A union can change a workplace.

You don’t need to know every labour law. You don’t need the perfect argument. You need to be willing to talk to your coworkers, listen to what matters to them, and work out together what you want to change.

Interested in learning how to put your rights into action? Join our Individual Organizing Training

More Than a Thank You: Workers Have Constitutional Rights
Solidarity: When Someone Else’s Fight Becomes Ours

Kanji of the Day: 補 [Kanji of the Day]

補

✍12

小6

supplement, supply, make good, offset, compensate, assistant, learner

ホ

おぎな.う

候補   (こうほ)   —   candidate
立候補   (りっこうほ)   —   candidacy
候補者   (こうほしゃ)   —   candidate
補助   (ほじょ)   —   assistance
補償   (ほしょう)   —   compensation
補助金   (ほじょきん)   —   subsidy
補正予算   (ほせいよさん)   —   revised budget
補選   (ほせん)   —   bye-election
立候補者   (りっこうほしゃ)   —   candidate (for an election)
補充   (ほじゅう)   —   replenishment

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Kanji of the Day: 醜 [Kanji of the Day]

醜

✍17

中学

ugly, unclean, shame, bad looking

シュウ

みにく.い しこ

醜い   (みにくい)   —   ugly
醜悪   (しゅうあく)   —   ugly
醜態   (しゅうたい)   —   disgraceful behavior
美醜   (びしゅう)   —   beauty or ugliness
醜聞   (しゅうぶん)   —   scandal
醜女   (しこめ)   —   homely woman
醜男   (しこお)   —   ugly man
醜名   (しこな)   —   wrestler's stage name
醜貌   (しゅうぼう)   —   hideous face
老醜   (ろうしゅう)   —   ugliness of old age

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

02:00 AM

Reporters Without Borders Calls For Brendan Carr’s Impeachment [Techdirt]

His endless illegal actions may not not rise to the level of indiscriminate boater murders and the illegal mass murder of children, but Brendan Carr’s impeachment should very much be a priority. That’s the position of Reporters Without Borders (RWB), which last week called for Democrats — in the wake of their landslide midterm victories — to impeach FCC boss Brendan Carr in the new year.

It’s their first ever such call in the history of the organization:

“Carr’s tenure as FCC Chair has been defined by his campaign to intimidate and punish media organizations disfavored by the president. He has launched baseless investigations into news organizations, seized on vaguely written regulations to punish news outlets for speech deemed anti-Trump, threatened the broadcast licenses of TV and radio networks based on their editorial lines, gutted rules against media ownership consolidation, put his thumb on the scales of massive media mergers to benefit Trump allies, and improperly supported midterm campaigns. His consistent abuse of his office demands urgent action from Congress.”

Carr’s effort to roll back America’s already shaky media consolidation limits is a very clear, illegal act that undermines the will of Congress. As is stuff like Carr’s illegal efforts to dismantle the FCC’s E-Rate program, which provides affordable internet access to rural schools, libraries, and communities.

And who can forget Carr’s illegal, unconstitutional assault on ABC for the “crime” of platforming journalism and comedians that dared make fun of the increasingly unpopular president. In that instance, ABC and Disney have provided evidence that Carr covertly worked with Trump-friendly TV broadcasters to pretend ABC broke the law — simply because the network aired an interview with Texas Senator elect James Talarico (particularly fertile ground for oversight subpoenas in the new year).

There are also numerous instances where Carr very clearly violated the Hatch Act, most recently when he he illegally leveraged his authority during a political rally for Alaska Republican Senate candidate Dan Sullivan. From the RWB statement:

“The American people have decisively rejected the Trump administration’s trampling of the Constitution. Few individuals have been more instrumental to the White House’s campaign to weaken the First Amendment than Brendan Carr. The incoming Congress now faces a defining test of its commitment to the Constitution and the freedoms it guarantees. Press freedom cannot be defended through words alone. RSF does not take the question of impeachment lightly. In fact, our organization has never before called for the removal of a US official. But the severity and persistence of Carr’s misconduct demand an extraordinary response. Congress has a constitutional responsibility to hold him accountable. Restoring the FCC’s independence must be central to that effort.“

There’s endless other stuff that tends to be obscured in the media by Carr’s ham-fisted attacks on free speech, whether it’s the way he’s made life easier on robocallers (while pretending to be tough on robocallers) and shitty prison telecom monopolies, stripped away every last shred of (already flimsy) U.S. oversight of our lumbering, unpopular broadband monopolies, rubber stamped endlessly harmful mergers, or turned a blind eye to the foreign-influence concerns of the recent Paramount/Warner Bros deal.

On one hand, Carr’s “policies” on telecom and media are utterly indistinguishable from industry. He’s never seen an AT&T or Comcast policy he hasn’t adopted as his own. But Carr’s unique in that he’s also an unapologetic fascist and bigot, and has spent a lot of time during his tenure demanding that telecom and media giants be more racist and sexist if they want their terrible, pointless mergers approved.

Trump’s first term FCC boss, Ajit Pai, was a textbook example of obvious regulatory capture, building an FCC dedicated exclusively to the interests of the biggest media and telecom giants. Carr’s similarly compromised, but his tenure has also been infused not just with dangerous and illegal authoritarian zealotry, but the sort of lame, edgelord meme-slinging you’d expect of a dim highschooler.

There’s simply no shortage of ammunition for investigations and impeachment in the new year. Without it, things will not only get decidedly worse for free speech and consumer protection, but the closest Carr will get to “accountability” is some post-FCC high six-figure gig at a telecom or media industry think tank, where he’ll spend the rest of his days using what’s left of his credibility to further ratfuck competition, consumers, and free speech.

If there’s ever somebody desperately in need of “making an example of” by a reconstituted Congress, it’s Carr.

12:00 AM

Practical empathy [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]

I don’t know what you know. I don’t want what you want, see what you see, believe what you believe.

And that’s okay.

In fact, it’s the only way to be of service, to make a sale or to cause a change to happen.

Of course, we’re more intimate with our ideas, our products and our approach than anyone else. We have a noise in our head, a narrative and a point of view we’ve spent our whole lives creating. It’s naive to believe that anyone else is completely in sync with us.

And so, our only opportunity is to go where they are, not to demand that they come to us.

Practical empathy isn’t primarily an act of kindness (though it’s an essential component of kindness.) Instead, it’s a direct and straightforward path from here to there. It’s how we create action, learning and change.

Marketing is the simple and brave act of going to where someone else might be, and helping them get to where they hope to go.

      

Monday 2026-11-16

11:00 PM

Alleged Operator of Pirate Site Movie2K Could Walk Free as Bitcoin Billionaire [TorrentFreak]

movie2kMore than a decade ago, Movie2K was one of the most visited websites in Germany, beating Twitter and Amazon.

The site shut down in 2013. By then, its operators had allegedly converted much of their advertising income into bitcoin. This was an early bet that eventually turned into billions.

In January 2024, German authorities secured around 50,000 bitcoin, which the alleged operator handed over after his arrest in Spain the year before. The state of Saxony moved these coins to exchanges that summer and eventually sold them for roughly $2.9 billion (€2.64 billion).

That wasn’t the first haul. In 2020, the authorities had already seized 2,700 bitcoin in the same investigation.

The proceeds of the 2024 sale are now held by the state’s judicial cash office. However, according to the court, the money still belongs to the defendant until there’s a final verdict.

Copyright Charges Expired

The criminal trial against the alleged operator and a co-defendant started at the Leipzig Regional Court in February. Prosecutors initially accused the main defendant of commercial copyright infringement in roughly 220,000 cases.

Movie2K.to

Movie2K.to

The court concluded that these copyright offenses were time-barred, so they are no longer part of the case. The main defendant now stands trial for, among other things, commercial money laundering in more than 100 cases. The co-defendant faces dozens of money laundering counts and tax evasion.

The piracy accusations still matter though. According to the indictment, the operators made millions from advertising deals on the site and used that money to buy bitcoin.

From Suspended Sentence to a Dismissal

In April, presiding judge Karsten Nickel already floated a potential deal, MDR and German news site Tarnkappe reported at the time. If the main defendant confessed, he could get a prison sentence of one to one and a half years, suspended on probation.

That’s far below the maximum sentence of 13 years mentioned in earlier media reports.

As part of that deal, the main defendant would also have to hand over the access credentials to another 57,000 bitcoin. The defense lawyers criticized this approach as mainly “economically driven” and left open whether they would agree to such a deal.

Talks between the court, prosecutors and the defense continued behind closed doors, and last week Judge Nickel came back with a new proposal. This time, there is no sentence on the table at all.

New Deal

The case against the main defendant could be dropped if he transfers 40,000 bitcoin to the authorities, a spokesperson for the Dresden General Prosecutor’s office confirmed to dpa. The court itself had not confirmed the proposal when dpa reported on it.

The alleged operator would also have to pay roughly $42 million (€38 million) to compensate possible victims, such as rightsholders. According to Freie Presse, he would also give up his claim to the billions Saxony already raised from the earlier sale.

Meanwhile, the co-defendant would have to hand over 600 bitcoin and $19 million (€17 million). His lawyer said she could imagine accepting that offer, while the main defendant’s lawyers are still weighing their options.

Still a Billionaire?

Even if the main defendant accepts the deal, he could still be left with a sizable fortune. Prosecutors believe he holds roughly 56,000 bitcoin, which means that he could keep about 16,000 coins, worth just over $1 billion (€945 million) at today’s rate.

Leipziger Volkszeitung reports that the judge doubts whether all the bitcoin were obtained illegally, which complicates the case.

At the same time, it’s not yet certain that the alleged operator actually controls all the bitcoin attributed to him, and the deal depends on that, Tarnkappe notes.

For now, nothing is final. The defense and the prosecutors are still reviewing the proposal. The next hearing is scheduled for December 3. If all parties agree, the case could be over before Christmas.

—

The German-language quotes in this article were translated by TorrentFreak.

From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.

07:00 AM

Funniest/Most Insightful Comments Of The Week At Techdirt [Techdirt]

This week, our first place winner on the insightful side is Nimrod with a comment about the tool built by election deniers that claimed perfectly alive voters were dead:

Trump’s insistence that anything that goes against him HAS to involve cheating actually makes perfect sense if you look at the situation from the perspective of a serial liar who also habitually cheats at golf. Since HIS wins are predicated upon his own illegal manipulations, certainly those of others MUST be, as well.

In second place, it’s Stephen T. Stone with a comment about the somewhat surprising fact that Trump hasn’t made the expected attempts to interfere with the midterm results:

Quoting Norm Eisen here: “The reason ‘Trump didn’t steal the elections’ is because we & the pro-voter coalition stopped him EIGHT times over the past 21 months[.]” As I said in a comment on a different article, this is a lot like the Y2K situation: The problem coming and going without any real issues makes us feel like the problem was overblown…and makes us forget that a whole hell of a lot of people put in a hell of a lot of work so that the problem would come and go without any real issues.

You were right to worry. I’ve no doubt that, had Trump and his fascist goons been far more competent, they would’ve found an effective way to fuck with the midterms. The fact that they didn’t speaks to the strength of the institutional guardrails around our elections (including the Supreme Court, for once) and to the work put in by pro-democracy groups to keep those guardrails up. The American people did their part by electing Democrats in such large numbers, with large enough margins and large enough swings, that there isn’t any way for someone to explain those results with “the elections were rigged” without someone else wondering why Republicans would rig elections against themselves in states where they controlled the state-level government.

For editor’s choice on the insightful side, we start out with two more comments on that subject and the fact that the DOJ dropped its illegal voters lawsuit against California. First, it’s That One Guy reminding us that things aren’t over yet:

Never underestimate someone THAT spiteful and deranged

While it’s nice that they to have accepted the results for the moment this is the same person/group that has claimed for six years now that they actually won the 2020 election and instigated an insurrection to try to overturn it in their favor, so personally I’ll be waiting until the new congress is sworn in and at their seats before I believe that Trump and his goons have actually accepted this loss and aren’t trying to find a way to overturn it.

Next, it’s BernardoVerda with a comment about what the withdrawal of the lawsuit means:

Wasn’t the withdrawal of this “illegal voters” lawsuit essentially an admission that the charge was pure fabrication all along – just an exercise in generating smoke and confusion, to help steal seats if they lost?

Over on the funny side, our first place winner is Bob with another comment about supposed illegal voters:

homeopathic election rigging?

The DoJ only found 28 illegal voters in California, out of 23 million, because the election rigging is homeopathic! The multiple dilutions make the rigging ever more powerful.

In second place, it’s an anonymous comment about Starlink:

Starlink is great for improving internet access in remote, rural areas that lack adequate infrastructure.

You know, like downtown Washington, DC.

Things were a little slow on the funny side this week, so we’ll keep it to just one editor’s choice. It’s a reply from Pixelation to Bob, who accidentally double-posted versions of his winning comment above:

Sure. Clearly you are a Democrat voter, posting twice!

That’s all for this week, folks!

03:00 AM

Solidarity Symposium 2026 – Visa Changes: What Now? [General Union]

Japan’s immigration system is changing, and the proposed reforms could have significant consequences for foreign workers. From stricter residency requirements to changes in visa renewal fees and permanent residency conditions, it is more important than ever to understand what is happening and what these changes mean for foreign workers.

The General Union Solidarity Committee invites you to join us for “Visa Changes: What Now?”, a hybrid symposium on Sunday, November 29, 2026, featuring speakers: Dennis Tesolat, Simon Cole, and Sunai Naoko.

This symposium will examine recent changes to Japan’s immigration laws, the implications for foreign workers, and what unions can do to support and protect their members.

Two Sessions: Understanding the Changes and Their Impact

Part 1:  The Specified Skilled Worker (SSW) Program

The second session will focus on Japan’s Specified Skilled Worker (SSW) program. Sunai Naoko will explain the program and explore its implications for foreign workers, including the challenges and issues that workers and their communities should understand.

Part 2:  Recent Changes to Immigration Law

The first session will look at recent changes to Japan’s immigration laws and the guidelines surrounding them. Dennis Tesolat and Simon Cole will discuss what these developments mean for foreign residents and workers, what people should be aware of, and how unions can respond to protect workers’ rights.

The two sessions will be followed by a Q&A session, where participants will have the opportunity to ask questions to the speakers.

Meet the Speakers

Sunai Naoko

Naoko Sunai is a sociologist and lecturer at Gifu University whose research focuses on Vietnamese migrant workers, labour exploitation, and gender issues. She holds a doctorate from Université Laval and is also an active member of a community union, bringing both academic expertise and practical insight into the challenges facing migrant workers in Japan.

Dennis Tesolat

Dennis is the current vice chair of the union and a long time staffer involved in the daily struggles of immigrant workers as an organiser and negotiator. He is Italian-Canadian and came to Japan in 1994. He has experienced immigration issues both as the child of immigrants and now–in Japan–as an immigrant himself.

Simon Cole

Simon Cole is a founding and executive member of the General Union and currently convenes the union’s Solidarity Committee. A British national and permanent resident of Japan, he has extensive experience in union organising and supporting migrant workers in Japan. 

Event Details

Visa Changes: What Now?

  • Date: Sunday, November 29, 2026
  • Time: 14:00–16:30
  • Format: Hybrid (in person and Zoom)
  • In-person venue: General Union Office, Osaka
  • Language: English, with Japanese translation provided

In-person attendance at the General Union office is limited to General Union members and their family members. Everyone else is welcome to participate online via Zoom.

Register Now!

Immigration policy affects all of us. Understanding the changes, sharing information, and organising collectively are essential to protecting the rights and security of all workers in Japan.

REGISTER FOR THE SYMPOSIUM HERE

Revisit Our December 2025 Immigration Seminar

Want to catch up on the proposed immigration changes before attending? In December 2025, we held a seminar examining the government’s proposed reforms to Japan’s immigration system and their potential impact on foreign residents.

Watch the December 2025 seminar on YouTube:

Kanji of the Day: 覚 [Kanji of the Day]

覚

✍12

小4

memorize, learn, remember, awake, sober up

カク

おぼ.える さ.ます さ.める さと.る

覚え   (おぼえ)   —   memory
感覚   (かんかく)   —   sense
覚悟   (かくご)   —   readiness
自覚   (じかく)   —   self-consciousness
発覚   (はっかく)   —   detection (of a plot, fraud, etc.)
覚える   (おぼえる)   —   to memorize
視覚障害者   (しかくしょうがいしゃ)   —   visually impaired person
聴覚   (ちょうかく)   —   the sense of hearing
目覚め   (めざめ)   —   waking
視覚   (しかく)   —   sense of sight

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Kanji of the Day: 諾 [Kanji of the Day]

諾

✍15

中学

consent, assent, agreement

ダク

承諾   (しょうだく)   —   consent
受諾   (じゅだく)   —   acceptance
快諾   (かいだく)   —   ready consent
許諾   (きょだく)   —   consent
応諾   (おうだく)   —   consent
諾否   (だくひ)   —   consent or refusal
承諾書   (しょうだくしょ)   —   letter of acceptance
内諾   (ないだく)   —   informal consent
指名受諾演説   (しめいじゅだくえんぜつ)   —   acceptance speech
許諾契約   (きょだくけいやく)   —   license agreement

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

02:00 AM

Reddit’s Copyright Removals Rise as Repeat Infringer Bans Drop [TorrentFreak]

redditEvery day, more than 130 million users visit Reddit, sharing millions of posts and comments. Some of these include or link to copyright-infringing content.

When rightsholders spot these, they can send a DMCA takedown notice to Reddit, which then decides whether to remove it or not. The company reports this takedown activity in its biannual transparency report, of which the latest version came out last week.

More Removals, Fewer Takedown Notices

The latest transparency report covers the first half of 2026. During this period, Reddit received 66,221 copyright takedown notices, 4% fewer than in the second half of last year.

While there were (marginally) fewer notices, they targeted more posts, comments, and other content. In the first half of the year, rightsholders identified 465,803 pieces of content, an increase of 9% compared to the previous reporting period.

Reddit removed 258,855 of these items. That’s 55% of all reported content, up from 51% in the second half of 2025.

Reddit’s H1 2026 takedown overview

Reddit's H1 2026 takedown overview

Looking at the longer trend, we see that the number of notices and flagged posts and comments remains on a lower level than in 2022 and 2023. This, despite the fact that Reddit’s active users continued to grow.

Copyright takedown notices trend

Copyright takedown notices trend

Copyright-Related Bans Plunge

Although Reddit removed more content than it did last year, it banned fewer repeat infringers. In the first half of 2026, Reddit banned 1,266 user accounts for repeat copyright violations, which is a 21% drop compared to the six months before.

This might in part be reversion to the mean as last year the number of user bans had nearly doubled.

The decline is even steeper for communities. Reddit banned 118 subreddits for repeat copyright violations, down 79% from 563 in the second half of 2025. In the first half of 2025, that number was still 709.

Reddit doesn’t explain this recent drop. However, zooming out reveals that these numbers are also far below 2022 levels. In the first half of that year alone, Reddit banned 3,859 user accounts and 1,543 subreddits for repeat infringement.

Counter-Notices and Fair Use

Meanwhile, Redditors are also pushing back against takedown notices more often. In the first half of this year, Reddit received 688 counter-notices, which is 60% more than in the previous period. Of these, 221 were valid, resulting in 599 pieces of content being restored. That’s a big jump compared to the second half of 2025, when just 34 of 430 counter-notices were valid.

Reddit also rejected 20,143 takedown notices outright, 30% of the total, leaving 109,706 pieces of content in place. The company explains that takedown notices can be invalid for various reasons, including when the targeted content makes fair use of a copyrighted work.

Rejected notices

reddit rejected

The report highlights a few notable requests. A religious organization, for example, tried to remove two posts that reproduced the text of an internal announcement, together with extensive commentary and criticism.

“We declined to remove the posts because they make fair use of the original work,” Reddit writes.

Another notice came from an individual in Australia, who objected to a Reddit user’s photo of their business card. The card had allegedly been handed to the sender’s partner in a public park.

“Because the business card (stating: “Gentleman of Leisure”) did not contain personally identifiable information or any creative elements, we declined to remove the content,” Reddit notes.

The next transparency report will be the first report to cover a full six months after the Supreme Court’s Cox ruling, which cleared the Internet provider of liability for not disconnecting repeat infringers.

Whether this will have an impact on the repeat infringer bans has yet to be seen.

From: TF, for the latest news on copyright battles, piracy and more.

Sunday 2026-11-15

11:00 PM

Confusion about causation [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]

It’s not difficult to develop an incorrect theory. Ice cream and spaghetti have more letters than tofu and celery, so therefore, foods with long names are more fattening than those with short ones.

If you start moving forward with this theory, you’ll soon find outliers. Sugar only has five letters, and watercress has ten. If we want to stick with our theory, we’ll have to come up with more and more complex reasons why we ignore some of the data and embrace the rest.

Of course, this is absurd.

And yet we do it all the time. Ornate explanations about the stock market, SEO or politics. Charts and graphs where we spend most of our time fitting a plot to a few dots, or amplifying the obscure to justify the theory.

A simple theory that matches the data is much more likely to accurately explain causation. It might not be a comfortable theory, or one that matches our trajectory, but it’s a better theory.

It turns out that the number of letters is completely irrelevant to how fattening a food is. I’m sorry you spent all this time on research, but you’re on the wrong path.

If you want to know why your marketing, your investments or your arguments are floundering, it might pay to reconsider the theory, not look for more data to justify the current one.

      

10:00 AM

Just for Skeets and Giggles (11.14.26) [The Status Kuo]

It’s the week after the week that changed everything, and we’re still reveling in the afterglow! SNL’s cold open drew cheers around the country:

Image.heic

Gonna need some aloe for this burn.

Image.heic

There were signs of a happier America, from Michigan…

IMG_4395.jpeg

… to Texas!

Image.heic

Speaking of Texas, off its blue coast:

Image.heic

One of my favorites from the week:

Image.heic

Seen in our nation’s capital:

IMG_4409.jpeg

For Star Trek fans, who recently lost two beloved icons, this stirred the heart.

Image.heic

With votes still being counted in close races, we got some sweet desserts after the big election meal. In Colorado, Lauren Boebert, um, went down.

Image.heic

Okay, one more off-color joke about this…

Image.heic

We waited all week on the results from a certain Southern state.

Image.heic

The count was slow and painstaking.

Image.heic

Then some incredible, history-making news!

Image.heic

The joy was everything, everywhere, all at once.

IMG_4569.jpeg

A strange new feeling spread across a long-oppressed people.

There was this pledge that Steve seems… happy to fulfill?

Image.heic

“Let my people go!”

IMG_2301.heic

The Alaska Senate race was also on many minds. They’re just, well, different up north.

Image.heic

VoteHub projected Peltola as the winner, and when I shared that on Facebook everyone suddenly became statistics and math experts, saying “Well, actually…” as if they had run a regression analysis on ranked-choice voting.

Hey, everyone, she’s going to win! The math is clear from the actual math people!

In D.C., incoming Democrats took glorious selfies.

Image.heic

Republicans are running scared and clutching their pearls over hearings to expose all their corruption and criminality.

IMG_4369.jpeg

It took a week, but Donald Trump finally tried to assert election fraud. And it fizzled like Lara Trump’s singing career.

Image.heic

There wasn’t election fraud, but there was a concerted effort by the other side to suppress the vote.

Image.heic

Trump still needs a press secretary, so on the sixth anniversary of the Four Seasons Total Landscaping debacle, there was the matter of the Dana Whites.

IMG_4347.jpeg

Two Dana Whites? Like two Dan Sullivans?

Image.heic

I don’t know why this deadpan is so funny to me. It just is.

The red American carnage is so bad that the end of MAGA is on people’s lips—and splashed across the internet.

IMG_4390.jpeg

Trump gave a post-election interview to 60 Minutes, and hoo boy. Jon Stewart had some thoughts.

Image.heic

And there was this part:

Image.heic

Trump’s strange noises have a possible culprit, according to the inimitable Josh Johnson.

IMG_4342.jpeg

Dan Docimo is fast becoming one of my favorite political commentators. I hadn’t thought about this question quite this way, but he’s right!

Image.heic

Over in Congress, Hegseth had a near miss when Rep. Thomas Massie took his shot.

Image.heic

The tech world got rocked this week.

Image.heic

The Daily Show explained how Trump’s in this Nvidia mess, too.

Image.heic

The commentary was, as the kids say these days, fire.

Image.heic

And this needed to be said.

Image.heic

So many clever, funny people out there.

Image.heic

The irony of AI creating this stuff so quickly now…

Image.heic

No respect!

Image.heic

A fair observation by Ben Collins:

Image.heic

How would that have gone, though?

Image.heic

His defenders (those with large Nvidia holdings?) leapt to his aid.

Image.heic

But then reports surfaced of two more affairs, both with Nvidia employees.

Image.heic

By Thursday, Jensen Huang had resigned as Nvidia’s CEO, sending its stock tumbling.

Image.heic

But Marco is ready if Donald isn’t!

Image.heic

Simu Liu said, “Think of the possibilities though.”

Image.png

The fallout goes beyond Huang. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick is in very hot water for failing to blacklist a Singapore-based company suspected of funneling Nvidia’s advanced AI chips to China.

And for unknown reasons, Trump’s National Economic Council director, Kevin Hassett, is reportedly headed for the exit, though he denies it.

IMG_4452.jpeg

Of course, many dark terrors remain. People are still horrified by Stephen Miller’s elevation to White House chief of staff.

900479099_10244255377142251_662156167799493599_n.jpeg

Remember to plan ahead for his capture!

2ceaa6b6-13a4-4488-b3c7-de1375f8b431.jpg.jpeg

Pete Hegseth’s group showed disrespect at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier and got yelled at by the sentinel on duty.

Image.heic

Speaking of incompetent former Fox hosts, on Friday afternoon, the FAA under Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy grounded every departing flight in the country for more than four hours. And a lot of people learned the news from (checks notes) Flavor Flav.

The nation was in jeopardy.

Image.heic

It was the second major systems fail of the week.

Image.heic

We’d better get used to the whole internet flickering.

Image.heic

Will it be AI or some other cause?

Image.heic

Oh, and about that Microsoft outage…

Image.heic

This summed up the national mood on Friday.

Travelers awaited an explanation.

Image.heic

Planes couldn’t take off, like, at all.

Image.heic

Tens of thousands of passengers were stranded.

The outrage dragged on for hours, with passengers stuck overnight as the chaos spread.

Image.heic

The FAA is apparently rolling out new AI systems on top of legacy infrastructure, which has many worried.

46d41c65-31fe-4d68-97d5-dec5ed3098f0.jpg.jpeg

Of course, we all know the real reason for the nationwide failure.

Thankfully, I had booked Amtrak back home from D.C. on Friday.

Image.heic

I can’t wait until we destroy what’s left of the GOP in 2028 and take back the White House. But once we do, heed this sage warning about the U.S. electorate from Patton Oswalt:

IMG_4321.jpeg

I’m so grateful for the support that paid subscribers give my work. If you’re currently a free subscriber, ask whether what you read from me six days a week is worth buying me one cup of coffee a month. If it is, please hit the button below and become one of my personal heroes!

Subscribe now

On to the doggies! She really makes her human work for it, huh?

Image.heic

A ball is truly irresistible to so many of our best friends.

Image.heic

I haven’t quite seen this reaction to scritches before, but I love it.

Image.heic

This is actually me with my children.

Image.heic

A corgi race ended with a chase around the field. As someone who has seen his own corgi get loose, I feel for the handlers.

IMG_4407.jpeg

I would love for a professional photographer to capture Windsor in this way.

Image.heic

Or my cat Shade in this manner.

IMG_4357.jpeg

This cat really is an a-hole!

Image.heic

This story of a cat in a zoo made me smile.

Image.heic

I follow this music-loving cockatoo named Jackson, and his reels always crack me up.

Image.heic

Everyone needs a fly-or-die.

Image.heic

The secret to humor is the element of surprise.

IMG_4484.jpeg

I did not expect this to go this way, but OMG lololol

Image.heic

Not everything is scatological with kids!

Image.heic

You Can See Everything is a hit in theaters. But have you seen this version? (You may get a “non sexual nudity” warning that you have to click “show” on lol)

Image.heic

Here’s something bright and silly to move us past the darkness. Hum along!

IMG_4396.jpeg

When women say men don’t understand women’s bodies, this is what they mean.

Image.heic

By the end of this, I was shaking my head in disbelief and couldn’t stop smiling.

Image.heic

The British have a highly-developed sense of the absurd. I’m a fan.

Image.heic

Not a word was spoken, and none was needed.

Image.heic

We have some dad-joke battles. She finally got him back!

Image.heic

And she put up a valiant fight.

Image.heic

Happy 56th blue Senate seat! What a week, with two more senate seats going our way!

Have an amaaaaazing weekend, and if you’re happy and you want to share some joy, remember to tip your writer with a supporting subscription!

Jay

Subscribe now

06:00 AM

This Week In Techdirt History: November 8th – 14th [Techdirt]

02:00 AM

Kanji of the Day: 底 [Kanji of the Day]

底

✍8

小4

bottom, sole, depth, bottom price, base, kind, sort

テイ

そこ

徹底   (てってい)   —   thoroughness
徹底的   (てっていてき)   —   thorough
海底   (うなぞこ)   —   bottom of the ocean
底上げ   (そこあげ)   —   raising (the standard)
到底   (とうてい)   —   possibly
根底   (こんてい)   —   root
底力   (そこぢから)   —   hidden reserves of strength
心底   (しんそこ)   —   bottom of one's heart
どん底   (どんぞこ)   —   very bottom
心の底   (こころのそこ)   —   bottom of one's heart

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Kanji of the Day: 爆 [Kanji of the Day]

爆

✍19

中学

bomb, burst open, pop, split

バク

は.ぜる

爆発   (ばくはつ)   —   explosion
原爆   (げんばく)   —   atomic bomb
被爆   (ひばく)   —   being bombed
被爆者   (ひばくしゃ)   —   atomic bomb victim (esp. of Hiroshima and Nagasaki)
爆弾   (ばくだん)   —   bomb
原爆症   (げんばくしょう)   —   atomic-bomb sickness
爆笑   (ばくしょう)   —   roar of laughter (from multiple people)
爆破   (ばくは)   —   destructive blast
空爆   (くうばく)   —   aerial bombing
爆発的   (ばくはつてき)   —   explosive

Generated with kanjioftheday by Douglas Perkins.

Saturday 2026-11-14

09:00 PM

Have your AI call my AI [Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect]

Sharp lawyers have often used the fine print to win an advantage in a contract. It’s called the fine print for a reason–you’re not supposed to read it. But you should.

Now, armed with AI, it’s significantly easier to bury arcane, unfair or unanticipated clauses in agreements, even (and especially) if we don’t expect it.

You shouldn’t sign anything until you’ve had your AI read it. And if it’s important, have your lawyer and her AI read it too.

The next step seems reasonable to me: You and I describe our agreement in plain English and then our mutual AI’s work out a written agreement that actually captures what we’ve agreed on. And for the avoidance of doubt, append each AI’s interpretation to the contract itself.

It shouldn’t be confrontational or adversarial. After all, it’s an agreement.

      

03:00 PM

DLSS 5 Got Faster, Leaner, & More Subtle For ‘Hogwarts Legacy’ [Techdirt]

Earlier this year, NVIDIA released a demo video of it’s new DLSS 5 AI neural rendering technology and it caused an uproar. The complaints about the video were varied. There is a never-AI crowd in the gaming industry that doesn’t seem to understand that DLSS 2 and 3 already made use of machine learning for pixel reconstruction and frame generation. They were late to the party. There are those with environmental concerns that are on much stronger footing. But what it takes to run this technology today versus what it will take in the future can be widely varied as the tech progresses. And then there were the two loudest groups: those that suggested this broke the intent of the original artists and those that claimed all of this was stupid because of the expensive hardware required to run DLSS 5 smoothly at all.

And on those two specific issues, the latest game to get DLSS 5 incorporated into it offers us some answers. The tech has gotten leaner, faster, and Nvidia is working directly with the developer of Hogwarts Legacy to ensure that no artistic intent is infringed upon.

The progression into leaner requirements for the technology are the easiest to tackle.

Remember when Nvidia needed two monstrous RTX 5090 graphics cards to demonstrate DLSS 5 back in March? Now it runs on a single supported GPU.

Nvidia claims a tenfold performance improvement since that original showcase. Its latest neural rendering model runs twice as fast as September’s version while using 20 percent less VRAM at 4K. DLSS 5 supports GeForce RTX 50-series desktop and laptop GPUs, RTX Spark systems, and GeForce Now Ultimate.

This, of course, also has implications on the environmental concerns, as the hardware needed becomes leaner. I know full well that the environmentalists out there won’t be satisfied with this, nor am I sure they should be. But we have to allow for progress in this area and admit when progress has indeed been achieved. I see no reason to think the tech requirements for DLSS 5 won’t continue to get leaner and leaner, especially since Nvidia is expected to bring this to the 40 series cards as well. GPUs are still expensive, so even one 50 series card requires a hefty investment, but the trend is going the right way here. Saying so should be easy.

But when you dig into how Nvidia and the developers behind Hogwarts Legacy are collaborating to make sure the tool can do what the developer wants and not break artistic intent, well, that’s sort of the ballgame on most of the backlash we heard initially.

Nvidia’s official before-and-after comparisons show richer lighting and deeper shadows throughout Hogsmeade. Moss stands out against weathered rooftops, foliage casts more convincing shadows, and the stonework gains an almost tangible depth. Character changes are subtler, without the dramatic facial transformations that kicked off the original uproar — at least in the promotional images.

Avalanche Software worked with Nvidia to dial things back. DLSS 5 lets developers adjust lighting and structural detail independently, choose different neural models for different scenes, and use masking tools to keep the AI from mucking with specific objects or characters. Avalanche says it fine-tuned Hogwarts Legacy’s environments, lighting, and skin details to preserve the game’s original artistic vision.

Good! Because making a game look more realistic doesn’t necessarily make it look better.

Indeed and the artists ought to retain control of their art. What Nvidia is doing here is taking a blanket tool it created and putting control over how the tool is used, and to what extent, directly in the hands of the developers of the game. The control over what the ultimate output of this art resides with the developer, which employs or contracts the artists.

And that’s precisely where it should reside. The tech demo, which was rolled out in a fashion that left it wide open to exactly the type of criticism it received, made it look like Nvidia was planning to stomp all over the Mona Lisa without permission and turn Mona into an Instagram influencer. That’s just not what is actually happening. DLSS 5 is being refined to be what it always should have been: one more tool in the artist’s tool belt.

Perhaps this is a one-off and Nvidia will do some horrible thing next that will revive all of the complaints. Perhaps the majority of those lashing out at this technology don’t care about this sort of progress and are simply going to remain never-AI-ers in gaming. There’s a small chance the tech can’t get even more lean and environmentally friendly.

But progress is progress, no matter how much some don’t like it. And the DLSS 5 of today is simply not the same as the DLSS 5 that was railed against in March.

11:00 AM

Pluralistic: I told you so (13 Nov 2026) [Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow]

->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->-> Top Sources: None -->

Today's links



The Earth from space, wreathed in flames. Protruding from a vast mid-North American impact crater is Microsoft Clippy, shimmering in the heat.

I told you so (permalink)

Here's the one weird trick that made it possible for monopolies to conquer the world: the antitrust bar changed the rules so that it was impossible to prove whether a company had formed an illegal monopoly, and then these rules meant that monopolies were almost never challenged, and what challenges did arise were usually unsuccessful, and even the successful challenges resulted in meaningless "penalties" that left monopolists unscathed.

Every policy has three important dimensions: substance, scope and administrability:

  • "Substance" is what the policy actually says. For example, the basic substance of copyright law is, "You can't display, transmit or reproduce a copyrighted work without permission."

  • "Scope" is when the policy gets applied. When copyright law was formulated, the key activities it regulated all required a bunch of expensive industrial equipment. Every book implied a printing press, every record implied a record-pressing plant, every film implied a film duplication lab. That meant that, by default, pretty much the only people who had to care about what copyright law said were industrial actors – firms that might reasonably be expected to also have access to a lawyer. That matters a lot to administrability.

  • "Administrability" is what it takes to actually administer the policy. Can you detect potential violations, and when you do, how hard is it to figure out whether the rule was actually broken? Again, in the pre-digital era, it was pretty easy to spot copyright violations: pirate books, records and movies are tangible, physical objects, and distributing them requires advertisement, delivery and payment.

After detecting an infringement, copyright enforcers must resolve a further question: whether a display, transmission or copy falls under "fair use." Fair use is a "fact intensive" rule, one that requires a lot of evidence and argument to adjudicate. It's almost impossible to categorically rule in or rule out a specific use as "fair":

https://pluralistic.net/2024/06/27/nuke-first/#ask-questions-never

Despite the complexity and expense of determining fair use, pre-digital copyright was still relatively administrable, because fair use questions themselves were relatively rare. Most fair uses (for example, photocopying part of a book for classroom use) were below the threshold for detection by rightsholders, so these questions almost never found their way into court. The fair use questions that did get to court were big, splashy affairs, like whether it's okay to rewrite a famous pro-slavery novel from the enslaved characters' perspective (it is!):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wind_Done_Gone

There are a lot of legal questions that require nuance, fact-finding and argumentation to resolve, and that's not necessarily a problem. It's fine to apply these complicated, lengthy processes to things that only happen every once in a while. Take probate: most of us will die one or fewer times, so it's not the worst thing in the world that figuring out what happens to our stuff when that happens can involve some legal complexity.

But as media went digital, copyright's scope expanded dramatically. "Making or handling copies of copyrighted work" stopped being an industrial activity that implied a complex business and access to legal expertise. The only thing a digital computer does is make and handle copies, so every time any ordinary person clicks their mouse, dozens of potentially thorny copyright questions arise. What's more, those questions involve the public internet, which raises the number of potential infringements that a rightsholder can detect (and potentially seek legal redress for) from dozens to millions.

Nearly all of these potential infringements fall under fair use, but fair use is a fact-intensive doctrine suited to resolving occasional disputes between large firms. Fair use is monumentally unsuited to resolving questions that arise hundreds of times every day for nearly every person alive, including small children and other people who almost certainly can't get legal advice:

https://locusmag.com/feature/cory-doctorow-a-new-deal-for-copyright/

This is how copyright broke: new technology (digital computers) radically expanded its scope, conscripting everyone into using copyright's framework for everyday activities that had nothing to do with the media industry's supply chain. That framework was developed for industrial actors with access to lawyers, and its most important aspect (fair use) is a fact-intensive doctrine that takes serious work to resolve, but now had to be navigated many times every day by every person. So copyright became unadministrable: you can't apply a fact-intensive doctrine to everyday activities undertaken by everyday people. If you try, you will make criminals of everyone. It would be literally impossible to train enough copyright lawyers to advise every person every time they use a computer to do something that might violate copyright law.

Back to antitrust: when the pro-monopoly partisans of the "law and economy" movement set out to neuter antitrust, they deliberately introduced a set of hurdles that were designed to make it impossible to administer competition law.

First, they introduced an "intent" standard: it was no longer enough for a company to have a monopoly, the company must have intended to secure and maintain that monopoly. If you want to be sure a law doesn't get enforced, this is a fantastic standard to apply. After all, how can anyone know what anyone else intended? Ask any anthropologist and they'll tell you: the only way to find out what someone intends by their actions is to ask them, and even that only works if you can trust them to answer honestly:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thick_description#Clifford_Geertz

If antitrust law can only be enforced by mind-readers and advanced philosophers who have solved the intersubjectivity problem, then antitrust law can't be enforced at all:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersubjective_verifiability

But that wasn't all! Antitrust's enemies insisted on another fact-intensive question: "market definition." They made the (seemingly commonsense) point that if a company is said to have a monopoly, we must first determine which thing the company has monopolized. This sounds like a no-brainer, but it's actually a way to introduce unresolvable, show-stopper arguments into any antitrust enforcement action.

Take Amazon: the company's ecommerce monopoly is obvious to anyone who hasn't been in a coma for the past 15 years. But when Amazon gets investigated for this monopoly, they will insist that they don't participate in the "ecommerce" economy, but rather in "the buying and selling of things in general." Then they point out that people still go to the corner store for a pint of milk, still buy a pack of gum from the kiosk at the train-station, and still buy some hair-gel from the barber after a trim, and therefore Amazon can't possibly have a monopoly.

"Market definition" is a playground for bad-faith semanticians. Luckily for the world's monopolists, the very existence of this legal doctrine has conjured up an army of bad-faith semanticians, most of them with expensive Ivy League economics degrees, who make millions coming up with bizarre market definition arguments that can draw out any legal proceeding for years, often to the point where there is a change in government and the federal prosecutors just walk away from the case.

Taken together, these impossible fact-intensive questions would be enough to bury antitrust, but then came the final blow: frequency. Once capital had won the battle to mire antitrust cases in questions that take years and millions to resolve, they embarked on a frenzy of monopolistic mergers. This meant that the kind of antitrust questions that originally arose every few years were suddenly coming up several times per month. This was the killer combo: making antitrust a plodding ball-ache of thorny philosophical and technical questions, and then rigging the system so that these questions arise in a nonstop flurry guaranteed that antitrust would fail.

That's what happened with Microsoft. The company had a 95% desktop OS market-share when Clinton's trustbusters dragged them into court. Nevertheless, the company played all kinds of "market definition" games that dragged the case out for years. They also insisted that they never intended to form a monopoly, despite smoking-gun memos about "sucking up all the market oxygen":

https://web.archive.org/web/20190717023522/https://www.justice.gov/atr/department-justice-7

This dragged on so long that even after Microsoft lost its case, the appeal carried on until after GW Bush stole the presidency, and then his DoJ walked away from the case, letting Microsoft continue to enjoy (and increase) its monopoly:

https://www.nytimes.com/2001/09/07/business/us-vs-microsoft-overview-us-abandoning-its-effort-break-apart-microsoft-saying.html

What happened next should not come as a surprise to anyone. Microsoft got convicted of deliberately setting out to create a monopoly, and then paid no penalty. After an all-too-brief period of post-traumatic good behavior, Microsoft returned to its monopolistic ways. Along the way, Microsoft sucked up to a succession of presidential administrations, culminating in the company's emergence as a de facto wing of the Trump regime. Microsoft's CEO paid $1m to sit on the inaugural dais, and then directed the company to donate millions to the Epstein Ballroom, and then provided the IT services for ICE's ethnic cleansing pogroms:

https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/us-ice-triples-use-of-microsoft-cloud-in-six-months/#:~:text=ICE%20has%20been,first%20presidential%20term.

Microsoft isn't merely the in-house IT shop for Trump's domestic agenda: they've also weaponized foreign reliance on Microsoft's cloud apps and they punish foreign officials who thwart Trump abroad:

https://www.theregister.com/off-prem/2026/02/18/microsoft-throws-spox-under-the-bus-in-icc-email-flap/

When forced, Microsoft candidly admits that no matter where in the world your Microsoft data is stored, when it comes to foreign firms and governments, the company will give warrantless, secret access to their data to Trump's cronies:

https://www.theregister.com/off-prem/2025/07/25/microsoft-exec-admits-it-cannot-guarantee-data-sovereignty/458553

All of this raises an urgent digital sovereignty question: what if Microsoft (a monopolist that is entirely dependent on Trump's favor to keep it free of existential legal problems) cuts off your country's Office 365 access? This is the question I raised late last year in my CCC talk about the "Post-American Internet":

https://pluralistic.net/2026/01/01/39c3/#the-new-coalition

(Coming soon in expanded form to a bookstore near you:)

https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374623845/thepostamericaninternet/

And now, Microsoft has given the whole world a preview of how this might play out, because their servers have collapsed, shutting the world off from Outlook email, Azure cloud, Copilot, Teams, and other key offerings:

https://www.bbc.com/news/live/cq5y10ge3dp3t

The outage lasted for about two days, and around the world, government agencies and businesses large and small ground to a halt. Without Office 365, Outlook and Teams, many organizations could not even convene a meeting or formulate a plan to deal with the outage.

All of this raises an important question: is Microsoft guilty of negligence, and, if so, what should be done about this? Here's my answer: Yes, Microsoft is presumptively guilty of negligence, and any response to this must include antitrust breakups of the company.

Here's why I think that. Microsoft has demonstrably underinvested in its IT stability. Any IT plan that results in a global, multi-day outage is, by definition, inadequate. Whether the problem could have been solved by buying more servers, or hiring more people, or changing the management of key divisions is immaterial. Every one of these measures – every single measure that could have prevented this – costs money. By not spending that money, Microsoft definitively underinvested in its products.

But Microsoft doesn't lack for funds! Microsoft is a convicted monopolist, and it has the margins to prove it. In 2025-2026, the company pissed away more than $30b in stock buybacks, a once-illegal (and still sleazy) form of stock manipulation. Over that same period, Microsoft lost nearly $200b on AI ventures that it now admits will not pay off:

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/02/24/microsoft-reiterates-plan-to-invest-80-billion-in-ai-.html

Then there's the layoffs. 2026 saw Microsoft's first-ever voluntary retirement buyout, which served as the overture to a year that saw a 25% headcount cut – 60,000 employees slated for destruction:

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/oct/26/microsoft-buyout-offers-ai-cuts

Ever had a boss who caught you catching your breath and shoved a broom in your hand, barking, "If you have time to lean, you have time to clean?" That goes quintuple for convicted monopolists who bring the global economy to a halt due to a multi-day outage. If you can't manage to keep your servers online, you have no business incinerating tens of billions on stock buybacks, much less hundreds of billions to feed the AI money-furnace. Did Microsoft need the tens of thousands of workers it threw away? Demonstrably so: when they were on the payroll, Microsoft's servers were up. Now they're gone, and so are the servers. It doesn't matter how those workers related to this specific outage: if you can't keep your servers online, you either don't have enough site reliability engineers, or you don't have enough managers to deploy them effectively, or you don't have enough managers to hire the managers and SREs you need.

Q.E.D.

This is all characteristic of the monopolist's pathology. The problem with monopolists is that they have pricing power and market power: the power to foist inferior products on their customers and degraded working conditions on their employees and unfair terms on their suppliers. Microsoft's hundreds of billions in wastage and tens of thousands of layoffs are a massive transfer of value from customers, workers and suppliers to investors. The fact that the company judged (correctly, it seems) that they could make us all eat shit and we'd ask for second helpings is a nice, clean proof of monopoly power.

Here, I think, is a nice, bright-line, administrable test for monopoly power. If your company has a dominant position and if it allocates its surplus capital to its investors and if that precedes a significant degradation of your products, then you have an illegal monopoly and you should be broken up. We don't need to inquire as to whether you have a wicked heart that intentionally set about to create a monopoly, nor do we have to argue endlessly about how many angels can dance on the head of your market definition. If you think you are so powerful that you can fuck up your products and not suffer as a result then you are too big to care, and that is simply too big.

This isn't the only fix we need to antitrust law, but it is a fix that would specifically let us target Big Tech. Microsoft is a living, breathing (limping, gasping) repudiation of the thesis that monopolies are efficient and if we only let them amass endless market share and profits, they will use their "economies of scale" to deliver superior products. It's not that economies of scale don't exist, but for companies to take advantage of these economies of scale, they have to be motivated to expend their capital to do so. The more powerful a company is, the less inclined it will be to apportion capital to workers, suppliers and consumers, and the more it will cheat us all to enrich its shareholders.

We can't afford to let this crisis go to waste. Google was convicted of creating and maintaining a monopoly three times over the past couple years and every single time the judge decided the company should not face any real punishment for that monopoly, on the basis that the monopoly is what lets Google deliver such excellence for us.

Does anyone still think Google is excellent? How about Apple? Google pays Apple an annual bribe of more than $20b to stay out of the search market. Judge Amit Mehta decided to let Google continue paying this bribe to Apple so that Apple would have the capital it needed to deliver excellent products. Apple promptly went on to have a string of catastrophically bad product launches – while throwing away $170b manipulating its share-price with stock buybacks:

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/apple-dodged-a-20-billion-hit-thanks-to-google-antitrust-ruling-163056806.html

Both companies are demonstrably underinvesting in quality in order to divert R&D and product maintenance capital to their shareholders. They are too big to care. In this age of nonstop mergers and acquisitions, we can't afford to make merger approval turn on fact-intensive questions, but we can sure as hell create this administrable, bright-line test for whether a merger should be unwound after the fact. Did your company buy another company and then enshittify both products? Great, now we're breaking you up, and your investors are getting fucked. Maybe next time they'll fire the board when they announce another stupid, anti-competitive merger.

Microsoft is too big in every way. Too big to fail, too big to jail and too big to care. Too big to trust. Too big to rely upon. Too big to foster a corporate culture that cares about reliability, a decent workplace, or product quality. There's a straight line from GW Bush's decision to let Microsoft skate in 2001 and the situation a quarter century later, where Microsoft is a load-bearing piece of the world's most important firms and government agencies, and where this means that Microsoft knows that it can throw away tens of thousands of workers and hundreds of billions of dollars, crash the planet, and wake up tomorrow unscathed, ready to do it all over again.


Hey look at this (permalink)



A shelf of leatherbound history books with a gilt-stamped series title, 'The World's Famous Events.'

Object permanence (permalink)

#20yrsago Canadian copyright minister caught lining pockets https://web.archive.org/web/20061115062027/https://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/1529/135/

#20yrsago Universal Music CEO: iPod owners are thieves https://web.archive.org/web/20061201014046/https://www.billboard.com/bbcom/news/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003380831

#15yrsago OccupyLondon members evicted from St Paul’s memorial services https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/nov/13/occupy-london-asked-leave-st-pauls-services

#15yrsago Berlusconi to neo-fascists: “I’ll be back.” https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/13/berlusconi-hints-return-italy-government

#15yrsago Balancing 3,118 coins on a dime https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmLjO0Wu3ug

#10yrsago People who voted for Trump knew their shot at the elites was fired through the guts of their neighbors https://web.archive.org/web/20210916183118/https://www.newstatesman.com/spotlight/2016/11/on-the-election-of-donald-j-trump-2

#10yrsago Ontario judge dishonours his court and disgraces himself by presiding in a MAKE AMERICA GREAT hat https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/osgoode-hall-professor-ontario-judge-hamilton-trump-hat-1.3848913

#10yrsago 300 million Adultfriendfinder accounts breached https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/13/13615750/412-million-adultfriendfinder-accounts-exposed-breach

#5yrsago How to be safe(r) online https://pluralistic.net/2021/11/13/opsec-soup-to-nuts/#secured

#1yrago For-profit healthcare is the problem, not (just) private equity https://pluralistic.net/2025/11/13/patients-not-customers/#medicine-vs-markets


Upcoming appearances (permalink)

A photo of me onstage, giving a speech, pounding the podium.



A screenshot of me at my desk, doing a livecast.

Recent appearances (permalink)



A grid of my books with Will Stahle covers..

Latest books (permalink)



A cardboard book box with the Macmillan logo.

Upcoming books (permalink)

  • "The Post-American Internet," a geopolitical sequel of sorts to Enshittification, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2027

  • "Unauthorized Bread": a middle-grades graphic novel adapted from my novella about refugees, toasters and DRM, FirstSecond, April 20, 2027

  • "Enshittification, Why Everything Suddenly Got Worse and What to Do About It" (the graphic novel), Firstsecond, 2027

  • "The Memex Method," Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2027



Colophon (permalink)

Today's top sources:

Currently writing:

  • “Once Is Enemy Action,” a science fiction novel about the origins of modern technofascism. Today's words: 561 (36083 total).

  • "The Post-American Internet," a sequel to "Enshittification," about the better world the rest of us get to have now that Trump has torched America. Fourth draft completed. Submitted to editor.

  • A Little Brother short story about DIY insulin PLANNING


This work – excluding any serialized fiction – is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. That means you can use it any way you like, including commercially, provided that you attribute it to me, Cory Doctorow, and include a link to pluralistic.net.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Quotations and images are not included in this license; they are included either under a limitation or exception to copyright, or on the basis of a separate license. Please exercise caution.


How to get Pluralistic:

Blog (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

Pluralistic.net

Newsletter (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://pluralistic.net/plura-list

Mastodon (no ads, tracking, or data-collection):

https://mamot.fr/@pluralistic

Bluesky (no ads, possible tracking and data-collection):

https://bsky.app/profile/doctorow.pluralistic.net

Medium (no ads, paywalled):

https://doctorow.medium.com/

Tumblr (mass-scale, unrestricted, third-party surveillance and advertising):

https://mostlysignssomeportents.tumblr.com/tagged/pluralistic

"When life gives you SARS, you make sarsaparilla" -Joey "Accordion Guy" DeVilla

READ CAREFULLY: By reading this, you agree, on behalf of your employer, to release me from all obligations and waivers arising from any and all NON-NEGOTIATED agreements, licenses, terms-of-service, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap, confidentiality, non-disclosure, non-compete and acceptable use policies ("BOGUS AGREEMENTS") that I have entered into with your employer, its partners, licensors, agents and assigns, in perpetuity, without prejudice to my ongoing rights and privileges. You further represent that you have the authority to release me from any BOGUS AGREEMENTS on behalf of your employer.

ISSN: 3066-764X

10:00 AM

U.S. Supreme Court Deals Final Blow To Corporate Human Rights Accountability [Techdirt]

For the past two decades, the U.S. Supreme Court has been slowly weakening the Alien Tort Statute (ATS), a key human rights law that allows foreign nationals to sue persons or entities in civil court for harms resulting from violations of international law. The court’s recent ruling in Cisco Systems, Inc. v. Doe I dealt the law a final blow, foreclosing—absent new legislation by Congress—any future ability by plaintiffs to use the law to hold technology companies accountable for aiding and abetting human rights abuses. EFF filed multiple amicus briefs in the case, including most recently in the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court Rejected New Causes of Action Under the ATS

The ATS was passed by the very first Congress in 1789 and in just a few words gives U.S. federal courts jurisdiction to hear civil claims brought by foreign nationals against defendants who violated “the law of nations or a treaty of the United States.” There has been a longstanding question about what counts as a valid civil claim under “the law of nations.”

In Sosa v. Alvarez-Machain (2004), the Supreme Court had noted three historical international law claims that the First Congress likely had in mind: violation of safe conducts, infringement of the rights of ambassadors, and piracy, collectively known as the Blackstone Three.

The Sosa court also held that federal courts may recognize other substantive causes of action under the ATS if they reflect international norms that are “specific, universal, and obligatory,” stating that this “door is still ajar subject to vigilant doorkeeping, and thus open to a narrow class of international norms today.”

Thus, the Sosa court recognized that the ATS could be used to bring claims related to historical violations of international law as well as select newer claims reflecting modern concepts of human rights.

In Cisco, the Supreme Court overruled the second Sosa holding. The majority held that the current case, a technology company aiding and abetting torture and other human rights abuses, was beyond the scope of the original three ATS claims and it was not for the court to create new ways of enforcing international law. The court said:

[W]e close the door that Sosa cracked to judicially created ATS liability. We do not disturb Sosa’s holding that the ATS is a jurisdictional statute; nor do we revisit its assumption that causes of action are available for torts corresponding to the Blackstone three. We conclude only that Sosa was overly optimistic in its prediction that there might be a narrow class of cases in which courts may create ATS actions without infringing on the prerogatives of the political branches. In truth, this class is a null set.

What result for this case? Cisco argues that the Ninth Circuit erred in holding that aiding-and-abetting liability exists under the ATS for the torts alleged by the plaintiffs. Cisco is correct. Courts cannot create new rights of action to remedy violations of international law, so there is necessarily no liability for aiding and abetting such violations. Plaintiffs’ ATS claims against Cisco must be dismissed.

Cisco is Off the Hook for Aiding and Abetting Horrific Human Rights Abuses

The Supreme Court’s ending of the plaintiffs’ case against Cisco is hugely disappointing given that the case has been going on since 2011 and the Ninth Circuit in 2023 allowed the case to move forward in an excellent and well-reasoned opinion. The court held, in part:

We conclude that Plaintiffs’ allegations, accepted as true, are sufficient to state a plausible claim that Cisco provided essential technical assistance to the douzheng [violent struggle] of Falun Gong with awareness that the international law violations of torture, arbitrary detention, disappearance, and extrajudicial killing were substantially likely to take place. 

The plaintiffs sued Cisco for the company’s role in building and deploying the “Golden Shield,” also referred to as “The Great Firewall of China”—a vast surveillance system that Cisco began building in the late 1990s and that the company customized to enable the Chinese government to target disfavored minorities, including members of the Falun Gong religion.

The thirteen plaintiffs—Falun Gong practitioners—alleged arrest, detention, and torture, including of themselves and family members, at least one of whom died by beating while being detained. The allegations were horrific: the plaintiffs were placed in forced labor camps, beaten with steel rods, shocked with electric batons, and endured sleep deprivation and violent force-feeding.

Importantly, the plaintiffs also alleged that their private emails, text messages, and other information—intercepted by the Golden Shield—were shown to them and used as part of their torture and forced conversion sessions, which included threats to their family members and others who had communicated with them. 

And now, Cisco is off the hook for all of this.

Congress Must Act to Hold American Tech Companies Accountable for Aiding and Abetting Human Rights Abuses

As we argued in our amicus brief to the Supreme Court, a robust federal statute is necessary given that voluntary and informal mechanisms of corporate human rights accountability are inadequate.

The plaintiffs filed their lawsuit in 2011. The following year, in 2012, Cisco first published its Global Human Rights Policy. Since then, the company has never provided redress to the plaintiffs, despite its currently operative human rights policy stating:

Where we have identified that we have caused or contributed to an adverse human rights impact, we are committed to providing access to and cooperating in remediation for affected individuals, workers, and communities through legitimate processes.

What’s more, the Associated Press conducted an extensive 2025 investigation, which recently won the Pulitzer Prize, further mapping Cisco’s and other American tech companies’ involvement in creating China’s surveillance state over the past three decades. When questioned by the AP reporters, the companies dismissed any notion of human rights obligations and simply “said they adhere to relevant export controls, laws and regulations where they operate.”

In short, Cisco’s commitment to human rights is a fiction.

Given that the U.S. Supreme Court has effectively read the ATS into non-existence, Congress must now step up. While there might be other avenues for redress including under state law, there must also be a comprehensive federal human rights law allowing any plaintiff to hold American companies—especially technology companies—accountable for aiding and abetting human rights abuses, with knowledge or intent that those abuses would occur, and whether the victims suffered those abuses in the U.S. or in foreign countries.

The implications of this gap in U.S. human rights law are significant. As Prof. Harold Koh considered:

[T]he Justices should ask whether affording such immunity in Cisco would implicitly signal to U.S. companies that they could not be held liable for assisting the U.S. government in committing gross violations. Such violations could include constructing a mass surveillance system that may be used to surveil, persecute, retaliate against, and punish real and perceived opponents and constructing systems that autonomously commit war crimes.

American companies should not have a free pass to build out surveillance states (or other technologically sophisticated systems) that not only violate personal privacy or facilitate censorship, but that can also lead to real-world physical violence and even death.

Reposted from the EFF’s Deeplinks Blog.

RSSSiteUpdated
XML About Tagaini Jisho on Tagaini Jisho 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Arch Linux: Releases 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Carlson Calamities 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Debian News 2026-11-17 08:00 AM
XML Debian Security 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML debito.org 2026-11-17 08:00 AM
XML dperkins 2026-11-17 12:00 AM
XML F-Droid - Free and Open Source Android App Repository 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML General Union 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML GIMP 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Japan Bash 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Japan English Teacher Feed 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Kanji of the Day 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Kanji of the Day 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Let's Encrypt 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Marc Jones 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Marjorie's Blog 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML OpenStreetMap Japan 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML OsmAnd Blog 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Popehat 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Ramen Adventures 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Release notes from server 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Seth Godin's Blog on marketing, tribes and respect 2026-11-17 12:00 AM
XML SNA Japan 2026-11-17 12:00 AM
XML Tatoeba Project Blog 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Techdirt 2026-11-17 08:00 AM
XML The Business of Printing Books 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML The Luddite 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML The Popehat Report 2026-11-17 12:00 AM
XML The Status Kuo 2026-11-17 12:00 AM
XML The Stranger 2026-11-17 03:00 AM
XML Tor Project blog 2026-11-17 08:00 AM
XML TorrentFreak 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML what if? 2026-11-17 05:00 AM
XML Wikimedia Commons picture of the day feed 2026-11-12 07:00 PM
XML xkcd.com 2026-11-17 05:00 AM